From Bona Fide Mask: DUE TO AN INCREASE IN COVID-19 CASES WE ARE NOW OFFERING FREE DOMESTIC SHIPPING ON ALL KN95 FDA AUTHORIZED MASK ORDERS THRU 7/19/20! ALL ORDERS SHIP FROM OUR WAREHOUSE IN NEW YORK!
|
Hey guys don't want to burst your bubble, however, what you are talking about is not a filtration test, but one that has been propagated by social media. You have sadly been misinformed. The only actual liquid barrier test that is performed on respirator masks is for a small classification known as Surgical N95's, which are considered medical devices by the FDA. Also, liquid barrier protection is rated by ASTM and not NIOSH. Your standard N95 from 3m or Honeywell is not designed for liquid barrier protection and the ability of it to hold water has zero impact on filtration. I emailed Powecom after seeing some of these posts just to be sure and recieved the following back:
IT IS NOT scientific to test qualified KN95 masks by pouring water into them. The dripping test is just a rumor. Firstly, water will destroy the protection ability of the melt blown filtering layer, that means: Water will destroy the effectiveness of the face mask; Secondly, too much water has weight (universal force[Laugh]) , so too much water will drip. Also, : The first layer of nonwoven material can let O2 (= oxygen ) pass through the face mask. That is why, the 1st Layer of face mask cannot 100% block water, especially when there is too much (for example, a cup of Water , too much water !!) pour in the face mask. This is not a scientific test and should not be used. Below are links from actual testing reports from the NPPTL that may be helpful Guangzhou Powecom Labor Insurance Supplies Co., Ltd.KN95GB262699.2898.962020-211.1pdf icon [cdc.gov] Guangzhou Powecom Labor Insurance Supplies Co., Ltd.KN95GB262699.5698.182020-303.1pdf icon [cdc.gov] Just want to make sure you guys have all the information. N95's are not for liquid barrier protection and neither are KN95's. The only liquid barrier protection masks are real ASTM surgical masks and Surgical N95's, which right now should be reserved ONLY for healthcare professionals. |
Statement for the Medical Device Respirator recalls in Canada
Guangzhou Powecom Labor Insurance Supplies Co., Ltd hereby declare that the following two importers are not our purchasers.We have not found any information about the relevant companies in the sales records. Our company has an export license. All exports in our company's name are genuine.
There are many fake products on the market. The products that fail to pass the inspection in Canada are not exported by our company. Obviously these are fake.
Our main task in February, March and April is to provide the Chinese government with a large number of high-quality and qualified masks.We've been on the EUA list since April 3 . In fact ,CDC has always tested the quality of all respirators,in order to ensure that all the respirators imported to the United States are safe and up to standard. The following four test reports were issued by NPPTL and can be read on CDC website: https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npptl/R...SULTS.HTML
Government of Canada has issued a RECALL on these products.
Health Canada has determined that certain respirators that do not meet performance standards may pose a health and safety risk to users when used in a setting that requires 95% filtration (such as a health care settings).
https://healthycanadian
Useful links regarding mask reuse and cleaning:
USA today has a good simple article about mask cleaning, including N95 (same as KN95):
https://www.usatoday.co
Official recommendation from CDC :
https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/...xtuse.html
There's a dedicated website about disinfecting N95, contributed by renown researchers and professionals:
https://www.n95decon.or
https://www.n95decon.or
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
679 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
The one they sell at the local China market has 5 layers as well as the MIT CDC tested one.
Can't believe they pull something like this.
KF94 standard is good if you can find a legit supplier which is hard to find a legit one and there are counterfeit of KF94 by the Chinese manufacturers.
Watch out for Taiwanese face mask (N95, medical, surgical grade,) Taiwan just relax their export ban on face mask. And hopefully we can see em soon.
Another Chinese Brand to check out, Energy Fortress.
About Harley, I got some from color shield, but 3 out of 10 had welding issue. Their earloops were just loosely touched on masks.
I haven't done any researches on KF94 and not sure if all KF94 are with equally good or acceptable qualites.
let me try to find a screenshot and see if i can post it.
The one they sell at the local China market has 5 layers as well as the MIT CDC tested one.
Can't believe they pull something like this.
I checked before online at Jing Dong, China's version of Amazon, and in Powecome KN95 page, it clearly said 4 layers. It's for local market, not for export.
