Need Reviews on Costco: Emerald Home Furnishings Canby 7-piece Modular Sectional

Quote from LukesMama : I am about to pull the trigger on this [costcoconnection.com] sectional at Costco (Canby Modular bottom left) and was hoping that I could get honest reviews from anybody who owns it before I purchase. I have a couple questions: Does it have connectors of some kind to hold the separate pieces together? Do the back cushions get flattened easily? Do the cushions removable, and/or do they unzip? I would appreciate any feedback. I almost bought a different style from Costco last year, but due to some reviews, I decided against it. So I am back here again to see if it is worth it. TIA

The fabric is great, but you need to get someone to come out and put Guardsman protection on it. My parents have this set, and didn't have Guardsman protection the first year, and it made the couch look old. If you would sit on the cushion wearing dark clothes, the fabric of the cushion would get these little pile pieces of fabric/fuzz that would be dark black or navy blue in color and they would stick to the cushions. With the Guardsman, you can spill just about anything on it, like ketchup and it wipes clean with a dry paper towel.

There is nothing to hold the separate pieces together, I would recommend that you purchase attachment clips and rubber pads to put underneath the feet, as the pieces will slide around if you don't have it up against a wall. I have a friend who said her set came with connectors, though my parents set didn't, so maybe it's something the manufacturer has changed recently?

The material is soft, and comfortable to sit on. However, the cushions flatten down fast. Within two to three days, the cushions look like they need ironed and it looks worn out almost immediately after you start using it. The back cushions also flatten out in the same manner if you are constantly leaning against them. The cushions don't bounce back when you stand up, so they always look flattened.

It's huge to move around and to get home in the first place if you don't have it delivered. It takes 2 trips in a large pickup truck, and barely fits inside of the the average size rental moving truck.

When the cushions sink in, it makes the whole couch look uneven, like there are rolling hills going throughout your couch. Sort of reminds me of the ripples in those Astro Jumps at children's parties.

I don't recommend it for larger people, my mom is 250 and the piece that she sits on gave out (literally cracked the wood in the frame) in less than 3 months and it was not returnable at that point, and because it was due to her weight rather than the craftsmanship on the unit itself the warranty was no help.

All in all, the set lasted 11 months and was complete trash at that time. The ottoman remains, but that's the only piece still in tact, probably because the only thing that sits on it is a blanket.

Quote from livinglife : The fabric is great, but you need to get someone to come out and put Guardsman protection on it. My parents have this set, and didn't have Guardsman protection the first year, and it made the couch look old. If you would sit on the cushion wearing dark clothes, the fabric of the cushion would get these little pile pieces of fabric/fuzz that would be dark black or navy blue in color and they would stick to the cushions. With the Guardsman, you can spill just about anything on it, like ketchup and it wipes clean with a dry paper towel. There is nothing to hold the separate pieces together, I would recommend that you purchase attachment clips and rubber pads to put underneath the feet, as the pieces will slide around if you don't have it up against a wall. I have a friend who said her set came with connectors, though my parents set didn't, so maybe it's something the manufacturer has changed recently? The material is soft, and comfortable to sit on. However, the cushions flatten down fast. Within two to three days, the cushions look like they need ironed and it looks worn out almost immediately after you start using it. The back cushions also flatten out in the same manner if you are constantly leaning against them. The cushions don't bounce back when you stand up, so they always look flattened. It's huge to move around and to get home in the first place if you don't have it delivered. It takes 2 trips in a large pickup truck, and barely fits inside of the the average size rental moving truck. When the cushions sink in, it makes the whole couch look uneven, like there are rolling hills going throughout your couch. Sort of reminds me of the ripples in those Astro Jumps at children's parties. I don't recommend it for larger people, my mom is 250 and the piece that she sits on gave out (literally cracked the wood in the frame) in less than 3 months and it was not returnable at that point, and because it was due to her weight rather than the craftsmanship on the unit itself the warranty was no help. All in all, the set lasted 11 months and was complete trash at that time. The ottoman remains, but that's the only piece still in tact, probably because the only thing that sits on it is a blanket.

