BDM Renewals (Best Deal Magazine's second, underground site) has 1 year subscriptions available for Cook's Country and Cook's Illustrated magazines available for $6.24 each per year. Two year subscriptions are available for $12.49 each.
- Yes, the website looks like it was designed in 1995.
- Yes, they are reliable. They have been around a very long time and I have ordered dozens of magazines from them without a problem.
- No, you're not required to order renewals only through this site. I have no idea why they have two different sites.
Cook's Country [bdmrenewals.com]
Cook's Illustrated [bdmrenewals.com]