Amazon has 6-Pack Amazon Basics Sponges (Non-Scratch or Heavy Duty) on sale for $3.58 when you checkout via Subscribe & Save. Shipping is free w/ Prime or on orders $25+.
Thanks to Community Member theon105 for finding this deal.
This collaborative space allows users to contribute additional information, tips, and insights to enhance the original deal post. Feel free to share your knowledge and help fellow shoppers make informed decisions.
Amazon has 6-Pack Amazon Basics Sponges (Non-Scratch or Heavy Duty) on sale for $3.58 when you checkout via Subscribe & Save. Shipping is free w/ Prime or on orders $25+.
Thanks to Community Member theon105 for finding this deal.
Has anyone actually tried these sponges? How do they compare to Scotch?
How much worse can these possibly be as compared with Scotch?
I've not tried these, but Scotch quality has been abysmal for a long time: I currently have two Scotch blue sponges in circulation at my kitchen sink ... chunks come off easily, they degrade rapidly, and the pad delaminates from the sponge in no time. It's nothing more than a well known brand name with a deep reputation emblazoned on a very low quality product. It never ceases to amaze me at how quickly they degrade.
Last edited by Lovegasoline March 22, 2023 at 03:18 PM.
How much worse can these be possibly be as compared with Scotch?
I've not tried these, but Scotch quality has been abysmal for a long time: I currently have two Scotch blue sponges in circulation at my kitchen sink ... chunks come off easily, they degrade rapidly, and the pad delaminates from the sponge in no time. It's nothing more than a well known brand name with a deep reputation emblazoned on a very low quality product. It never ceases to amaze me at how quickly they degrade.
I actually like the scotch ones a lot and haven't had issues, but if you're looking for longevity, the Scrub Daddy ones are actually excellent. Bit of an adjustment to get used it though; it's a thermopolymer that gets softer as it gets warmer. It's a lot more durable.
I actually like the scotch ones a lot and haven't had issues, but if you're looking for longevity, the Scrub Daddy ones are actually excellent. Bit of an adjustment to get used it though; it's a thermopolymer that gets softer as it gets warmer. It's a lot more durable.
I've never had a dishwasher and hand wash everything. I always have two dish brushes (one for cast iron and one for everything else) and two sponges (as a sponge wears out it's demoted to general kitchen cleaning, tables/sink, etc). Scotch are like all the other cheap sponges and degrade quickly but have succeeded with name recognition.
Check out O-Cedar Scrunge for a a more durable sponge which also has a more effective non-scratch 'abrasive' side (at least initially, it will wear down in time). They're more expensive than Scotch brand. Disclaimer: it's been a while since I've used them (and too many manufacturers routinely cheapen their products while charging the same - or more - in order to make a few more pennies profit).
I've never had a dishwasher and hand wash everything. I always have two dish brushes (one for cast iron and one for everything else) and two sponges (as a sponge wears out it's demoted to general kitchen cleaning, tables/sink, etc). Scotch are like all the other cheap sponges and degrade quickly but have succeeded with name recognition.
Check out O-Cedar Scrunge for a a more durable sponge which also has a more effective non-scratch 'abrasive' side (at least initially, it will wear down in time). They're more expensive than Scotch brand. Disclaimer: it's been a while since I've used them (and too many manufacturers routinely cheapen their products while charging the same - or more - in order to make a few more pennies profit).
Yeah, though scotch is my baseline as the even cheaper ones tend to really fall apart and be terrible.
Should have clarified; the scrub daddy is interesting because its so different from regular sponges. It's not quite as absorbent, which means it tends to not retain as much of the grease and grime, but it's a looser structure, so it tends to hold the detergent better. It's also a bit firmer and less prone to felting than the usual scrubber side of sponges.
That being said... I've used scotch for years and I just replace them frequently when I notice them wearing out. The ones no longer fit for dish service become the ones I use to scrub down the sink and range, and so forth. Just be on top of that and there shouldn't be many issues.
I've done a lot of dishwashing (old world household) and hate it, and have tried to make as many things as I can dishwasher safe, but I still have to handwash a good amount (the occasional non-stick pan, my cast iron and carbon steel stuff, and of course, my knives). So the sponge still sees a lot of use.
Most of the 4-star reviews are complaining how they are falling apart and not strong and yet 4-stars!
I still use these types of sponges, but more often use separate scour pads like these, or cheaper dollar store ones https://www.amazon.com/Scotch-Bri...B0196H6TKM
in conjunction with the skoy pads https://www.amazon.com/Skoy-Eco-f...B00275BB6S
put the scrub pad under the skoy to scour my cast iron or other pans, then soap and wipe dry with the skoy. The skoy rinsed out, removes water so better than sponge or any other dishcloth on cookware and countertops that no towels are needed.
The combo is more effective and lasts a lot longer than sponges.
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
26 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
I've not tried these, but Scotch quality has been abysmal for a long time: I currently have two Scotch blue sponges in circulation at my kitchen sink ... chunks come off easily, they degrade rapidly, and the pad delaminates from the sponge in no time. It's nothing more than a well known brand name with a deep reputation emblazoned on a very low quality product. It never ceases to amaze me at how quickly they degrade.
I've not tried these, but Scotch quality has been abysmal for a long time: I currently have two Scotch blue sponges in circulation at my kitchen sink ... chunks come off easily, they degrade rapidly, and the pad delaminates from the sponge in no time. It's nothing more than a well known brand name with a deep reputation emblazoned on a very low quality product. It never ceases to amaze me at how quickly they degrade.
Check out O-Cedar Scrunge for a a more durable sponge which also has a more effective non-scratch 'abrasive' side (at least initially, it will wear down in time). They're more expensive than Scotch brand. Disclaimer: it's been a while since I've used them (and too many manufacturers routinely cheapen their products while charging the same - or more - in order to make a few more pennies profit).
https://www.amazon.com/Cedar-Mult...120&sr=8-3
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Check out O-Cedar Scrunge for a a more durable sponge which also has a more effective non-scratch 'abrasive' side (at least initially, it will wear down in time). They're more expensive than Scotch brand. Disclaimer: it's been a while since I've used them (and too many manufacturers routinely cheapen their products while charging the same - or more - in order to make a few more pennies profit).
https://www.amazon.com/Cedar-Mult...120&sr=8-3 [amazon.com]
Should have clarified; the scrub daddy is interesting because its so different from regular sponges. It's not quite as absorbent, which means it tends to not retain as much of the grease and grime, but it's a looser structure, so it tends to hold the detergent better. It's also a bit firmer and less prone to felting than the usual scrubber side of sponges.
That being said... I've used scotch for years and I just replace them frequently when I notice them wearing out. The ones no longer fit for dish service become the ones I use to scrub down the sink and range, and so forth. Just be on top of that and there shouldn't be many issues.
I've done a lot of dishwashing (old world household) and hate it, and have tried to make as many things as I can dishwasher safe, but I still have to handwash a good amount (the occasional non-stick pan, my cast iron and carbon steel stuff, and of course, my knives). So the sponge still sees a lot of use.
https://www.amazon.com/Scotch-Bri...B0196H6TK
in conjunction with the skoy pads
https://www.amazon.com/Skoy-Eco-f...B00275BB6S
put the scrub pad under the skoy to scour my cast iron or other pans, then soap and wipe dry with the skoy. The skoy rinsed out, removes water so better than sponge or any other dishcloth on cookware and countertops that no towels are needed.
The combo is more effective and lasts a lot longer than sponges.
problem is it will also speed the deterioration of the sponge
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!