Forum Thread

Thoughts on the TLC show

justmeagain 499 1,048 December 14, 2010 at 09:44 PM in Chat
Deal
Score
+22
347,462 Views

Thread Details

Last Edited by slayers750 December 14, 2010 at 10:09 PM
Here is my thoughts on the TLC show--this is a post I copied from my NON-coupon--NO DEALS blog.

"UGH. NOT good at all. I have been couponing YEARS before this had become a fad/popular thing to do. It is already getting hard enough–I see no need to broadcast this info across the whole nation. The owners of all these couponing blogs/websites always want to broadcast and get as many people as they can to sign up on their blog. I had a coupon friend online and I told her how I think all this “recruiting” will bring extreme couponing to a screeching halt eventually. The difference between when I started couponing to now is already vastly different. Stores have put policies into place making it more difficult for couponers. For the first time ever since couponing P&G has new wording on their coupons “limit 4 like coupons per customer.” It just really blows because there the more people that get into couponing, the more fraud there is too. I have seen blatant examples of blog owners actually tellling people how to de-code the bar codes so they can get around purchasing what the coupon says to purchase. Our grocery stores head cashier told us about this lady who photocopied a coupon and she made a whole stack of them. At RA they posted that only 5/25 coupon is allowed per customer per month because someone supposedly tampered with their coupon. I could give many more examples. And, not too sound like a bitch but all these newbies that have crawled out of the woodwork—they just make more work for me. Yes, I was a newbie once too–BUT, I took it upon myself to READ the threads, and learn the store policies etc etc. It seems all these dumb newbies want everything spoon fed to them–thinking for themselves I guess is too much to ask. They ask the SAME questions over and over and OVER again–the answers are there—they just need to READ.

I’m sure the blog/website owners and those profiting from broadcasting about extreme couponing are happy to have more money coming in. Some already make huge bucks—enough to constantly offer crazy giveaways. But I feel like they are cutting off their nose despite their face. I just don’t think it is very smart to go and advertise about what used to be a secret underground world of extreme couponing. Yep, as you can see–I’m NOT happy about this TLC show."

On top of all this recruiting--I also think couponing will come to an end as we know it because everything is going digital. I found out the Detroit free press has decided NOT to carry red plum inserts anymore outside their tri county delivery area. When I called red plum and the DFP, I was told they want customers to start printing their own coupons instead of getting inserts.

April 13, 2011, 3:13 am: em Notice:[/COLOR] This thread has been automatically renewed after reaching a post limit. Most of its content has been moved to this thread for reference purposes.

May 6, 2011, 3:13 am: System Notice: This thread has been automatically renewed after reaching a post limit. Most of its content has been moved to this thread for reference purposes.

June 29, 2011, 3:13 am: System Notice: This thread has been automatically renewed after reaching a post limit. Most of its content has been moved to this thread for reference purposes.

Community Wiki

Last Edited by RETSBAR April 24, 2011 at 09:20 AM
TLC's new couponing GAME SHOW features people trying to get the most products for the littlest amount of money. It is not a couponing-instruction show.

http://popwatch.ew.com/2010/12/13/tlc-extreme-couponing-supermarket-sweep/

http://press.discovery.com/us/tlc/programs/extreme-couponing/

Quote from dealznstealz View Post :
Here's the clip of the Extreme Couponing (ABC) describing them as OCD..gambler's...hoader's.
LINK [go.com]

ET Tonight video LINK [zimbio.com]

TLC Added on 1/19 to YouTube
Extreme Couponing- Nathan's Six-Figure Stockpile [youtube.com]
Extreme Couponing- Amanda's Coupon Game Day Plan [youtube.com]
Extreme Couponing- Dumpster Diving for Coupons [youtube.com]

Just remember what ever precedent is set by this show goes out the window with one new coupon policy put in place by your store. The Southeast region for Kroger is already seeing some store coupon policies changed to limit of 2 like coupons over night. I was told this by Kroger Corporate under the discretion of the District Manger's due to "shelf clearing" happening in their stores.

