Long Island: $109 -- Shelter Island: Charming B&B Escape for 2, Reg. $175 (expired)

Shelter Island, located just across a narrow stretch of water from Long Island, offers a low-key respite where "quiet country lanes wind across the island's rolling land," according to Fodor's. Spend a night on the island this spring with this exclusive deal from the Candlelite Inn that saves nearly 40% on current pricing.
With this deal for two, check in Sunday-Thursday through May 23 for $109 per night. For $70 more, make it a two-night trip, or spend two nights over the weekend for $229.
The bed-and-breakfast, housed in a 180-year-old Victorian home, is situated in the center of the island, making it an ideal home base for casual bike rides or hiking through the Mashomack Nature Conservancy, within walking distance of the inn. Grab a book and relax on the inn's wraparound porch after a day of exploring.
The hotel is a three-hour train ride to Greenport from New York City, or a 40-minute drive from the Orient Point ferry.
Photo credit: Moya McAllister
Terms and Conditions
Once the room is reserved with the hotel, hotel cancellation policy prevails, and cancellations or changes must be made 7 days prior to arrival. Hotel-imposed penalties may apply. Any unused promotional value credit will be forfeited upon checkout. Parking is complimentary. This deal cannot be combined with other offers. Taxes and gratuity, if applicable, are additional. Voucher must be used in 1 visit.

Update: May 17-18 are no longer available. With this deal, you don’t have to decide yet when to go. Just purchase a voucher from Travelzoo then call the hotel directly at 631-749-0676 to make a reservation for your desired travel dates. Guests may be prompted to leave a message. Not available on: March 29-31. Reservations are subject to availability and early booking is encouraged. See below for full terms and conditions.