Gamestop is selling Anthem Standard-edition for both XB1 and PS4 for $1.49 as pre-owned or $2.00 as new.
Pre-owned for XB1 is available for in-store pickup only. All other iterations are available for delivery.
Digital code otherwise priced at $59.99
Pre-owned should be just as good as new because after installation, the disc is used to verify the user-license and not to render the game. On the other hand, you can guarantee the disc's future condition for an additional $0.51.