j'aime kirlew's original youtube/target videos:

photobucket

http://s1097.photobucket.com/albu...burg%20MD/

http://s1097.photobucket.com/albu...Bonphotos/

Dailymotion

http://www.dailymotion.com/releva...e%20kirlew

youtube
Quote from alanisrox69 View Post :
both videos are now on youtube:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9AfZh_CrYes
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f014iZzowDc

spread the links!
hotfile
Quote from shuriken View Post :
ok, new links:
download 1 [hotfile.com]
download 2 [hotfile.com]
these won't play in the browser and are in .flv format. you might need to download the codecs (if they aren't on your computer) or i suggest vlc media player [videolan.org] or cnet link [cnet.com]

Links for updates from News reports

4/6 Article by Jill Cataldo
"TLC's Extreme Couponing raising controversy as new season approaches"
http://www.jillcataldo.com/node/16170

4/8 Article by Jill Cataldo
"Was coupon fraud shown on TLC's Extreme Couponing?"
http://www.jillcataldo.com/node/16258

4/14 news report by Sandra Gonzalez with Entertainment Weekly
TLC 'looking into' allegations of coupon fraud on 'Extreme Couponing'
http://insidetv.ew.com/2011/04/14...couponing/
Thanks to skincarekathy for posting the link

4/15 Article on the Consumerist By Laura Northrup
Extreme Couponing: Fraud Edition
http://consumerist.com/2011/04/me...olice.html
Thanks Jill Cataldo for posting the link

4/15 Kate Torgovnick from The Frisky
An "Extreme Couponing" Scandal
http://www.thefrisky.com/post/246...g-scandal/

4/15/11 Article NY Post
Xtreme Coupon Scam?
http://www.nypost.com/p/entertain...&FEEDNAME=

4/16/11 Article Oklahoma City Examiner
Did Jaime Kirlew commit fraud on 'Extreme Couponing?' You be the judge!
http://www.examiner.com/tv-in-okl...-the-judge

4/24 article in Baltimore Sun
http://www.baltimoresun.com/enter...feedburner
Thanks SlickCate for posting the link


This post can be edited by most users to provide up-to-date information about developments of this thread based on user responses, and user findings. Feel free to add, change or remove information shown here as it becomes available. This includes new coupons, rebates, ideas, thread summary, and similar items.

Publix may change its coupon policy thanks SUCHaDEAL Discussion Thread

Extreme couponing! How to get $1,100 of merchandise for $40 [msn.com] Today Show

Discounting coupon rules might get you in trouble [chicagotribune.com]

Extreme Couponing: Showcase for Frugal Geniuses or Crazed Hoarders? [nymag.com]

'Extreme Couponing' gone too far? Expert offers tips on how to save big without obsessing [nydailynews.com]




This post can be edited by most users to provide up-to-date information about developments of this thread based on user responses, and user findings. Feel free to add, change or remove information shown here as it becomes available. This includes new coupons, rebates, ideas, thread summary, and similar items.

Once a Thread Wiki is added to a thread, "Create Wiki" button will disappear. If you would like to learn more about Thread Wiki feature, click here.

