Call Discover to cancel your credit card, they'll try to keep you
0Deal Score
2,041 Views
Hey I've finally got a slick deal to share with everybody. Call Discover (back of your card) and tell them you want to cancel. My particular credit card was the Discover IT card. They asked me why I wanted to cancel and I told them I was getting more cash back elsewhere. They offered me an extra 2% cash back on up to $7500 in purchases for the next year. They said that would be 3% cash back on all purchases and 7% cash back on the revolving quarterly purchases. That's good enough for me to at least try and make the effort of taking advantage of this over just cancelling the card so I signed up.
Bonus: If anybody gets them to offer a better deal than this let everybody know so we can all try for it.
Didn't offer me anything. And insisted and insisted, in trying to steer me away from closing the "Discover It" credit card account (and which in the meantime they have also tried to morph it into a "Discover Travel" card which was of no use to me). So I've closed it anyway.
Can't see why anyone would cancel a credit card\play this game and potentially take a hit to their credit score to get what amounts to an extra 1% roughly over what you can get on other cards. Just seems like a lot of effort for very little gain. And Discover card does not have any benefits any more of any note, so using it for purchases across the board is just not something one should do imo unless one has no other options.
Well when you've opened all the credit cards and used up their rewards you logically need to close them to get them again in the future
Discover has shit for "rewards" or benefits imo. The only thing they have left of note is the 5% rotating quarterly categories. Chase Freedom and others offer the same or similar. Chasing after a percent or two on such a crummy card is fine for what it is, but seems like more or less a waste of time and you are better off just going and signing up or a big bonus offer card and then canceling after a year. You will get far more value for you spent dollars imo.
Discover has shit for "rewards" or benefits imo. The only thing they have left of note is the 5% rotating quarterly categories. Chase Freedom and others offer the same or similar. Chasing after a percent or two on such a crummy card is fine for what it is, but seems like more or less a waste of time and you are better off just going and signing up or a big bonus offer card and then canceling after a year. You will get far more value for you spent dollars imo.
My 2 cents.
I half heartedly agree with you. I've closed a ton of credit cards lately and figure I'll be reapplying for rewards again eventually.
I'm not an expert in doing that. I'm not sure if I can turn right around and reapply and get a reward just after closing or if I gotta wait a while. I assumed I needed to wait a while and while I waited I figured I'll leave this Discover open and use the 3% cashback and 7% cashback quarterly. But yeah it's almost not worth messing with I agree.
Age of credit influences the credit score calculation. Not saying there is no gain to playing the signup bonus game but all the cancelling and starting new cards negatively affects your credit score. Potentially to the point you get a less-attractive interest rate on the card, your next car loan or mortgage and it costs you much more than those signup bonuses you got.
Just something to keep in mind. Age of credit is just one of many metrics in that magical credit score determination.
You really don't have to threaten them with a cancelation. They will easily give one year of zero interest on purchases. You just have to ask. Also they will give you some kind of spending bonus if you are a valued customer.
Age of credit influences the credit score calculation. Not saying there is no gain to playing the signup bonus game but all the cancelling and starting new cards negatively affects your credit score. Potentially to the point you get a less-attractive interest rate on the card, your next car loan or mortgage and it costs you much more than those signup bonuses you got.
Just something to keep in mind. Age of credit is just one of many metrics in that magical credit score determination.
You should never close your oldest cards, but closing ones you opened a year or so ago is not going to impact your score significantly for any meaningful length of time in most cases. Credit scores are based on age of credit and you get dinged slightly for opening new accounts. That ding is very small usually.
In most cases, what will lower your score on closing a new credit card is that your credit utilization % will increase because your available credit decreases when you close the card. So say if you had 2k in outstanding balances each month and a 50k credit limit among all your cards and then you close a CC that had a 10k limit. Your % utilization goes from 4% to 5%. In most cases this is not going to be too meaningful, but if you carry larger balances, esp. with just a few cards, it may increase that utilization percentage significantly.
That is why you should space out the getting and cancelling of cards and basically manage it. As to CC companies and banks, many will have limits and waiting periods on how often you can get a bonus and how many of their various cards you can do that with over a period of time.
11 Comments
Your comment cannot be blank.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Well damn, maybe this is ymmv
My 2 cents.
Discover has shit for "rewards" or benefits imo. The only thing they have left of note is the 5% rotating quarterly categories. Chase Freedom and others offer the same or similar. Chasing after a percent or two on such a crummy card is fine for what it is, but seems like more or less a waste of time and you are better off just going and signing up or a big bonus offer card and then canceling after a year. You will get far more value for you spent dollars imo.
My 2 cents.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
My 2 cents.
I half heartedly agree with you. I've closed a ton of credit cards lately and figure I'll be reapplying for rewards again eventually.
I'm not an expert in doing that. I'm not sure if I can turn right around and reapply and get a reward just after closing or if I gotta wait a while. I assumed I needed to wait a while and while I waited I figured I'll leave this Discover open and use the 3% cashback and 7% cashback quarterly. But yeah it's almost not worth messing with I agree.
Just something to keep in mind. Age of credit is just one of many metrics in that magical credit score determination.
Just something to keep in mind. Age of credit is just one of many metrics in that magical credit score determination.
You should never close your oldest cards, but closing ones you opened a year or so ago is not going to impact your score significantly for any meaningful length of time in most cases. Credit scores are based on age of credit and you get dinged slightly for opening new accounts. That ding is very small usually.
In most cases, what will lower your score on closing a new credit card is that your credit utilization % will increase because your available credit decreases when you close the card. So say if you had 2k in outstanding balances each month and a 50k credit limit among all your cards and then you close a CC that had a 10k limit. Your % utilization goes from 4% to 5%. In most cases this is not going to be too meaningful, but if you carry larger balances, esp. with just a few cards, it may increase that utilization percentage significantly.
That is why you should space out the getting and cancelling of cards and basically manage it. As to CC companies and banks, many will have limits and waiting periods on how often you can get a bonus and how many of their various cards you can do that with over a period of time.