Xbox One vs. Xbox 360: Is It Time To Upgrade Yet?

Should you turn in your 360 and pick up an Xbox One?
Slickdeals content may contain references to products from one or more of our affiliate partners. If you make a purchase on their site through a link on Slickdeals, we receive a small commission. This in no way affects our opinions on products or services mentioned in our content.

Xbox One

The Xbox One is coming up on its second anniversary, and while the Xbox 360 was a console champion in the previous generation (we’re not counting the Wii here, as that’s a whole separate discussion) its successor has not seen the same booming success. Many 360 owners have either jumped to a different console or continued on with their 360. But two years later, is now the time to finally take the plunge?

Games

71jUlLTTl3L._SL1380_ While the Xbox One does a lot of things that are not game related, we’re starting with the games because they matter the most. Much like the PS4, many current games are seeing releases on both Xbox consoles through the end of this year. Unfortunately, that seems to be changing soon. Microsoft has previously stated they will be ending support for the 360 in 2016, so gamers will start to see a hard push toward the Xbox One next year.

That isn’t as dire as it sounds however, as Microsoft shocked everybody this past June when they announced that the Xbox One would add backwards compatibility for Xbox 360 games. This is by far the biggest thing to happen to the Xbox One since launch, and a major reason to consider upgrading. It will not cover all games, but beginning with the November system update. Microsoft says that more than 100 games will be backwards compatible, with more being added over time. As a member of the Xbox Live Preview Program, I’ve been able to play a limited number of backwards compatible games and they work as well as they did on the 360. This means that all the money you have dropped on 360 titles over the last decade will not be wasted, which is a very good thing.

Also, there's a little game called Halo 5 coming out in October, which is kind of a big deal if you're an Xbox gamer.

Controller

The Xbox 360’s game controller was dangerously close to being the world’s most perfect input device. Microsoft did themselves a favor by not making any major changes to it. They did replace the 360’s terrible D-Pad with a traditional directional pad, which was definitely needed, but all other changes have just been polish. Your fingers grip the sticks a little better; the triggers and bumped buttons are larger; and the triggers now have their own rumble built in, which is a thing nobody needs, but we’ll happily take.

There is also a new controller design that adds a 3.5mm headphone jack so you can plug in headphones or a headset without using the otherwise required  stereo audio adapter. As Slickdealer iiispeck points out, both control configurations have upsides and downsides. The audio adapter requires you to spend $20 more, but gives you discrete game and chat volume control at your fingertips. Using the standard headset jack saves you the money, but requires you to make audio adjustments in the console menu, which means you can't make minor adjustments on the fly.

81C4Q18LHbL._SL1500_

Social Media/Broadcasting

Xbox has its own activity feed, not unlike Facebook. While the social media aspects of the Xbox One are not as robust as the PS4, they are there so you can see what your friends are playing, view game clips they've recorded and comment on them like you would any other social media platform. Streaming via Twitch works well, and the ability to take screenshots and make video clips to share with friends is simple and intuitive.

Xbox Live

Xbox Live has always been a necessary part of the Xbox experience, and that hasn’t changed with the Xbox One. The Games With Gold feature of monthly free games has carried over from the 360, and there are also weekly game discounts, so eventually that game you’re waiting on will hit the price point you’re looking for.

Technical Specs

The Xbox One is a technical improvement over the 360. It includes a massive upgrade in RAM, and the number of processor cores increases from three to eight. Much like the PS3 vs. the PS4, the jump in performance as far as graphics quality in your gaming is more of an evolution than a revolution, but you won't be disappointed in the performance that you get. Your hard drive space jumps from the 500GB maximum on the 360 to a minimum of 500GB on the Xbox One with a 1 TB model also available. While this space may go quickly depending on how many games you own (since all games need to be downloaded onto the hard drive), external drives can be added.

Windows 10

Another reason to consider upgrading now is the integration of Windows 10. Since Windows 10 launched in July and is available free to everybody who has an OS newer than Vista, most PC owners now have the ability to access more features of their Xbox One via their computer. This includes the ability to stream your Xbox One games to your Windows 10 PC and play competitive games across the two platforms.

Xbox One will be receiving its own Windows 10 update this fall, which will only add to the ways the two systems will work together.

