|
|||||||
|
Performance + Cost Analysis: The best SD Card / MicroSD for you!
Full Size SD Card discussion goes here (See next post (#2) for MicroSD cards)SD Cards can be Regular SD (1MB-4GB), SDHC (4GB to 32GB) and SDXC (64GB and up) --------- Introduction: There are a lot of SD Cards on the market nowadays. How do you know which one to pick? In the end, what really matters is what's the fastest for your use. Whether you have specific or general uses, it's all up to you to decide. Obviously speed comes at a cost of $$$. Maybe you don't want the fastest, but certainly not the cheapest, so I'll have a "best bang for buck" section. -------- Summary: If you don't want to read anymore, just get the SanDisk Extreme 45MB/s or any decent UHS-I card that has U1 Speed Class 1 -------- In depth: First we'll go over speeds, bus types/connections, and card readers For SD Spec 2.0 speeds, we have Class 2, 4, 6 and 10 - each one of these represents the minimum sequential MB/s in write speed that the card will perform - note that if you get a higher performance, it is an added bonus, but it is not something that you should expect all the time). I read how someone posted that they expected a a Class 6 to do 12MB/s, Class 10 to do 20MB/s, etc... this is totally wrong. - if you want a fast card (that's faster than the rated Class series), you should get a card that has a manufacturer guarantee of a minimum MB/s rating. SD Spec 3.0 introduces UHS-I Bus and UHS-I Class ratings - the bus allows the card to perform @ a higher overall speed, denoted by an I on the card - the UHS-I Speed Class 1 has a rating of a performance of "something close to" 50MB/s (either read or write). It is denoted by having a 1 inside a U on the card. - UHS-I Speed Class 2 is around 100MB/s - SD Spec 3.0 is backwards compatible with SD Spec 2.0, and will have a 2.0 Class rating to go long with it. ---------- Card Readers and Ports Most people will use SD Cards with USB 2.0 Card Readers and USB 2.0 ports. Even though the USB 2.0 Spec is rated at 480mbit/s (that's 60MB/s), there is a lot of overhead in that goes with SD cards and readers (power, QoS, etc..) which typically brings down typical transfer speeds that max out @ around 20MB/s on average (depending on card reader). I had a card reader that maxed @ 22MB/s, and another built-in one from a laptop that did 10MB/s max! People with USB 3.0 Card Readers and USB 3.0 ports can enjoy a nice speed boost if using an SD Spec 3.0 UHS-I card. They will also see (generally) a slight speed increase (around 5-10%) if using an SD Spec 2.0 card in a USB 3.0 card reader (whether using a USB 2.0 or 3.0 port). --------- UHS-I (SD Spec 3.0) vs. Class 10 (SD Spec 2.0) So a lot of people ask, "I don't have a device that can get those high UHS-I speeds, so I wouldn't bother with them anyway. I'll just get the cheapest/fastest Class 10". Not all Class 10 cards are made the same. Remember that they only need to do a minimum sequential write of 10MB/s to meet that specification. Also, I've never seen any regular SD Spec 2.0 Class 10 cards that are just as fast as a SD Spec 3.0 UHS-I card that's working in SD Spec 2.0 Class 10 mode Example: A popular card, the Transcend 32GB Class 10 gets around 20MB/s read and 16MB/s write. - This is whether it's in a USB 2.0 or USB 3.0 reader, or USB 2.0 or 3.0 port. However, the SanDisk Extreme 45MB/s: - In a USB 2.0 card reader in USB 2.0 port, will get 20MB/s read and 20MB/s write - In a USB 2.0 card reader in USB 3.0 port, will get 20MB/s read and 20MB/s write - In a USB 3.0 card reader in USB 2.0 port, will get 36MB/s read and 30MB/s