Thanks so much for the review. I had already decided to purchase it, and got it on Monday. I can say so far (albeit it's brand new) I am pleased. My set does have connectors, so that is a good thing. I can see how the back cushions are going to not hold up well already. I have been sitting on one section mostly, and it is getting flattened out. However, I did notice just yesterday that on the underside of the back cushions, there are zippers, so you will be able to replace the stuffing or foam or whatever is in there when they get worn. I love that every piece is movable, and although I have a small apartment, the living room is long and this does not eat up a lot of space.

All in all, I feel that for what I paid (and I shopped around a lot) I feel it was a good deal, although time will tell. I will definitely check into getting the fabric protected though -- with a 9-year-old son, accidents are inevitable

Thanks again for the review. Also, though I am surprised that Costco wouldn't allow a refund after only 4 months. I believe they stand behind their merchandise longer than that. I would check again if your parents are not happy with the quality

Quote from LukesMama : Thanks so much for the review. I had already decided to purchase it, and got it on Monday. I can say so far (albeit it's brand new) I am pleased. My set does have connectors, so that is a good thing. I can see how the back cushions are going to not hold up well already. I have been sitting on one section mostly, and it is getting flattened out. However, I did notice just yesterday that on the underside of the back cushions, there are zippers, so you will be able to replace the stuffing or foam or whatever is in there when they get worn. I love that every piece is movable, and although I have a small apartment, the living room is long and this does not eat up a lot of space. All in all, I feel that for what I paid (and I shopped around a lot) I feel it was a good deal, although time will tell. I will definitely check into getting the fabric protected though -- with a 9-year-old son, accidents are inevitable Thanks again for the review. Also, though I am surprised that Costco wouldn't allow a refund after only 4 months. I believe they stand behind their merchandise longer than that. I would check again if your parents are not happy with the quality

The couch was already trashed, we couldn't even give it away on Craigslist. It was our first and last Costco couch purchase

Quote from livinglife : The couch was already trashed, we couldn't even give it away on Craigslist. It was our first and last Costco couch purchase

No disrespect, but it doesn't seem to be an issue with Costco or the sofa, but rather the weight as you stated. The manufacturer offers a warranty and Costco stands behind what they sell - moreso than if you purchased it at some other furniture retailer. I can tell you without a doubt that if my sofa is deemed trashed after 3-4 months that I will be getting a new sofa and I won't be paying for it. I hope your family was able to find something that they were happy with

Quote from LukesMama : I have been sitting on one section mostly, and it is getting flattened out. However, I did notice just yesterday that on the underside of the back cushions, there are zippers, so you will be able to replace the stuffing or foam or whatever is in there when they get worn.

It gets flattened that quickly??? I am also considering this, but if sagging is a problem in just a few days....I can't image what it will become in 5 years....

Just sat around on one today at a Costco.. didn't look flat to me, I'd assume that many people have sat on this with various weights. Was very comfortable and loved the price, didn't notice any flat cushions..I'm not too worried about the aesthetics of the flat cushions, just wondering if it would feel rounded, or stiff after a while..they should just use visco (memory) foam for this... It's between this one or a sectional that has individual pieces at easy life...

http://www.easylifefurniture.com/...bA10%2bA90

You don't have to buy all the pieces in that set, as they are sold separately, 149 for the ottoman, 199 for the armless chair section and 229 (if i remember correctly) for the corner pieces...each section comes with 2 very large pillows and the corners come with a small accent pillow as well. Quality actually seems better than the Costco modular, and one plus is that the pillows are high enough that it gives you some neck/head support whereas the canby one doesn't have any neck/head support.

Good point on the return policy though.. will be taking the girl friend to see tomorrow, will come down to a mixture of practicality/aesthetics... also have 2 cats, so I gotta' figure out which one is less prone to threads being pulled out.

