Those are really nice tents. They're also $500. I'm sure the quality shows that it's worth it, but anyone who is interested in this tent is absolutely not interested in spending $500 on one of the Kodaik ones. Conversely, anyone who is willing to spend $500 on one of those already knows why they wouldn't buy a $90 Coleman.
Yeah, I wish the hubby would let me get the Coleman but we're going for the Kodiak too. It's true if you have the coin the canvas is better. Kinda like getting a Dyson over a Hoover IMO.