1,358 Comments

85 86 87 88 89

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

#1291
Quote from wanderingwillow View Post :
Won't be watching. EC is a detriment to the couponing way of life, anyone who appears on it is an idiot.
+1, won't give them any views, show is terrible. Maybe if they ran another BF special, but that's it. The show is a joke.
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
Joined Jan 2011
Just Keep Swimming
7,666 Posts
11,705 Reputation
#1292
I don't have cable .. but I sure love WBBell's recaps. Gotta make sure to go to the bathroom before I start reading LMAO
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
Joined Jun 2009
Private Investigator
612 Posts
2,651 Reputation
#1293
No way in HELL I would ever go on that show! I don't care what they offered....TLC doesn't have enough money to make an a$$ out of me.....shake headshake headshake head
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
Watch your thoughts, for they become words. Watch your words, for they become actions. Watch your actions, for they become habits. Watch your habits, for they become character. Watch your character, for it becomes your destiny. ~ Unknown
#1294
Quote from CzarCzar View Post :
I suspect people won't be too happy with me. I violated store policy, manufacturer policy & used coupons that I didn't know were fake. The goal for my episode was $500 cash back at WalMart. Did I achieve my goal?! Find out December 10th.
WalMart? That one will be a first on EC..Popcorn
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
Thanks to BMR and BeeReel making me bold!
Joined Dec 2004
L10: Grand Master
22,029 Posts
11,990 Reputation
#1295
Quote from sdNewby View Post :
I don't have cable .. but I sure love WBBell's recaps. Gotta make sure to go to the bathroom before I start reading LMAO
wear tena. Big Grin

Quote from ladycat View Post :
LOL I would watch that episode!! LMAO
laugh out loud
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
Last edited by shuriken November 15, 2012 at 06:24 PM
Joined Sep 2009
I pay in barcodes
2,136 Posts
4,419 Reputation
#1296
Purvatory is a funny word.

And TLC & EC sux
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
Joined Feb 2005
L10: Grand Master
6,042 Posts
12,606 Reputation
#1297
Well, I could have only hoped that this show was gone for good, but no! Despite no publicity, not even a press release from TLC announcing the new season, here is our favorite show back to torture us with more nonsense. What fake drama awaits us? What kinds of crazy things wil people do? What kinds of questionable coupons will be used? What strange new cliches will we have this season? I can only imagine. Let's jump right in! And today we have an Extreme Disclaimer, a Fabulously Pretty Stockpile, Severe Anxiety, going to Freak Out, Fun to be Frugal, a "little bit OCD", lol, a problem, going to cry, PIGGLY WIGGLY, all in the season kickoff tonight …. and off we go!

We open on a couple chatting about how they are going to set up their camera and tripod, all in hopes of taking the perfect portrait. And are they photographing their wonderful offspring, or perhaps themselves? No, you silly fools, they are making a portrait of their Extreme Stack of Stuff! Here is Rudy, from Georgia, and in her world it is Fun to be Frugal. And here is Rudy with her husband Chase, tossing things around at the Piggly Wiggly. We learn that Rudy wants to memorialize every shopping trip, so we go through the above-outlined portrait procedure after EVERY TRIP. Umm.. Rudy tells us that most people have photo albums of their family vacations, or even of just their family, but Rudy has photo albums full of her stockpile shots. Oh, wait, now I see that these are not just photos, she has actually scrapbooked these photos into like works of art. Wow. And now we see the Fabulously Pretty stockpile. Chase comments that he started wondering if Rudy might be a little crazy, when she brought home 300 dog collars, but they don't have a dog. Rudy then tells us that she buys certain items just because she likes how they look in the stockpile, and she uses them to fill in the gaps. Rudy must have precisely 35 containers of Gain Dish Detergent in the stockpile because that everything must be in place and lined up. Moving on, Chase and Rudy are going to renew their vows, and Rudy plans to buy all the reception food for $20. She has 300 BBQ sauce coupons, and so she plans to give those out as reception gifts. Break already!

