|
|||||||
| 03-19-2013, 03:18 AM | |
|
|
|
To all the people saying Seagate sucks: What other options do you see in the marketplace besides Western Digital? The WD has worse reviews than Seagate.
I've have bad drives from both companies, but based on their Amazon reviews, the Seagate is the better of the two 4TB external HDDs currently on the market. |
|
Maybe for the 4 TB drive in its rather limited age. Seagate's rep is trash with the poor quality control they had. Hard drives and my data is not something I am going to penny pinch on. I trust Western Digital a whole lot more (which in comparison to Seagate is not saying much mind you). That is not to say Western Digital can not have a lemon, but they back their products (especially the caviar black line of internal disk) with better warranties than everyone else usually. That is all you really need to know about Seagate. The purpose of a hard disk is to store and backup data. Not to store and pray the disk does not go bad. |
|
|
Last edited by daon; 03-19-2013 at 04:14 AM.. Best deal evarrr: Loaded Thinkpad x230t convertible tablet - $561
|
|
|
What your paying for is the luxury/convenience of having the biggest size in 1 single drive. That alone makes it worth it. I'd personally bought 2x4TB for $500 when they came out, knowing I can get a 3TB/2TB for much cheaper... |
|
|
|
|
|
Well just because you did not get lemons obviously makes you the foremost expert on Seagate Quality control. Google search for Seagate Quality control issues on the web and read the mountains of flaming they have gotten in the past number of years. Few come out and say WD is garbage and Seagate is better. A good number say they are the same. Many say Seagate stinks...they must all be wrong lol. And unless you plan on backing up your disks to tape, disk is really your only cost effective and practical solution. Which is why people should store their backups onto 2 or more separate disks just to be safe because yes, they do eventually fail. All mechanical devices will eventually fail. The point being they should not fail at a more frequent rate then their competitors and if Seagate stood by their products, they woudl match WDs warranty. They will not, which speaks volumes. |
|
|
I find it especially funny that you think: "The point being they should not fail at a more frequent rate then their competitors " I think you mean "higher rate." And the response to this is "no shit." So WD fails at a higher rate in my experience, but I should trust the irate consumers who post negative reviews about the competitors to WD and buy another WD! Okay! |
|
|
Yes pretty much. That being said, externals most often contain a brand internal in the box so if the reliability of that model is in question, so is that of the external. Comes down to who you trust more with your data? I really do not trust either, but there is no large mass of WD haters out there like there are Seagate haters and Seagate brought this on itself. Many think it happened when they took over Maxtor. In relaity, it was probably a slow degradation over time in an effort to compete but there really is no way of knowing. |
|
|
To each his own. I have had a number of Seagates die and a lot less WDs historically. And I have not bought Seagates in awhile at this point. So I shoud trust your opinion over that of the Google U (to say nothign of myself)?...that is pretty laughable in and of itself. Anyone's experience can be an anomoly. So if you are the type that ignores all ratings all research of opinons of the user community and bases it solely on how lucky you are with the set of drives you have gotten, feel free. It is your money. |
|
|
WARNING! I have had 2 Seagate drives - a 2TB internal and a 3TB internal - one 2 years old and one less than 6 months old - critically fail on me in the last 6 weeks. Seagate is a crap brand that nobody should buy if they want to keep their data. Go with Fantom or Western Digital - hell, ANYONE but Seagate! I'll never buy another of their products again!
|
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Seagate 2-Bay Business Storage Diskless NAS (STBN100) + Free 500GB Seagate Backup Plus USB 3.0 Portable Hard Drive $215.99 + Free Shipping at Newegg | Discombobulated | Hot Deals | 12 | 03-02-2013 09:21 AM |
| 1TB Seagate Backup Plus USB 3.0 Portable Hard Drive for Mac (STBW1000900) $76.49 + Free Shipping | calistyle | Hot Deals | 0 | 02-16-2013 12:29 AM |
| 4TB Seagate Backup Plus USB 3.0 Desktop External Hard Drive (STCA4000100) $176.99 + Free Shipping | bc_boston | Hot Deals | 3 | 01-22-2013 01:35 PM |
| Western Digital 4TB My Book Essential USB 3.0 Desktop Hard Drive, $179 w/FS at B&H Photo Video online | g725s | Hot Deals | 13 | 01-01-2013 11:40 PM |
| Seagate Expansion 1TB Portable USB 3.0 External Hard Drive - Staples - $63.75 AC FS | Beradon | Hot Deals | 72 | 11-18-2012 07:56 PM |