write - In a USB 3.0 card reader in USB 3.0 port, will get 45MB/s read and 43MB/s write Note that both the Transcend and SanDisk Extreme are both rated Class 10 (a minimum of 10MB/s sequential write). They only need to adhere to that standard, and anything "extra" is a bonus. However, in this case, SanDisk is throwing in their own manufacturer guarantee of a minimum of 45MB/s . It gets 45MB/s read and 43MB/s write, so it matches up pretty well. -------- Cost/Performance Analysis: Obviously the SanDisk Extreme 45MB/s is a fast card. Probably the best 32GB card you can get for $35. The question is, do you need it? How much are you willing to pay for that speed? Regular Class 10 cards have gone on sale for "much" lower (it depends what your definition of "much" is). Example 1: The 32GB Patriot EP SDHC rivals the performance of the Extreme 45MB/s Series: - In a USB 2.0 card reader in USB 2.0 port, will get 20MB/s read and 20MB/s write - In a USB 2.0 card reader in USB 3.0 port, will get 20MB/s read and 20MB/s write - In a USB 3.0 card reader in USB 2.0 port, will get 36MB/s read and 30MB/s write - In a USB 3.0 card reader in USB 3.0 port, will get 54MB/s read and 38MB/s write With a slightly slower write (38MB/s vs 43MB/s) but faster read (54MB/s vs 45MB/s) it may be a good compromise for some. And naturally, it will blow away any regular Class 10 card. At $5 less ($30), I'd say its worth it ![]() Example 2: SanDisk Ultra 30MB/s Class 10: - In a USB 2.0 card reader in USB 2.0 port, will get 20MB/s read and 14MB/s write - In a USB 2.0 card reader in USB 3.0 port, will get 20MB/s read and 14MB/s write - In a USB 3.0 card reader in USB 2.0 port, will get 36MB/s read and 14MB/s write - In a USB 3.0 card reader in USB 3.0 port, will get 40MB/s read and 14MB/s write A new SanDisk card, but with "average" write speeds. Note that SanDisk says "up to 30MB/s read* -- write speeds may be lower, and it is! Unlike the Extreme Series, this Ultra Series has a huge difference between read and write speed. You can see here also that USB 2.0 is a bottleneck for read speeds. There's no performance increase in write speed regardless of card reader/port. You can tell that it's not even going to get any higher since it doesn't even go anywhere near the USB 2.0 write limitation. However this card is still much faster than some other lower quality Class 10's. And you get that extra read speed ![]() But for $25, can you really complain? Well, do you "need" that extra write speed? The decision is yours! Example 3: Philips 32GB Class 10: - In a USB 2.0 card reader in USB 2.0 port, will get 20MB/s read and 12MB/s write Not even going to bother trying to test this card in USB 3.0 card reader or USB 3.0 port But for $22, can you really complain? Well, do you "need" that extra write speed? The decision is yours! Historical Pricing (meaning, these cards have been as low as): - 32GB SanDisk Extreme 45MB/s SDHC has been $35 (that's ~$1.09/GB) - 32GB Patriot EP Series ----------- SDHC has been $25 (that's ~$0.94/GB) - 32GB SanDisk Ultra 30MB/s ---- SDHC has been $25 (that's ~$0.78/GB) - 32GB Philips --------------------------- SDHC has been $22 (that's ~$0.69/GB) ----- Non-recommended cards Patriot LX - terrible/unreliable cards Sony 32GB SDHC - terrible performance - is Class 10, but barely gets 10MB/s write! <-- not sufficient enough to record 1080p video on Canon T2i / T3i / 60D / 5DM3 / 7D* / 5DM2* -- * requires SD->CF adapter to be edited ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
Last edited by AkumaX; 11-24-2012 at 12:09 PM.. |
| 05-11-2012, 04:13 PM | |
|
|
|
MicroSD Cards!