Price

The price was a major issue at the Xbox One’s launch, as its $499 price point was the highest among consoles. The fact that this price was due to the “required” Kinect camera system, which many people didn't want, didn’t make the Xbox One a lot of friends early on. Microsoft then removed the Kinect, dropping the price to $399, and then they instituted a “holiday deal” at $349, which has remained in place since then. There is also a $399 model with a 1 TB hard drive, as opposed to the standard 500 GB.

Your best option is to find a good bundle that includes additional games or accessories for the same $349 price point. We’ve seen occasional console deals as low as $288, and it wasn't even during Black Friday or Cyber Monday. However, that's usually the best time of the year for gaming console deals. Last Black Friday saw deals around $329 from several retailers (though Wal-Mart and Target added store gift cards on top of the deal, making their bundles better overall) back when retail price was $399, so expect to see sub $280 deals this year. Best Buy is also a popular retailer to get gaming consoles from because you can always get an extra 10 percent off with the Movers Coupon, which will at least cover sales tax. Remember not to get too fixated on just the price, though. A bundle might cost an extra $40 or so, but you could be getting games, gift cards or other bonus items worth $100+ in value.

You can also  help reduce the cost of a new Xbox One by trading in your 360. At the moment, you can get about $50 from Gamestop, but you may be able to find more for your trade-in elsewhere.

Bottom Line

With 360 backwards compatibility open to all in November, a Black Friday deal on an Xbox One is probably exactly what you should be looking for. You can upgrade to a new console without losing all your old games, while gaining all the new games and features.

Images courtesy of Xbox, Amazon.com

 



Add a Comment
About the Author
Stephen Libbey Contributor

Stephen is a veteran of the consumer electronics industry where he was a sales manager for numerous products, everything from basic stereos to whole home automation systems.  Most of the people he knows in that industry call him Dirk, but that’s not important.  He is an avid gamer, occasional podcaster, coffee snob, and watches much more TV than is probably healthy.  Today he is a freelance writer specializing in his various geek obsessions.  You can join his obsessions on Twitter, @childe_dirk

11 Comments

1
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Oct 2007
L10: Grand Master
9,506 Posts
3,385 Reputation
Our community has rated this post as helpful. If you agree, why not rep Technosquid?
#2
Eventually they'll release a version with the high-definition microphone built in, so you'll never need Kinect. Storage / Hybrid drive updates aside, they're still in hardware 1.0. Wait until the slim / 2.0 rev if you've waited this long.
Reply Helpful Comment? 5 0
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Nov 2011
L3: Novice
113 Posts
30 Reputation
#3
I traded in my old 360 and with tax and everything got the new Xbox One for $226 in the end. I'm going to trade that one in to get the Elite Bundle that will be showing up at my front door on December 1. That should be the last one for me (hopefully) for now.
Reply Helpful Comment? 1 0
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users Show Post
HIDDEN
09-22-2015 at 11:42 AM
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Aug 2008
L3: Novice
140 Posts
14 Reputation
Our community has rated this post as helpful. If you agree, why not rep machaan?
#5
Quote from ChrisB6750
:
If you're smart enough to read this article you're smart enough to build a pc. You'll end up saving money in the long run as a pc isn't strictly a "gaming time suck", you'll be able to play higher quality games (60fps @ 1080p or higher), you won't be shelling out $60 a game (pc games are typically much cheaper), you don't have to pay for xbox live or playstation plus to play online (you already pay for internet, should that be enough?), and you won't have to deal with little children screaming "YOUR MOM" every time your character dies while playing online.
All true statements-I used to play PC games before buying my Xbox 360 in 2006. Here's why I don't play PC games anymore:
  1. In online multiplayer shooters, I get killed almost instantly after spwaning-I don't have the time nor skills to find cheats, macros, etc to outfox the super -techies.
  2. Every 6 months, there is a new processor, graphics card etc that gives the purchaser an added advantage online-again not interested in throwing money out the door.
  3. With the xbox, everybody has similar hardware, cheats are few and far in between and matchmaking is quick and painless.
  4. When I want to use a PC, I use my laptop which I can take with me into any room I want. If my gaming rig is also my computer, then I'm stuck in one spot-no added benefit of a PC gaming rig over the xbox.
  5. PC games are $50 as opposed to $60 for xbox-I buy a couple games a year-I'll be ok.
Reply Helpful Comment? 4 1
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Dec 2013
L3: Novice
381 Posts
661 Reputation
Pro
#6
Quote from Technosquid
:
Eventually they'll release a version with the high-definition microphone built in, so you'll never need Kinect. Storage / Hybrid drive updates aside, they're still in hardware 1.0. Wait until the slim / 2.0 rev if you've waited this long.
Too true.

