Amazon Echo Review: Alexa Passes the Family Test

I took the Amazon Echo and Alexa voice service out for a spin to see if they live up to the hype.

At Slickdeals, we work hard to help you find the best deals. To do this, some of the products featured here are from our partners, who may provide us with compensation. However, this doesn’t influence our opinions. Our views are our own.

Amazon Echo

This year’s Super Bowl ad featuring the Amazon Echo and Alec Baldwin left many viewers, myself included, itching to get their hands on one — which is exactly what I did. My family and I spent a full week playing with the world’s most famous virtual assistant. Here’s how it went.

Setting Up the Amazon Echo

As far as setup goes, Alexa is a snap. Simply plug in the Echo, Amazon Echo in boxdownload the Alexa app (I opted for the iOS version on my iPhone), and follow the super easy, step-by-step directions. All you need to get going is an Amazon account, access to Wi-Fi and five minutes to spare. The only thing that surprised me here was that the Echo needs to be plugged into a power source at all times in order to work since it doesn’t have a battery. Is it a deal breaker? Not really, but it does require rebooting if you want to take it into another area of the house. On the upside, it was nice that we didn’t have to wait several hours for it to charge before using. Similarly, low-battery life is a non-issue.

Overall Ease of Use

Amazon includes a quick but informative video tutorial within the app that helped us get acquainted with how the whole thing works. Again, I give Amazon points here for being extremely user-friendly. For example, they include a rundown of handy features, popular things to try, and the answers to all the basic FAQs.

As Alec Baldwin demonstrated, the Echo’s “wake word” is Alexa. Upon saying this, a blue ring lights up the top of the device to indicate that she’s “awake” and listening. FYI: You can change the wake word to “Amazon” or “Echo” if you prefer.

From there, fire away.

“Alexa, what’s the weather tomorrow?”
“Alexa, how’s my commute looking?”
“Alexa, what’s the news?”

One of the first things that impressed my husband was the speaker quality. For such a tiny device — about half the size of a loaf of bread — it packs a big punch in the sound department. You can control the volume with your voice, instructing Alexa to get louder or quieter on demand. When it came time to play music (more on that in a bit), the sound quality didn’t disappoint.

Amazon Echo on a tableWhile the voice command is an obvious selling point and does the bulk of the heavy lifting, the app also comes in handy. There you’ll find controls for everything Alexa can do, along with your shopping list and to-do list. (When I told Alexa to add eggs to my shopping list, it showed up in the app a second later.) The app is valuable for a few reasons, like helping you clarify the odd request that Alexa is struggling to understand. For example, I kept asking Alexa to play a podcast I like, but she just couldn’t figure out what I was asking for. After a few times, I gave up and just typed it into the app, which found it easily. From there, I played it on the app, which slung it over to the Echo.

This experience begs a big question: How good is Alexa at interpreting your requests? Overall, I give her a solid 7 out of 10. For the most part, she understood what we threw at her just fine, especially when spoken in a slow, clear voice. The tricky part, of course, is when you have two young children running around, the TV on and the dog barking. In a typical household setting, Alexa couldn’t always make sense of what we were asking. A small thumbs down, but it wasn’t enough to really frustrate me.

My Favorite Feature: The Prime Music Library

If you invest in an Amazon Echo and you’ve also got a Prime account, you’ll be able to play anything from the Prime Music library. This, hands down, was my favorite thing about having Alexa in our house. Ordinarily, we play iTunes radio through our Apple TV. This, of course, involves the small hassle of grabbing the remote, typing in what you want to hear, and pressing play. If you want to skip a song or change the channel, you’re reaching for that remote again.Prime Music Banner

The Echo was life-changing in this department. While getting dressed in the morning, I’d simply ask Alexa to put on some Coldplay and boom — it was on. While the Prime Music library is, admittedly, a bit limited (when I requested The Staves or Beirut, for instance, it came up empty), the selection is more than decent. And the voice command is just oh, so nice. While washing the dishes, I used my voice to switch from music to my favorite podcast, all without stepping away from the sink. The Echo is also complete with streaming radio.

I’ll warn you, though: My 4- and 6-year-old daughters loved this just as much as I did, which translated to them blasting Katy Perry without permission pretty much constantly. More than once I had to hit the mute button so that my kids couldn’t use it.

Notable Functions

Music aside, Alexa has some other pretty cool perks. If you type a destination into the app, she’ll tell you the current traffic conditions. In addition to the obvious stuff, she also spouts off news briefs from NPR via TuneIn. The morning after I fell asleep during the Academy Awards, she told me that Leo had indeed snagged the Oscar. Everything from movie times to nearby restaurants are all instantly available.

When my brother came by and asked for the Lakers score, Alexa responded straight away — prompting him to remark that her answer was “way faster than it would have taken Echofor me to look it up on my phone.” This brings up another plus of the Echo. While Siri can perform similar tasks, Alexa can perform the same tasks without you having to pull out your phone. Plus, as mentioned above, the sound quality if better than on your phone.

Amazon also now has Spotify integration, which is pretty cool for music lovers. Pandora and iHeartRadio are also at your fingertips. Book worms might also be interested to know that Alexa will read audio books via Audible or Kindle Unlimited.

