This collaborative space allows users to contribute additional information, tips, and insights to enhance the original deal post. Feel free to share your knowledge and help fellow shoppers make informed decisions.
This isn't a good deal for $180 unless you are banking on the Costco returns. $180 is a pretty average price for a 4TB QLC drive these days; you can get much better YMTC Nand or a better controller for the same price.
Pros:
It's from Costco so in theory you can return it forever.
Very high 3200TBW for a QLC
Cons:
Controller is InnoGrit IG5236, which is a low end one from 2021 with known firmware issues. Either Lexar fixed it as this is a new product or this is never going to be patched. It's a PS5 marketed drive so the tech competency for the average buyer for this product is effectively negative -> review has 0 value.
Very low end Intel/Solidigm QLC
Researched my own question:
This SSD is the Costco exclusive "SE" version of the normal PLAY model. It's a little slower and is QLC instead of TLC. If it were the normal TLC PLAY version, it would be almost identical to the M790, but that's not quite the case here as it's the downgraded QLC version.
This 4TB Lexar PLAY 2280 SE is a Costco exclusive PCIe 4.0 SSD aimed at PS5 and large game libraries, with a heatsink, 7,000 MB per second read speeds, and a 5 year warranty. The main appeal is the storage capacity and Costco return policy, which makes it feel low risk for buyers who need space now. The big caveat is that this SE version is the downgraded QLC, DRAMless model with an InnoGrit controller, so it is less attractive for heavy writes, video editing, or cache use. For mostly static game storage, it still looks like a practical fit.
Costco members who want a low-risk way to get 4TB storage now because multiple commenters pointed out Costco's return policy can make the purchase safer if the drive fails, even if "lifetime" returns depend on how the CSR handles eligibility.
PS5 owners who want to expand storage for game downloads and mostly read data because commenters said even a slower PCIe 4.0 SSD worked fine on PS5 with many 100GB+ AAA games, and this one should be even faster for that use.
People buying a 4TB SSD specifically for mostly static workloads like installing AAA games with only occasional updates because commenters noted QLC's main weakness is write performance, so it's "just fine" when files don't change much.
Desktop users planning to do video editing, heavy file management, or use the SSD as a cache drive because commenters warned that QLC drives are not recommended for those kinds of write-heavy or frequently changing workloads.
Buyers who care about controller quality and firmware reliability because commenters specifically called out the InnoGrit IG5236 controller as low-end with known firmware issues, arguing the $180 price isn't good unless you're relying on returns.
People who want to avoid DRAM-less designs because commenters said the drive is DRAM-less and strongly discouraged the purchase ("RUN AWAY" / "Trashtier").
At $179.99, it is a fair price if you want 4TB now and value Costco's return policy, but it is not a standout bargain for a QLC drive. Comparable TLC drives and alternatives like the Crucial T500, Samsung 990 EVO Plus, or WD Black SN7100 have been cited around the $200-$210 range.
The Costco-exclusive PLAY 2280 SE is the downgraded SE version of the normal PLAY model and is described as QLC rather than TLC. It is also reported as DRAM-less with HMB and an InnoGrit IG5236 controller, so it is not the same drive as the regular TLC PLAY version.
Costco purchases can fall under its lifetime return handling, but the practical limit depends on the item category and the CSR processing the return. Computer hardware is argued to be outside the 90-day electronics restriction, yet returns after many years may still be questioned at the counter.
It should work well for PS5 game storage and loading, since a 5000/4200 MB/s SSD has already been used without issues and this drive is faster on paper. The main caution is that it is better suited to installing and reading games than to heavy desktop workloads like video editing or cache use.
For all my more technical friends, if I just need more space to store these 100gb AAA games and I have a budget of $200 for a 4tb drive, what else would you recommend instead of this one?
And would the other ones offer performance gains for ps5? Maybe for desktop usage but we're talking ps5 here.
This isn't a good deal for $180 unless you are banking on the Costco returns. $180 is a pretty average price for a 4TB QLC drive these days; you can get much better YMTC Nand or a better controller for the same price.
Pros:
It's from Costco so in theory you can return it forever.
Very high 3200TBW for a QLC
Cons:
Controller is InnoGrit IG5236, which is a low end one from 2021 with known firmware issues. Either Lexar fixed it as this is a new product or this is never going to be patched. It's a PS5 marketed drive so the tech competency for the average buyer for this product is effectively negative -> review has 0 value.