One thing conveniently absent from this article and every other advertisement for the Xbox One gen1 is the monstrous power brick with built in fan. Yep. That's right. The dedicated power brick needs it's own fan which generously whooshes air and sound through the room when the console is in standby.

Necessity for this was to power the Kinect? Or just general poor engineering?

Anyway, yeah. The second iteration will hopefully do away with the electrical masonry. On second thought who knows? In Soviet Union, they drink vodka. At Microsoft, they drink vodka and then approve the absurd.
Reply Helpful Comment? 1 1
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Sep 2011
L3: Novice
210 Posts
188 Reputation
#7
Quote from captivater
:
Too true.

One thing conveniently absent from this article and every other advertisement for the Xbox One gen1 is the monstrous power brick with built in fan. Yep. That's right. The dedicated power brick needs it's own fan which generously whooshes air and sound through the room when the console is in standby.

Necessity for this was to power the Kinect? Or just general poor engineering?

Anyway, yeah. The second iteration will hopefully do away with the electrical masonry. On second thought who knows? In Soviet Union, they drink vodka. At Microsoft, they drink vodka and then approve the absurd.
Funny thing is my Xbox One is not noisy at all. I don't here fans or anything like that. In fact if you research it the Xbox One is actually whisper quiet compared to the Xbox 360. I would fact check about that so called noise...
Reply Helpful Comment? 2 0
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Nov 2008
L7: Teacher
2,579 Posts
369 Reputation
#8
I think Nov/Dec 2015 would be a excellent time to upgrade to the XBOX ONE with so many great titles out by then and better sales.
Reply Helpful Comment? 2 0
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Nov 2012
L3: Novice
115 Posts
75 Reputation
#9
Get a PS4. It's the better system between the two, and will get more varied and interesting exclusives starting next year.
Reply Helpful Comment? 1 4
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Jun 2014
L5: Journeyman
931 Posts
105 Reputation
#10
Quote from Technosquid
:
Eventually they'll release a version with the high-definition microphone built in, so you'll never need Kinect. Storage / Hybrid drive updates aside, they're still in hardware 1.0. Wait until the slim / 2.0 rev if you've waited this long.
very insightful...but too many good black friday deals to resist. picked up a 1TB Holiday Bundle for $313 out the door.

i suspect when the mike is added, it will be added to the controller, not the console, so it will be an upgrade that anyone can add by getting a new controller.
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
Last edited by schlack December 3, 2015 at 08:45 AM.
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Nov 2014
L2: Beginner
88 Posts
10 Reputation
#11
It's probably better to get something with VR capability like either a Windows PC with Vive or Oculus Rift or the upcoming upgraded PS4 with VR.
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users
Joined Dec 2007
L1: Learner
21 Posts
14 Reputation
#12
Quote from machaan
:
All true statements-I used to play PC games before buying my Xbox 360 in 2006. Here's why I don't play PC games anymore:
  1. In online multiplayer shooters, I get killed almost instantly after spwaning-I don't have the time nor skills to find cheats, macros, etc to outfox the super -techies.
  2. Every 6 months, there is a new processor, graphics card etc that gives the purchaser an added advantage online-again not interested in throwing money out the door.
  3. With the xbox, everybody has similar hardware, cheats are few and far in between and matchmaking is quick and painless.
  4. When I want to use a PC, I use my laptop which I can take with me into any room I want. If my gaming rig is also my computer, then I'm stuck in one spot-no added benefit of a PC gaming rig over the xbox.
  5. PC games are $50 as opposed to $60 for xbox-I buy a couple games a year-I'll be ok.
Ever heard of steam ?
Reply Helpful Comment? 0 0
Page 1 of 1
1
Join the Conversation
Add a Comment
 
Copyright 1999 - 2018. Slickdeals, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Copyright / Infringement Policy  •  Privacy Policy  •  Terms of Service  •  Acceptable Use Policy (Rules)  •  Interest-Based Ads
Link Copied to Clipboard