4-Piece American Tourister Fieldbrook XLT Softside Upright Luggage (Black or Blue)

CrimsonRiver926

Feb 05, 2023 08:20 PM

455 Posts

Joined Aug 2019

CrimsonRiver926Feb 05, 2023 08:20 PM

455 Posts

Question. I saw a comment about this not having a spinner and that was a deal breaker. What exactly about a spinner makes it so worth it? Is it really so much more convenient than leaning it over on two wheels and rolling it that way? I've never had one, so not sure I've seen the benefits, but also have never seen a need for it.

1

tbongo

Feb 05, 2023 08:39 PM

110 Posts

Joined Dec 2011

tbongoFeb 05, 2023 08:39 PM

110 Posts

Quote from CrimsonRiver926

:

Question. I saw a comment about this not having a spinner and that was a deal breaker. What exactly about a spinner makes it so worth it? Is it really so much more convenient than leaning it over on two wheels and rolling it that way? I've never had one, so not sure I've seen the benefits, but also have never seen a need for it.

Spinners are really nice because you can roll them while they're standing upright. The increased directional mobility is also nice when they're dragged at an angle (less likely to flip over if you turn sharply). I still use both on trips, but over time, I can see replacing the non-spinners and not going back. I think it comes down to how particular you are about convenience.

2

zbs60

Feb 05, 2023 09:24 PM

659 Posts

Joined Aug 2008

zbs60Feb 05, 2023 09:24 PM

659 Posts

Never mind the wheels. The big piece isn't even lined. Theres multiple hex nut bolts sticking out. The way the baggage handlers throw luggage I could easily see how your clothes could be damaged

3

1

chris431

Feb 05, 2023 10:47 PM

672 Posts

Joined Aug 2010

chris431Feb 05, 2023 10:47 PM

672 Posts

Given the high risk of your luggage being stolen by presidential appointees (at least those not flying private while on their way to preach the eco doom message), this isn't such a bad deal.

Additionally, higher quality luggage signals to baggage handlers that your luggage is more likely to contain valuables worth stealing than does a cheap set of luggage.

6

3

acubsfan

Feb 06, 2023 12:49 AM

648 Posts

Joined Sep 2010

acubsfanFeb 06, 2023 12:49 AM

648 Posts

I bought five individual pieces from American Tourister years ago. The two small kids sized and one smaller carryon don't have spinners. Medium and large one do. They've been used and checked on 10+ trips so far, big one loaded to 40-45lbs typical. So far, other than getting a little dirty (one is checkered white and blue so it shows dirt, but is super easy to spot), they're functionally as good as ever. No issues with zippers, no tears, no sign of any problems.

I do see what someone mentioned about this one not being lined so entirely possible these are a lower end of their offerings. Mainly just noting they have at least some decent options that hold up relatively well.

Last edited by acubsfan February 5, 2023 at 04:52 PM.

toastedwhitebread

Pro

Feb 06, 2023 02:26 AM

2,448 Posts

Joined Mar 2011

toastedwhitebread

Pro

Feb 06, 2023 02:26 AM

2,448 Posts

Quote from tictaktoe

:

Are Americans that much hated?

It's funny too. Because if you travel internationally you will see that EVERY country is full of total snobbish idiots as well as dummies. Americans just have some sort of guilt trip going on lately so they let everyone pretend they are the only country of people capable of being oblivious as they go through life.

pdinc

Pro

Feb 06, 2023 02:45 AM

2,451 Posts

Joined Nov 2006

pdinc

Pro

Feb 06, 2023 02:45 AM

2,451 Posts

Quote from dentalsalespro

:

TravelPro is probably the best value I have found. They do have some lower quality ones that they sell through BJs which are not good. I buy direct through their website.

Their Walkabout series at Macys is a good compromise

mtvnjoy

Feb 06, 2023 04:33 AM

139 Posts

Joined Oct 2011

mtvnjoyFeb 06, 2023 04:33 AM

139 Posts

Got 40% off using $0.5 in amex points on Amazon.

