Imperfect Produce: Is It Perfect For You?

Imperfect Produce saves the environment and saves on time, but does it save money?

According to the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization, about one third of food produced in the world gets wasted or lost — approximately 1.3 billion tons a year, around half of which are fruits and vegetables.

Grocery stores are one of the major contributors to food waste in America since they often reject fruits and vegetables due to small blemishes, irregular sizing or because of surplus. That's where Imperfect Produce steps in.

Their mission is to “find a home for these unloved and odd-looking fruits and vegetables at a price that is mouthwateringly affordable.” They currently operate in select cities in California, including the Bay Area and Los Angeles, but will soon be serving Orange County and San Diego, as well.

As a person who has a hard time eating healthy on a budget and dreads crowded grocery stores, I was pretty excited to try out Imperfect Produce and hopefully get more leafy greens in my life. But, while the subscription service sounds convenient, is it really cost effective? Here's what I found out when I gave the service a try.

What Is Imperfect Produce?

Imperfect Produce boxes range from small (7 to 9 pounds) to large (17 to 19 pounds), and subscriptions can be of mixed produce, all fruit, all veggie or all organic items. You can opt for deliveries either every week or every other week, and you can change your delivery frequency at any time.

I went with the cheapest option: a small, mixed produce box that averages about $11-13 (the price varies due to each item in the box being individually priced, but includes their flat $4 service fee.)

After receiving a few deliveries, I changed my order to come every other week instead of every week, having found that my roommate and I just couldn't eat that much food each week since we eat out a lot. Changing the frequency of a delivery is simple, and there’s even a vacation mode that puts a hold on your produce while you’re gone. It’s also possible to skip a week if needed.

While Imperfect Produce creates a default box for you, it’s totally customizable, so you can swap out or add in fruits and veggies from their selection that week. I look forward to customizing my box each week, but when I forgot one week and received the default shipment, I was still impressed with the auto-generated variety.

One final perk of Imperfect Produce is that they don't lock you in to a minimum subscription period and won't charge you any penalties if you decide to cancel. When I looked into the cancellation process, I found that it would only take 3 clicks to end a recurring order, with no hassles, guilting, or fees.

>>Related: AmazonFresh Review — Is it a Good Deal?

How Much Does Imperfect Produce Really Cost?


While the advertised rate of about $11-13 a box seems like a pretty good deal for produce, how does the price stack up against conventional grocery stores? I put one of my deliveries to the test.

The following chart shows my selection of produce — after I customized it — from one of the weeks I was due for a delivery. The first column shows the comparable price for the same or similar item in a grocery store (online prices from Ralphs or Costco) and the second column shows the Imperfect price.

In addition to the cost of your box, Imperfect Produce also charges a flat $5.99 for delivery and a $4 service fee. The last column takes the $10 total of shipping and service charges, divides it amongst all the produce I ordered ($10 / 7 items = approximately $1.40 per piece of produce), and adds this to the cost of Imperfect’s fruits and veggies, to show the true cost of using their service.

In the end, Imperfect’s produce is slightly cheaper overall if you compare just the base price of their fruits and vegetables. However, service fees and shipping charges make the overall cost of Imperfect Produce’s services more than if you just shopped at the grocery store — at least for my order.

It's possible that a larger order might have evened out the cost a bit. And, if you're in the Bay Area, Imperfect Produce now offers the option of picking up your box from their warehouse in Emeryville, CA in order to save on the shopping cost.

>>Related: Does Buying In Bulk at Costco Actually Save You Money?

Is It Actually Ugly?


So how “cosmetically challenged” are the fruits and vegetables from Imperfect Produce, and does it affect how they taste? When I first received my delivery, I couldn’t understand what could possibly be the problem with any of the produce. They seemed just as good as anything I would see in the grocery store. It took about a month or two of deliveries for me to get my first, even remotely “ugly” vegetable — a carrot that seemed to have two limbs. For the most part though, it seemed like most of the produce came simply from surplus.

The taste and freshness of each delivery was never questionable either and tasted just as good as grocery store produce — even that two-legged carrot. The produce arrived ready to eat or a day or two away from being ripe, and with the right storage, stayed fresh for a long time.

Lastly, I love that the produce comes in a recyclable box and each delivery includes a recipe card to make seasonal dishes with your new fruits and vegetables.

Is Imperfect Produce Worth It?

Overall, Imperfect Produce's shipping and delivery fees result in higher costs when compared to simply going to the grocery store. But, the cost isn't that unreasonable if you really just hate shopping at the store, and still want more variety and inspiration in the kitchen.

Plus, the company is truly making admirable strides toward environmental sustainability. They’re expanding to new areas across California and will soon be adding other items, such as pastas and bread to the line up, making the future bright for all the “ugly” groceries out there.

 



Add a Comment
About the Author

Katherine (Kat) is a college survival expert, having dedicated her time as a UCLA Bruin to having fun while staying on a budget. Kat has the hookups: she’s the girl in the group chat with the Uber codes, free food spots, and make-up or clothes sales. Need fairy lights? She’s got you. When she’s not touting a coffee from “Frappy Hour” or an ice cream from “Cone Day,” she’s looking for parking in Los Angeles so she can start another adventure.


3 Comments

1
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Aug 2013
L7: Teacher
2,061 Posts
4,954 Reputation
Pro
#2
As a Calif. gardener some of my most fun is growing odd shaped fruit that would never make super market shelves but is fine. I currently have a huge volunteer butternut squash that occasionally disguises itself as a giant zucchini squash. Many of my tomatoes have odd shapes but are so good. I salute anyone able to forgo the looks of an item for its great texture. Good to know there is a company doing this. Thanks Kat.
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Feb 2014
L4: Apprentice
302 Posts
141 Reputation
#3
Any product where shipping/service fees is 240% of the retail cost of the product is ripe for competition like Amazon or Walmart to crush. So for now we can put this in the category of skimming dollars from rich people.

People would be better served getting the rubbermaid freshworks. Now those are amazing. It easily extends the life of my produce 2-3x and the waste is practically down to zero now.
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Jul 2017
New User
2 Posts
10 Reputation
#4
I just Like this post and enjoying while reading this article. You are asking the Question that Imperfect Produce saves the environment and saves on time, but does it save money? My answer is no. Because of the shipping charges are very costly, So it's not affordable to me.
Reply Helpful Comment? 1 0
Page 1 of 1
1
Join the Conversation
Add a Comment
 
Copyright 1999 - 2018. Slickdeals, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Copyright / Infringement Policy  •  Privacy Policy  •  Terms of Service  •  Acceptable Use Policy (Rules)  •  Interest-Based Ads
Link Copied to Clipboard