My kids definitely got the biggest kick out of asking Alexa to tell them jokes. They also asked her an endless array of questions, from “How many teeth do dogs have?” to “How far away is the moon?” She answered them all without missing a beat.

Finally, within the app, you’ll find an option to enable different skills. We tried one called MemoryChallenge, which basically translates to Alexa saying a series of words and you trying to accurately repeat them back. There are literally pages upon pages of random games like this that you can enable or disable at any time.

 

Other Features Worth Trying

For those who frequently shop on Amazon, you can configure the Echo to make voice purchases from your account. So buying shampoo can be as simple as telling Alexa to order it.

Amazon has also teamed up with a service called If This Then That (IFTTT). As Wired points out, the partnership allows for “cross-app cause and effect.” This is what allows for Alexa to find your phone or turn on your TV. Plus, if you have smart lights in your house, Alexa can turn those on and off for you as well. It’s like a much classier version of the Clapper.

Overall Verdict

After trying out the Echo first hand, I’d be lying if I said I didn’t love it. Is it something every household needs? No, not by a long shot, but it is a really cool gadget. However, the $180 price tag could definitely be a stumbling block for some. A good time to buy on is during Prime Day or Black Friday/Cyber Monday, when prices have dropped to $140. Or look for a refurbished one, which can be bought for $119 when in stock.

If price is an issue, you might want to consider the Amazon Tap, which is $50 less at $129.99. This smaller, battery-powered version of the Echo provides direct access to Alexa while on the go. It’s essentially a portable Bluetooth speaker with Alexa’s capabilities. (You can see what Slickdealers are saying about it here.)

Amazon is also creating a lot of buzz with the Echo Dot: A teeny, Alexa-operated virtual assistant that can hook up to an external speaker for better music quality. Coming in at just under $50, the Dot is becoming increasingly popular and you can buy several of them to be placed in different rooms if you want Alexa to hear you from more areas of your home.

threadID: 8678019

What Other Slickdealers Think of the Amazon Echo

Amazon Echo

We polled some Slickdeals staff members who either own or have tried out the Amazon Echo to see what they think.

As a hands-free timer and alarm, the Echo is worth its weight in gold. It makes baking so much easier, and I even set it for the kids when it’s time to put the shoes and jackets on to go to the bus in the morning.” — daisybeetle, Slickdeals Deal Editor.

I purchased the Amazon Echo at launch when it was discounted at $99 for pre-­orders. I initially purchased it as a novelty item and it’s a very fun gadget, but I’ve also found it useful at some everyday tasks, too. Some things I use it for:

  • Listening to music I uploaded to Amazon Prime Music ($24.99 per year, 250,000 songs).
  • Measuring conversions, Ounces to Cups, Tablespoons to Cups, etc.
  • Weather: I love being able to have instant weather updates when I need them.
  • Amazon Echo has many jokes, although mostly silly and elementary.
  • Timer: It’s very useful when cooking or when you need a reminder/alert.
  • Sports updates: It’s very helpful when we are watching a movie rather than the game.

Although I am happy with the Echo, there are a few drawbacks and limitations. For example:

  • You can only choose the “wake­ word” Alexa or Amazon.
  • Amazon Music storage is $24.99, which is inexpensive but I feel it should have been included.
  • Sometimes it doesn’t understand my voice, although there is a voice training app. Being from Boston, I do have a strong accent.
  • Being a Slickdealer, there is no way to use a coupon code or get the best price if you try to use it for ordering products. So I have that feature turned off.

Overall, I think the Amazon Echo is a great product with a lot of features and a lot of room for future updates. I have recommended it to family and friends, and I have also pre­ordered Amazon’s new products based on The Amazon Echo, named The Echo Dot and Amazon Tap.” — BostonGirl, Slickdeals QA

The thing that stood out to me the most with the Amazon Echo after testing it out for a weekend was the sound quality of the speaker. I didn’t expect it to be that good in that department. I liked being able to just say “Alexa, play the news” when I walked in the kitchen in the morning and it starts playing NPR News. Using Spotify was pretty neat, too, but I couldn’t figure out how to skip ahead several songs when playing a playlist. I ended up doing it one song at a time, which became very repetitive.

My 7-year-old daughter thought it was the best thing ever and couldn’t stop asking it any and every question she could think of. I’d say Alexa had about a 50 percent success rate with answering her, which is probably on par with my own ability to do the same. Not too bad. I don’t see myself buying it for $180, but if they drop the price on Prime Day this year I might be tempted to get one. My girlfriend seems to have missed it after I brought it back to work on Monday, so I might not have a choice in the matter.” — JohanM1228, Slickdeals Staff

Images courtesy of Johan Mengesha, Marianne Hayes, Amazon.

Marianne Hayes

Marianne Hayes is a freelance writer, wife and mother in Tampa Bay. After earning a degree in journalism and creative writing from the University of Central Florida, she spent nearly a decade getting lost in New York City and Los Angeles before making her way back home again in 2014. Marianne's writing has appeared in a variety of publications including The Huffington Post, Forbes.com, LearnVest, The Daily Beast and more. When she's not writing, Marianne is usually cruising her local bookstore with her two daughters.

Related Articles

Back to top button
Close