Here's a link for your reference: https://i-item.jd.com/69537103682.htm
Here's the screenshot: Attachment 9169355
Just not sure why the meltblown is right behind outer layer? what's the advantage for that design?
let me try to find a screenshot and see if i can post it.
I suppose I could email Powecom directly and ask them how many layers their masks have. I read through all 3 of the CDC reports (Chinese lettering and English were both tested separately and have different reports, one even has the May batch with QR code) for these masks and did not see any cross section images or mention of # of layers.
https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npptl/r...sults.html
Under test results you can see 3 separate batches of Powecom with 3 separate reports.
Hopefully the 5 layer ones are not counterfeit Powecom. Did they come with the QR code to verify authenticity?
Will report back on what Powecom says on # of layers.
They all have 5 layers as long as it is the Chinese version.
I have never bought the English version of the Powecom Kn95 so I would know.
But I do noticed that when the Chinese version Powecom Kn95 sold out on discount, the English version always has stock.
Attachment 9169376
Attachment 9169379
And here's the screenshot: Attachment 9169355
Just not sure why the meltblown is right behind outer layer? what's the advantage for that design?
The Chinese local version has Chinese characters and not "Powecom."
I suppose I could email Powecom directly and ask them how many layers their masks have. I read through all 3 of the CDC reports (Chinese lettering and English were both tested separately and have different reports, one even has the May batch with QR code) for these masks and did not see any cross section images or mention of # of layers.
https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npptl/r...sults.html
Under test results you can see 3 separate batches of Powecom with 3 separate reports.
Hopefully the 5 layer ones are not counterfeit Powecom. Did they come with the QR code to verify authenticity?
Will report back on what Powecom says on # of layers.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
They all have 5 layers as long as it is the Chinese version.
I have never bought the English version of the Powecom Kn95 so I would know.
But I do noticed that when the Chinese version Powecom Kn95 sold out on discount, the English version always has stock.
Attachment 9169376
Attachment 9169379
https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npptl/r...ed-508.pdf
It has a picture of the mask with chinese characters on it.
That's the one I have tested myself and did research with (in a quick and dirty way, not as scientific as the MIT CDC test of course as I don't have those test equipment and materials.)
I would still buy the BYD 20 bucks/ 50 masks or this Powecom KN95 till we have 3M, SAS, Honeywell, Kimberly Clark supply.
Suggestion: anyone can do these tests yourself:
waterproof testing the outer non-woven layer,
candle-blow test for leakage,
burning of the melt-blown/ static testing the polypropylene layer
and the laser pointer test if there are any hole for the polypropylene layer.
They all have 5 layers as long as it is the Chinese version.
I have never bought the English version of the Powecom Kn95 so I would know.
But I do noticed that when the Chinese version Powecom Kn95 sold out on discount, the English version always has stock.
Attachment 9169376
Attachment 9169379
The masks in your screenshot don't look like Powecom's typical green theme KN95. Also there's no carbon layer in their regular KN95 masks. Majority of masks I have are China version and they have 4 layers.
From its online store in Jing Dong. Apparently a China version with 4 Layers:
Attachment 9169415
May be Powecom has changed to 4 layers but I haven't seen it in the Chinese local version.
BTW, a Ton (literally) of kn95 grade polypropylene (the middle layer material) still sell for a few hundred thousands Yuan (chinese currency 7.2 to 1 USD)
while the below 80% filtration rated polypropylene has become junk and nobody want it even in the Chinese market.
From its online store in Jing Dong. Apparently a China version with 4 Layers:
Attachment 9169415
When first cut, the meltblown looked like one layer, but it actually separates.
I also have Powecom masks purchased from the Back to Normal site (early May batch, English packaging, no anti-fake labels yet), and the layers are pretty much identical.
My order from Bonafide will arrive this week, so I'll cut one up after I've had a chance to use one.
They all have 5 layers as long as it is the Chinese version.
I have never bought the English version of the Powecom Kn95 so I would know.
But I do noticed that when the Chinese version Powecom Kn95 sold out on discount, the English version always has stock.
Attachment 9169376
Attachment 9169379
Attachment 9169379
See the side by side Chinese vs English versions:
Attachment 9169472
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
When first cut, the meltblown looked like one layer, but it actually separates.
I also have Powecom masks purchased from the Back to Normal site (early May batch, English packaging, no anti-fake labels yet), and the layers are pretty much identical.
My order from Bonafide will arrive this week, so I'll cut one up after I've had a chance to use one.
Did you get shipment info from Bonafide? I didn't hear anything yet.
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!