So it's basically tribes with medieval playes? I'll pass on this one, realism is key to these types of games.
Chivalry shouldn't be classified as "these types of games." Chivalry did not get ruined like Tribes did. Don't even compare the two. Ratchet and Clank is a good example of non-realistic shooting. Chivalry goes away from realism in the same direction and it's a great game.
Also, if you like serious/realistic battles, don't join a server with no gravity... even then it's still better than floaty tribes.