1

MerryHill169

Feb 06, 2023 05:47 AM

231 Posts

Joined May 2018

MerryHill169Feb 06, 2023 05:47 AM

231 Posts

Should be illegal for airlines to change their allowable baggage dimensions.

saytoanand

Feb 06, 2023 12:11 PM

65 Posts

Joined Jul 2012

saytoanandFeb 06, 2023 12:11 PM

65 Posts

I got these similar line in the past (but fieldbrook II), they were trash and flimsy. I had to return them fortunately it was Amazon and easier to return. Don't believe the brand name, these were low quality cheap ones. I don't know why American tourister spoil their reputation with this filmsy stuff.

dentalsalespro

Feb 06, 2023 03:39 PM

1,406 Posts

Joined Aug 2011

dentalsalesproFeb 06, 2023 03:39 PM

1,406 Posts

Quote from pdinc

:

Their Walkabout series at Macys is a good compromise

That is an excellent suggestion. They look like they are having a closeout sale right now on the Walkabout - https://www.macys.com/shop/produc...D=10365509

1

iopinion

Feb 06, 2023 11:56 PM

23 Posts

Joined Jul 2017

iopinionFeb 06, 2023 11:56 PM

23 Posts

Quote from CrimsonRiver926

:

Question. I saw a comment about this not having a spinner and that was a deal breaker. What exactly about a spinner makes it so worth it? Is it really so much more convenient than leaning it over on two wheels and rolling it that way? I've never had one, so not sure I've seen the benefits, but also have never seen a need for it.

Once I started using spinner, I started hating myself for not knowing earlier the difference between 2 wheel and 4 wheel. Now i'm not bringing home a 2-wheel suitcase even if it is for free. That is how much i dislike 2-wheel ones.

spook02

Pro

Feb 07, 2023 10:13 AM

280 Posts

Joined Jul 2014

spook02

Pro

Feb 07, 2023 10:13 AM

280 Posts

These are decent brand bags. I was skeptical but this is a good deal if you can live without spinners. I've had this for 7 years now and big bags have had 8-10 trips (local and international). Carry on, I've probably put in 50+ trips on them. At $20/bag, no brainer (if you are fine without spinner)

bagarwa

Feb 08, 2023 12:58 AM

631 Posts

Joined Oct 2015

bagarwaFeb 08, 2023 12:58 AM

631 Posts

Quote from CrimsonRiver926

:

Question. I saw a comment about this not having a spinner and that was a deal breaker. What exactly about a spinner makes it so worth it? Is it really so much more convenient than leaning it over on two wheels and rolling it that way? I've never had one, so not sure I've seen the benefits, but also have never seen a need for it.

When your 25+" luggage is full and you have to drag it across the airport on two wheels, it starts weighing on your arms and after a while, the shoulder will also start aching. If you also have a backpack on your back, it gets worse.
A luggage with 4 spinner wheels are like sliced bread. You just push them around and they carry their own weight. You are not pulling on that weight.

Quote from dentalsalespro

:

That is an excellent suggestion. They look like they are having a closeout sale right now on the Walkabout - https://www.macys.com/shop/produc...D=10365509 [macys.com]

25" for $150, 29" for $170!! Still too pricey for me. Why are luggage either too cheap (4 piece set for < $100) or too costly (1 piece for > $150)? Frown

adi778899

Feb 12, 2023 04:19 PM

206 Posts

Joined Jan 2011

adi778899Feb 12, 2023 04:19 PM

206 Posts

Quote from BigPapa5

:

Is American tourister a decent brand? Middle of the line? Never used them before.

I have a 25" American Tourister and a 21" carry-on set bought in 2003 that I used on 2-3 international + 3-4 domestic trips/year. Both of them still in decent condition. Not my main luggages for since 2019 but still usable. Definitely worth the money. Also had some Walmart store brand Prestige 28" and 20" that held up decently over 15 years.

4-Piece American Tourister Fieldbrook XLT Softside Upright Luggage (Black or Blue)

$80

$190

Editor's Notes

Original Post

Editor's Notes

Original Post

Community Voting

Top Comments

Join The Conversation

34 Comments

Join The Conversation

Related Searches

Popular Deals

Trending Deals