After an Extremely long commercial break (4 minutes!), it occurs to me that we haven't heard from Mr. Narrator thus yet. I hope they didn't get rid of him, that would be a shame, and we would also have no one available to tell us the latest findings from the Extreme Couponing Research Department. Did you know that 47% of all households get BBQ sauce for free after coupon at least once a year? That's because I just made that up!! Sorry, I was having factoid withdrawal and I had to do something. Budget cuts affect everything, y'know. But did you like how I tied that into the theme? Yeah, I am good. Anyhoo, back to Chase and Rudy, and we're pulling up to the Piggly Wiggly, where we are hoping to get $700 worth of stuff for $20. We go to the BBQ sauce shelf, where they put about 80 into the basket, but then they find another place where cases are stacked up. Rudy will only get the cases, because she likes things organized, stacked up, and she orders Chase to put the 80 back on the shelf. Chase comments that he thinks Rudy might be a little bit OCD. Really? Actually, Chase has been inserting all of these wry little comments into this whole affair which are kinda funny, so at least he is a good sport about the fact that his wife is completely nutty. Now, we are buying the ever popular Yak and Cheese, and Chase asks Rudy if she is buying these solely to look good in her stockpile. To my amazement, Rudy says YES, she actually buys items of different colors and shapes, to make the stockpile look good. Instead of debating this, Chase tells the camera what may be the best line ever - "In our house, you've got to know your role, and shut your hole". LOL!! Free Chase!

Now it's time to check out, and Rudy tells the poor Piggly Wiggly lady that she is doing 87 transactions (!!) and I am so not even going to try to summarize this. Lots of beeping, Scanning is Boring, Random Disinterested People,. The Piggly Wiggly lady tells us in this awesome Suthern Accent that Rudy's totalk was $776 and she spent only $19.20. Random clapping from some random people, who were probably paid off in BBQ sauce. And now we're at the reception, all is lovely, and Rudy thinks it was a big hit.

We're back, and here is Gia, who says she is the Long Island Coupon Queen. She says that without coupons, she'd probably die. She spends over 50 hours a week on couponing. Gia's mom Maria thinks it might be a "little obsession". Off we go to the beach, where Gia's family dig a sort of protective bunker in the sand, to protect the coupons from the wind. Gia sits in the bunker and clips coupons while her family has fun in the water. Sounds great to me! We see her stockpile room, and every time she enters, she has a sigh of relief. Here come some more people into the house, and Gia says her family is the biggest and loudest you'll ever meet. They have a weekly dinner, which is nice, and Gia is hosting the dinner tonight. She aims to prove that she can do this dinner for 25% of what they normally spend. Gia's brother has helpfully offered to notify Gia whether or not her dinner "sucks". Thanks, bro! So now Gia is bribing her mother with candy bars, if she will help with the 6 hour shopping tip. Maria agrees, of course, who wouldn't? So now we are pulling up to "Key Food", and right away we have some kind of kooky music, then Gia says that shopping with mom is like a "3-ring circus". And Maria has a can of something perched on her head, which she nods right into the basket! And another break!

Gia's going to make Chicken Parm, and grabs a bunch of chicken. Next we're going to buy 40 2-liters of soda, and Gia is actually making her poor mom shove this cart full of sodas around the store. Now Gia is going to buy 10 packs of strawberries at $2.00, for which she has a mysterious coupon for $5.00 off, and she says the overage will pay for the chicken. Now it's "The Moment of Truth", aka the checkout. Scanning is Boring™, annoying running commentary by Gia, and she warns us that if her total is even one CENT over $100, she is going to freak out. She will FREAK OUT, I say! More annoying commentary from Gia, unhelpful commentary from mom, lol, and her final total is $758. And Do You Have Any Coupons Today?™, and scanning is still boring, and Gia says she wanted to cry as soon as she saw the last coupon scan! Her total was $118, and Gia says that even though she saved over $600 on this stuff, she feels like she failed, and again with the wanting to cry, and a very morose trip out to the car. THen, after loading the bagged items into her car, Gia discovers $28 in unredeemed coupons that had apparently fallen out of the binder. Gia mopes even more at this discovery, I'm wondering why doesn't she just take 'em in the store and do a return/rebuy, especially since the coupons were for cat food, but we don't do that. Now it's dinnertime, where Helpful Brother loves the sauce, and he's amazed that Gia paid only $118 for all the stuff. Gia says that couponing has given her peace of mind and allowed them to get out of debt. And it all sounds lovely to me. heart
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
woot