Very low end Intel/Solidigm QLC
For under $50 a TB? And most of these big drives are QLC. What planet are you living on? Lol calls this shoddy and return plagued but then counters with a CHINESE branded product like YMTC...
Computers and electronics aren't covered by that. They have a 90 day return policy.
Not this item tho. The item category must be explicitly mentioned in the 90 day return policy to be included in it. Ssd, monitors, game consoles... Are not included
For under $50 a TB? And most of these big drives are QLC. What planet are you living on? Lol calls this shoddy and return plagued but then counters with a CHINESE branded product like YMTC...
In no world are 4 TB SSD so "big" that 4TB is mostly QLC. Completely backwards: many 4TB SSDs are TLC, in fact.
$50 / TB is not worth it for junk QLC. See the TLC-based Western Digital SN7100 for $210: $52.50 / TB vs your claimed $50 / TB. You won't pay 4% more for TLC? Bad move.
And the cherry on top for this nonsense comment: Lexar has been owned by China-based Longsys for almost a decade now. How did you not know that? Not unexpected from a commenter that capitalizes "Chinese" lmao.
Researched my own question:
This SSD is the Costco exclusive "SE" version of the normal PLAY model. It's a little slower and is QLC instead of TLC. If it were the normal TLC PLAY version, it would be almost identical to the M790, but that's not quite the case here as it's the downgraded QLC version.
Thanks for pointing that out.
Was able to get the regular version couple months back for $180 on Amazon. Was initially bummed at seeing OP post as I would definitely prefer buying from Costco- but SE being a slightly downgraded version, not so bummed.
For all my more technical friends, if I just need more space to store these 100gb AAA games and I have a budget of $200 for a 4tb drive, what else would you recommend instead of this one?
The Samsung 990 EVO Plus was on sale for $200 recently. The WD Black SN7100 is currently $210. I'd even take a WD QLC drive (like the SN5000) over this one (due to the Innogrit controller).
2
Like
Helpful
Funny
Not helpful
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
This is IMO an incredible value for 4tb at similar value to other drives priced at $220~250, and it's sold from Costco, with 5yr warranty included from Lexar.
I'm not sure about using it in a PS5 or Rog Ally or something cause the random write/read is mid and HMB.
Any heat issues are negated from the included heatsink IMO, but again it will run hot on heavy loads regardless cause of the controller version. But to be honest it's still way better than anything else in the same price range.
<br />
The 4TB Crucial T500 was $200 back in July on Amazon but only for a day before it sold out. It's Micron TLC, has DRAM, Phison E25 controller and 5 year warranty. I would expect it to hit $200 again around Black Friday/Cyber Monday.<br />
<br /> https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-c...ssd-review
I doubt it. Everyone is saying that all storage media is facing shortages due to AI and are likely to rise in price for the foreseeable future rather than falling.
Quote
from ilovetype
:
This is a Costco exclusive. Found some more reviews and benchmarks<br />
<br /> https://www.techpowerup.com/33942...ystation-5<br />
<br /> https://www.tweaktown.com/reviews...index.html<br />
<br />
This is IMO an incredible value for 4tb at similar value to other drives priced at $220~250, and it's sold from Costco, with 5yr warranty included from Lexar. <br />
<br />
I'm not sure about using it in a PS5 or Rog Ally or something cause the random write/read is mid and HMB. <br />
<br />
Any heat issues are negated from the included heatsink IMO, but again it will run hot on heavy loads regardless cause of the controller version. But to be honest it's still way better than anything else in the same price range.
Any PC can have HMB support with the right drivers. Only the PS5 would suffer from lack of HMB.
For under $50 a TB? And most of these big drives are QLC. What planet are you living on? Lol calls this shoddy and return plagued but then counters with a CHINESE branded product like YMTC...
Yeah i'd agree. not an insane deal but an okay one. and arrogance in the comment to lol
For all my more technical friends, if I just need more space to store these 100gb AAA games and I have a budget of $200 for a 4tb drive, what else would you recommend instead of this one?
You would be just fine. The real issue on QLC's is more of a write issue than a read issue, so if your files are gonna be pretty static (as in a AAA game which gets occasional updates), yeah, this is just fine.I wouldn't video edit or do mass file management or use it as some sort of cache drive.
Like
Helpful
Funny
Not helpful
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Top Comments
Pros:
It's from Costco so in theory you can return it forever.
Very high 3200TBW for a QLC
Cons:
Controller is InnoGrit IG5236, which is a low end one from 2021 with known firmware issues. Either Lexar fixed it as this is a new product or this is never going to be patched. It's a PS5 marketed drive so the tech competency for the average buyer for this product is effectively negative -> review has 0 value.
