|
|||||||
|
NAS = Network Attached Storage. If you want the added features of a HTPC then by all means continue on the path you are on. Back in June I spent about $1100 and built a water-cooled speed demon PC and dropped all of my current drives into it. I still easily have room for another five 3.5" drives but this machine is purely built for audio and video processing. This is why I NEED a NAS. I NEED to make backups of my backups. If I lose any concert footage I would be screwed. YMMV |
|
| 11-10-2012, 09:11 AM | |
|
|
|
1. Portable - My file server is a massive tower, the portability of a NAS may come in handy when you need move it somewhere quick. e.g. if you go on extended vacation, you may bring the NAS to your neighbor's house for safe keeping. 2. Power consumption - A full ATX PC will consume more power than a dedicated NAS. Heck, even a microATX PC may use more power. An ATX PC probably costs $50 more to operate per year, vs a dedicated NAS. 3. Hot swappable drives - Your newer PC may support this, but you still need to shutdown the PC, open the casing, screw in a new drive and hook up the SATA cable to the motherboard. With NAS, you just slot the drive in. You could buy one of those hot-swap drives bay for your PC though. 4. Harddive LED indicator - This tells you which drive is bad, this is much more convenient than opening your PC and guess which drive is bad. 5. Software/User-Experience - This is what I hope is the most important reason to get a NAS. I am hoping with the Synology DSM, everything can be plug-and-play, set-and-forget. With a home-built NAS (WHS-2001, FreeNAS, etc), you probably still need to spend some time to set them up correctly. Of course, all the above are not really the absolute-must reasons to get a NAS, as they may not be a big deal to everyone. If you just need a 2-drive solution and you already have a spare low-power consumption PC laying around, then maybe the DIY/FreeNAS solution makes more sense. |
|
|
However, if you want to run cool programs like Plex, the 413 (and 213+) do not have any support for it right now and for the immediate future. Just read the responses from the Plex developers on their forums. They don't think the time investment to code a PPC-based version of Plex Media Server is worth it for them. http://forums.plexapp. http://forums.plexapp. The 413 & 213+ don't have even a basic version of Plex Media Server to run. The lower ARM-based Synology NASes have Media Server but can't transcode video. The Intel-based 412+ and above can transcode 720p video as you can see in the spread sheet below. https://docs.google.com/spreadshe...xSm So if you want to save like $100 and really don't think that you'll be using some of the advanced 3rd party media features like Plex, then go for the 413. But in my opinion, once you start using your NAS for the first time, you'll see that all those other programs and features would be incredibly useful and cool to run. You'll wish that you had just spent the extra $100 to get the full feature set. Make sure that you've thought it all out with the feature sets because it's not as simple as saving an extra $100 in this case. |
|
|
|
|
I've never had a nas or server but was planning to use an old gaming rig to run as a server. Is there any benefit to me buying one of these synology units over just using a pc with server software on it? How much more power will a conservative pc server actually use over say the 4 drive synology?
Last edited by jefflam79; 11-10-2012 at 01:16 PM.. |
|
|
|
Still waiting on the 213+.
I expect alot more media streaming software support announcements to come in the future.. as these units are still fairly new on the market. Until that happens, its not a huge deal to continue doing what I was doing.. and thats use file formats that are supported by Itunes, Airplay, etc.. |
|
If you really want to transform an old computer into a nas with FreeNas, it's better to go with that. It's really dependent on your needs. If you're an average level consumer and want to back up a drive or so, stream movies/tv shows, then making your own Nas is better. But if space is an issue, and you really really want to conserve money on power, and rather not set up your own NAS, then these pre-built NAS are better. But if you are all of the above but budget is low, I would wait for Black Friday/Cyber Monday because Newegg usually has some NASes for sale. I purchased as NAS on Newegg last year on Cyber Monday for 120~ and it's great. |
|
|
A Synology NAS (like the 1812+, mentioned as on sale in this post) at $1000-ish will give you some pretty significant VAAI features under VMWare ESXi 5.1 that would typically cost thousands more, and offer massive improvements (hourlong disk operations become seconds or minutes long, etc.) in performance that until now required a much more serious SAN to do. Their DS36xxXS lineup is even better, but that's about $3000. Even the more basic Synology boxes have some very nice programs (packages) you can download, making iTunes sharing, Time Machine targeting/backup, SMB sharing, NFS sharing, and iSCSI sharing trivial. If none of that makes sense to you, you can still take great advantage of the simpler Synology boxes, because they offer a fantastic GUI, a very, very straightforward setup experience (slap the disks in the box, click OK a few times, and you're almost done!), and very good support from the vendor and from community forums. If you just need to share a file or two, or perform a PC/Time Machine backup or two, then download Linux-on-a-disk or use an old copy of Windows XP you have sitting in a closet, put it on an old dinosaur computer, put the old computer in a (ventilated) closet, set it up with a few shares and remote desktop access via RDP or VNC, and you're off to the races. Power usage is an issue for some, but for those in the USA, power is still cheap enough that it shouldn't be a deciding factor. For most, the difference between running that Synology box vs. a full, old computer might be $50/year or so. In Europe and Asia it can be a very different matter. |
|
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Jackson JS22R Electric Guitar with gig bag "Early Black Friday" sale $120 AC Shipped | The_Linux_Crew | Hot Deals | 35 | 12-12-2012 12:33 PM |
| ApparelCandy.com EARLY Black Friday Sale 30% Starts THIS Friday | KamJ | Hot Deals | 1 | 11-07-2012 03:33 PM |
| Amazon's Count Down with Early Black Friday Deals in Magazines Sale until Nov 10 | pathfinder35 | Hot Deals | 4 | 11-02-2012 05:19 AM |
| Bowlingball.com Early Black Friday Sale! 40-80% on various bowling equipment + FS | AD35 | Hot Deals | 0 | 11-23-2011 02:47 PM |
| newegg Early Black Friday Sale Up to 67% off | jayp0411 | Hot Deals | 49 | 11-13-2011 03:38 PM |