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Joined Dec 2004
L10: Grand Master
22,029 Posts
11,990 Reputation
#1298
we need to hire samuel l. jackson to read your recaps. Big Grin
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
Joined Dec 2004
L10: Grand Master
22,029 Posts
11,990 Reputation
#1299
Quote from WBBell View Post :
Next we're going to buy 40 2-liters of soda, and Gia is actually making her poor mom shove this cart full of sodas around the store.
Scratchchin where's the common sense there? just get it last.
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
Joined Jan 2011
Just Keep Swimming
7,666 Posts
11,705 Reputation
#1300
Whee
heart you WBBell
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
#1301
According to this story they know that the people on the show are using fake coupons and they don't care to comment about it.

http://www.kpho.com/story/2011284...pular-show
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
#1302
Quote from WBBell View Post :
Well, I could have only hoped that this show was gone for good, but no!
Ah, how I love a good WBBell EC recap.
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
#1303
Quote from AhorrarDinero View Post :
According to this story they know that the people on the show are using fake coupons and they don't care to comment about it.

http://www.kpho.com/story/2011284...pular-show
Wasn't this in the Extreme Couponing: All-Stars??
Quote :
Last spring, in Vegas, a shopper loaded up 200 bottles of Tide laundry detergent. Procter and Gamble said it was another fake.
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
#1304
Quote from AhorrarDinero View Post :
According to this story they know that the people on the show are using fake coupons and they don't care to comment about it.

http://www.kpho.com/story/20112842/az-counterfeit-coupon-operation-may-have-tie-to-popular-show
Oh gosh.. Bud Miller getting interviewed again.. I am sure he is in heaven with all the drama... So, P&G and Georgia Pacific have both confirmed that the Quilted Northern coupons and Tide coupons were fraudulent.. I wonder if they will go after the show and/or participants who committed fraud while being filmed??

Quote from PresarioXp View Post :
Wasn't this in the Extreme Couponing: All-Stars??
Quote :
Last spring, in Vegas, a shopper loaded up 200 bottles of Tide laundry detergent. Procter and Gamble said it was another fake.
Hmmmmm, not sure if it was the All Stars, but I did see part of that episode... and the fake Tide were allegedly copies of real Tide coupons which had been distributed to people who purchased washing machines and such from a major retailer.. I forgot which one.. I can NOT believe that someone would allow themselves to be filmed while doing that.. but people do CRAZY things these days, especially for 15 minutes of fame... Crazy
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
heart
#1305
Quote from Foladar View Post :
+1, won't give them any views, show is terrible. Maybe if they ran another BF special, but that's it. The show is a joke.
I truly don't understand why anyone would be on this show.
They always come across as either hoarders, nutjobs, coupon abusers or just plain selfish people (or a combination of all). Because the show is a boring rehash (I gather this info from WBBell's recaps,which I am sure are far more entertaining than the show--haven't seen it since the WUC guy was on) the producers up the ante for people to have a nonsense backstory & they resort to coupon fraud to make the savings more dramatic (and unbelievable).
To the best of my knowledge, no one gets paid for an appearance.The only way to make $ is by having a blog people go to after the appearance (see WUC guy), but those blogs are now a dime a dozen of rehashed deals & sh*t copied & pasted.
At the very least, people on the show give themselves more compitition in the store & from resellers & give all people who use coupons more aggravation & scruitiny. Also, the resellers may find themselves shining a spotlight on their lack of taxes paid. I have no idea what is to be gained from appearing; if they are just paid in ego, they will find it's a lousy ROI. My two cents.
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
Page 87 of 91
85 86 87 88 89
Join the Conversation
Add a Comment
 
Copyright 1999 - 2016. Slickdeals, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Copyright / Infringement Policy  •  Privacy Policy  •  Terms of Service  •  Acceptable Use Policy (Rules)  •  Interest-Based Ads
Link Copied to Clipboard