12 Month Xbox Live Gold - $39.99 - Microsoft Store Digital Subscription
My subscription is about to expire and was searching around online for options for getting another year in the $35-45 range.
Found a 12 month Xbox Live Gold Membership for only $39.99 a year. The only catch is you have to sign up for the auto-renew. The good news is immediately after signing up for the $39.99 you can turn off the auto-renew feature.