Quote from LukesMama : Thanks so much for the review. I had already decided to purchase it, and got it on Monday. I can say so far (albeit it's brand new) I am pleased. My set does have connectors, so that is a good thing. I can see how the back cushions are going to not hold up well already. I have been sitting on one section mostly, and it is getting flattened out. However, I did notice just yesterday that on the underside of the back cushions, there are zippers, so you will be able to replace the stuffing or foam or whatever is in there when they get worn. I love that every piece is movable, and although I have a small apartment, the living room is long and this does not eat up a lot of space. All in all, I feel that for what I paid (and I shopped around a lot) I feel it was a good deal, although time will tell. I will definitely check into getting the fabric protected though -- with a 9-year-old son, accidents are inevitable Thanks again for the review. Also, though I am surprised that Costco wouldn't allow a refund after only 4 months. I believe they stand behind their merchandise longer than that. I would check again if your parents are not happy with the quality

LukesMama,

I am looking at buying this couch as well. Is it still holding up to your expectations? And are you still happy with it overall.

Thank you

Quote from Syndicate8 : Just sat around on one today at a Costco.. didn't look flat to me, I'd assume that many people have sat on this with various weights. Was very comfortable and loved the price, didn't notice any flat cushions..I'm not too worried about the aesthetics of the flat cushions, just wondering if it would feel rounded, or stiff after a while..they should just use visco (memory) foam for this... It's between this one or a sectional that has individual pieces at easy life... http://www.easylifefurniture.com/...bA10%2bA90 You don't have to buy all the pieces in that set, as they are sold separately, 149 for the ottoman, 199 for the armless chair section and 229 (if i remember correctly) for the corner pieces...each section comes with 2 very large pillows and the corners come with a small accent pillow as well. Quality actually seems better than the Costco modular, and one plus is that the pillows are high enough that it gives you some neck/head support whereas the canby one doesn't have any neck/head support. Good point on the return policy though.. will be taking the girl friend to see tomorrow, will come down to a mixture of practicality/aesthetics... also have 2 cats, so I gotta' figure out which one is less prone to threads being pulled out.

Quote from puttputts : LukesMama, I am looking at buying this couch as well. Is it still holding up to your expectations? And are you still happy with it overall. Thank you

I am absolutely loving it. I've become a maniac about moving the pieces around to change the look of the room. I haven't even hooked any of them together yet. It's very nice, comfortable, and does not overwhelm my small living room. I'd say to anyone hesitating to get it - then purchase some nice accent pillows and maybe an ottoman tray and enjoy

Quote from LukesMama : I am absolutely loving it. I've become a maniac about moving the pieces around to change the look of the room. I haven't even hooked any of them together yet. It's very nice, comfortable, and does not overwhelm my small living room. I'd say to anyone hesitating to get it - then purchase some nice accent pillows and maybe an ottoman tray and enjoy

Awesome. After reading other peoples reviews I was a little worried about the quality. Thanks for your reply. I think I will have to go get one now.

LakesMama or anyone else who purchased this set. How is it holding up after a few months? We are considering purchasing this couch for our house. Any feedback would be great, thanks.

My husband and I purchased this set the end of July. So far we love it. We purchased a small sectional from IKEA at the same time for our kids play room. I thought the IKEA one wasn't too bad to sit on, but once we got these in the IKEA couch feels like a rock. These are very soft and durable. We have a toddler and a baby and they wipe down very easy. We also have two cats and a previous poster said cat hair and lint stuck. We have not had any issues with that. The couch has hooks to link them together, but the ottomans don't. We just moved them around yesterday for a football party and they unhooked very easy. I did notice that there is a spot of stitching that looks like the manufacturer had an issue with so I am contacting Costco today about how to get it replaced. Hopefully they can do something. All in all, we love these couches and are very happy we bought them.

costco's return policy online:

With few exceptions, Costco has a 100% guarantee on all of our merchandise.

If you are not completely satisfied with your purchase, simply return the product and packaging, along with the receipt, if possible, to your local Costco warehouse.