MicroSD Cards can be Regular MicroSD (1MB-4GB), MicroSDHC (4GB to 32GB) and MicroSDXC (64GB and up) ----- Note that here it is trickier to talk about MicroSD. In SD cards, you really only need the fastest card in general. However, for MicroSD, it has to be broken down into 2 categories: sequential write, and Random 4K write. In this case, there are a lot of card that have great sequential write, but terrible Random 4K write. Few cards have both great sequential write, and great Random 4K write Summary: If you don't want to read anymore, just get the Samsung High Speed (non-Plus) Class 10 Series, or the SanDisk Mobile Ultra UHS-I Class 6 Series Additional Info: When you use a microSD/SDHC/SDXC card in an android device, there are 2 factors that you have to consider: - sequential write - random 4k write Sequential write is obvious (Class 4 = minimum 4MB/s sequential write, Class 6/10 = etc..). Copy large files to the card is where you'll see your limitation However, there is random 4k write. If you plan on running anything off the SD (app storage, app cache, etc..) then this is very, very important. For MicroSD cards: - most Class 4, 1/2 of the Class 6 cards, and very few Class 10 cards will do random 4k write at around ~1.5MB/s. it sounds slow, but its good enough for most applications - most Class 10 cards will have a random 4k write of about ~0.01MB/s (that is not a typo). That means that most Class 4 micro cards are theoretically 150x faster than most Class 10 micro cards. There is a new breed of high speed Class 6/Class 10 micro cards that have great sequential write ( > 10MB/s) AND great random4k write (> 1.5MB/s) So far the only cards that I would personally recommend: - the Samsung High Speed Class 10 32GB MicroSDHC, which gets 13MB/s sequential write and 1.5MB/s random 4k write (note, do NOT GET THE PLUS VERSION). The Plus version has 0.01MB/s random 4k write, but around 16MB/s sequential write. - the SanDisk Mobile Ultra Class 6 30MB/s Series (32GB MicroSDHC or 64GB MicroSDHC). Even though its only Class 6, it can routinely get around 9.5MB/s sequential write, and 1.5MB/s random 4k write. Hope this helps! to be edited Last edited by AkumaX; 05-20-2012 at 07:54 PM.. |
|
test failed
houston we have a problem |
|
for those that hate spelling mistakes www.walmarts.com
![]() save money by checking your insurance every 2 years (and not every 20) |
|
Mind editing out your ridiculously long post?p.s. sdcard.org has some very interesting reading material: https://www.sdcard.org/consumers/cards |
|
|
The OP is nice but where are the sources? There are tons of misinformation about flash memory on the internet, how do I know this is not just one of those?
Oh and to who ever copied the entire wiki article, you fail. Vague questions receive vague answers . . . . . .
|
|
Why the hell would you copy and paste and entire wiki article..
~~~~~~~~~~~ Check out my Youtube [youtube.com] ~~~~~~~~~~~
~~ Corsair Carbide 500R | ASUS Maximus IV Gene-Z | Intel i5-2500k 4.7GHz [canardpc.com] | Cooler Master Hyper 212 | 2x MSI GTX 460 Hawks in SLI | 4x4GB G.Skill Ripjaws X 1600MHz | Seasonic X650 PSU | Corsair Force 3 120GB SSD 2TB HDD 1x750GB HDD 1x640GB HDD| Saitek Eclipse II | Logitech MX-518 | ASUS VS247H-P 23.6" Monitor x2 | Windows 7 Pro 64-bit~~ XBox Live Gametag - Reflection X13 Steam - jhu' X13_Y [steamcommunity.com] |
|
You can still open that long post but I filtered it for now so that it doesn't take up so much room in here. boltman2007 if you want to have it unfiltered and just edit it down a bit PM me and let me know.
'Be kinder than necessary, for everyone you meet is fighting some kind of battle.'
SD FAQ Megathread - Very helpful |
|
![]() As far as sources, its my own personal testing after many months (years?) of working with High Quality (and many, many, Low Quality SD cards). Naturally, I am only 1 case scenario. I have a (small) variety of equipment, so I am depending on users to either a) backup or b) refute my claims. I have available to me 1 x Asus Z68 and 1 x Gigabyte Z68 motherboard with USB 3.0 ports. I also only have 1 USB 3.0 card reader (Rosewill from newegg), but I am working on getting more. I have quite a few USB 2.0 card readers, as well as built-in readers from laptops and desktops. Here are some examples where I refer to some benchmarks that I personally tested: http://slickdeals.net/forums/show...ostcount=5 http://slickdeals.net/forums/show...stcount=12 http://slickdeals.net/forums/show...stcount=12 Let me know if you have any requests/questions/inquiries on any remarks
|
||
|
I have degrees in both animal behaviorism and psychology and have come to the conclusion that animals make a hell of a lot more sense than people.
![]() |
|
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| please help with SD cards | theresamax | Tech Support | 4 | 12-15-2011 10:56 AM |
| Best MicroSD for android 2.3 (aka EVO-IC) | pistoncup | Tech Support | 4 | 08-15-2011 01:29 PM |
| using SD card on 2.5" IDE adapter as an SSD, how long would it last? | atlaswing | Tech Support | 9 | 06-27-2011 02:56 PM |
| Good sd card for kodac playsport | AWILLIAMS64 | Tech Support | 2 | 05-02-2011 07:07 AM |
| Best CPU to OC Bang for your Buck! | DrClaw | Tech Support | 29 | 11-19-2010 11:04 PM |