The Official American Idol thread (Finale Poll Added)

[ForeverDcember]

Lady GaGa is a nasty skank. WTF was all that "dancing?" Looked like seizures and drunk dancing. Ugh.

I am not surprised by tonight and I am pretty happy. They were annoying me

Next week should be interesting, the theme is songs from the year the contestant was born.

[Autumn]

Quote from ForeverDcember : Lady GaGa is a nasty skank. WTF was all that "dancing?" Looked like seizures and drunk dancing. Ugh. I am not surprised by tonight and I am pretty happy. They were annoying me Next week should be interesting, the theme is songs from the year the contestant was born.

Yes!!!!

[Lloyd.]

i like lady gaga's songs. just dance and poker face

[Lloyd.]

i was extremely disappointed at this week's itunes top 100 performances. i thought i'd be listening to an all-contemporary lineup. i wasn't particularly impressed by any of them.

lil rounds could have done better with beyonce's listen, allison with so what by pink, matt with apologize or boston by augustana. i was disappointed that kris didn't pick a jason mraz song, he did a good job nonetheless.

[MAPAM]

Quote from LordRamZ : i think the only people they would save are Adam, Danny, Allison, maybe Matt DONT THINK THEY'LL NEED SAVING BEFORE THE TOP 5. i think kara provides the best critiques

MOST OF THE TIME I AGREE SHE DOES HAVE A PROBLEM WITH HER NUMBERS---"6 WORDS"-- WAS REALLY 8 AND "STUDIO57" WHATS THAT A KATCHUP BAR!!! LOL--- ITS STUDIO54!

AND YEAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!
BYE MEGAN
YOUR NASTY COMMENT TOOK AWAY ANY CHANCH(you did'nt have one anyway!) FOR A SAVE---YOU SHOULD CARE WHAT THEY SAY, YOU HAVE TO DEAL WITH PEOPLES OPIONS IN THE BIZ!

[Thrifteh]

Quote from RugratsGalore : Lady GaGa?!? I did not like her

Me either...just plain weirdariffic.

Quote from Autumn : David Cook's drummer was kinda hot in a Jesus kinda way. I'm watching it now...recorded it earlier....did Megan get kicked off?

Hilar!

Quote from ForeverDcember : Lady GaGa is a nasty skank. WTF was all that "dancing?" Looked like seizures and drunk dancing. Ugh. I am not surprised by tonight and I am pretty happy. They were annoying me Next week should be interesting, the theme is songs from the year the contestant was born.

Oh but it gets better in my house I get to listen to DH & DD's comments throughout the entire performance.

I am not sad to see Megan go. She was getting boring and monotonous. She was also real smug last night. Maybe smug isn't the right word...her attitude was definitely "I don't give a fark." I would have rather seen the girl they brought back make it this far. Ummm, lose the attitude chica.

[ForeverDcember]

Having only two girls out of the eight is interesting. I wonder how long they will last

[The Raddish]

Quote from ForeverDcember : Having only two girls out of the eight is interesting. I wonder how long they will last

My guess is that they'll both be in the top five.

There's still a lot of fat to trim.

[Lloyd.]

Quote from The Raddish : My guess is that they'll both be in the top five. There's still a lot of fat to trim.

i think allison's end is near.

sorry tr

[point5mann]

Quote from Thrifty-n-SoCal : I am not sad to see Megan go. She was getting boring and monotonous. She was also real smug last night. Maybe smug isn't the right word...her attitude was definitely "I don't give a fark." I would have rather seen the girl they brought back make it this far. Ummm, lose the attitude chica.

In her defense... though I am no fan of hers... I think she was torn the whole time about being away from her son. I really think it was bittersweet for her... kind of like the roughneck. She handled really poorly, but my feeling is she couldn't help it.... she seemed an emotional wreck.

I think Allison will make it to the top 5. Clearly Allison was the one they were contemplating saving, so I'm holding out hope if America gets it wrong that the judges will save her.

[Thrifteh]

Quote from Lloyd. : i think allison's end is near. sorry tr

No way, not before Scott and Matt.

[Iaaaiws]

Quote from point5mann : I think Allison will make it to the top 5. Clearly Allison was the one they were contemplating saving, so I'm holding out hope if America gets it wrong that the judges will save her.

Quote from Thrifty-n-SoCal : No way, not before Scott and Matt.

Unless Allison really does poorly she would be saved by the judges if Scott and Matt are still there.

[.teri.]

Allison reminds me of Pink a little bit. I think she has an amazing voice. Her song Tuesday was great in the beginning, until she tried to oversing it.

[cheapskate82]

I can't believe that nobody mentioned that Scott MacIntyre looked exactly like Beavis!!!

[gypsylady]

Quote from topchief1 : I can't believe that nobody mentioned that Scott MacIntyre looked exactly like Beavis!!!

Funny, but mean! After all give Scott a break, considering his disability he doesn't exactly have the exact choice in how he looks clothing and hairstyle wise. He can say what he wants to wear or what hairstyle he would like to have, but he has to depend on others to tell him what looks good. In their opinion of course not his, since he can't see how he finally looks. I like Scott and think he has done a great job, and like Paula said he makes you forget he has a disability when he is singing. I don't think he will win the competition, but think he deserves much praise for what he has accomplished.

I kinda figured Megan wouldn't be around for much longer, so no real surprise there. I think that the judges will keep their save for the last of the competition to shake things up at the end. They will also use it on one of the top singers, and sorry that wasn't Megan.

Once again I loved Adam and really do think he looks like a young Elvis. He is cute and according to someone on YouTube, Adam is so hot he is the cause of global warming. He also has quite the vocal range. Rock on Adam!