Very low end Intel/Solidigm QLC
This SSD is the Costco exclusive "SE" version of the normal PLAY model. It's a little slower and is QLC instead of TLC. If it were the normal TLC PLAY version, it would be almost identical to the M790, but that's not quite the case here as it's the downgraded QLC version.
Normal PLAY version review:
https://thepcenthusiast
SE Edition review:
https://www.pcworld.com/article/2...eview.html
Community Reviews
This 4TB Lexar PLAY 2280 SE is a Costco exclusive PCIe 4.0 SSD aimed at PS5 and large game libraries, with a heatsink, 7,000 MB per second read speeds, and a 5 year warranty. The main appeal is the storage capacity and Costco return policy, which makes it feel low risk for buyers who need space now. The big caveat is that this SE version is the downgraded QLC, DRAMless model with an InnoGrit controller, so it is less attractive for heavy writes, video editing, or cache use. For mostly static game storage, it still looks like a practical fit.
Common Questions (4)
At $179.99, it is a fair price if you want 4TB now and value Costco's return policy, but it is not a standout bargain for a QLC drive. Comparable TLC drives and alternatives like the Crucial T500, Samsung 990 EVO Plus, or WD Black SN7100 have been cited around the $200-$210 range.
The Costco-exclusive PLAY 2280 SE is the downgraded SE version of the normal PLAY model and is described as QLC rather than TLC. It is also reported as DRAM-less with HMB and an InnoGrit IG5236 controller, so it is not the same drive as the regular TLC PLAY version.
Costco purchases can fall under its lifetime return handling, but the practical limit depends on the item category and the CSR processing the return. Computer hardware is argued to be outside the 90-day electronics restriction, yet returns after many years may still be questioned at the counter.
It should work well for PS5 game storage and loading, since a 5000/4200 MB/s SSD has already been used without issues and this drive is faster on paper. The main caution is that it is better suited to installing and reading games than to heavy desktop workloads like video editing or cache use.
AI-generated summary based on comments from the community. Updated ago
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
40 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Pros:
It's from Costco so in theory you can return it forever.
Very high 3200TBW for a QLC
Cons:
Controller is InnoGrit IG5236, which is a low end one from 2021 with known firmware issues. Either Lexar fixed it as this is a new product or this is never going to be patched. It's a PS5 marketed drive so the tech competency for the average buyer for this product is effectively negative -> review has 0 value.
Very low end Intel/Solidigm QLC
Computers and electronics aren't covered by that. They have a 90 day return policy.
Computers and electronics aren't covered by that. They have a 90 day return policy.
$50 / TB is not worth it for junk QLC. See the TLC-based Western Digital SN7100 for $210: $52.50 / TB vs your claimed $50 / TB. You won't pay 4% more for TLC? Bad move.
And the cherry on top for this nonsense comment: Lexar has been owned by China-based Longsys for almost a decade now. How did you not know that? Not unexpected from a commenter that capitalizes "Chinese" lmao.
This SSD is the Costco exclusive "SE" version of the normal PLAY model. It's a little slower and is QLC instead of TLC. If it were the normal TLC PLAY version, it would be almost identical to the M790, but that's not quite the case here as it's the downgraded QLC version.
Normal PLAY version review:
https://thepcenthusiast
SE Edition review:
https://www.pcworld.com/article/2...eview.html
Was able to get the regular version couple months back for $180 on Amazon. Was initially bummed at seeing OP post as I would definitely prefer buying from Costco- but SE being a slightly downgraded version, not so bummed.
FYI here is another review of the regular TLC version from Tom's Hardware:
https://www.tomshardwar
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Any justifiable cause that this can be done without feeling guilty?
https://www.techpowerup
https://www.tweaktown.c
This is IMO an incredible value for 4tb at similar value to other drives priced at $220~250, and it's sold from Costco, with 5yr warranty included from Lexar.
I'm not sure about using it in a PS5 or Rog Ally or something cause the random write/read is mid and HMB.
Any heat issues are negated from the included heatsink IMO, but again it will run hot on heavy loads regardless cause of the controller version. But to be honest it's still way better than anything else in the same price range.
The 4TB Crucial T500 was $200 back in July on Amazon but only for a day before it sold out. It's Micron TLC, has DRAM, Phison E25 controller and 5 year warranty. I would expect it to hit $200 again around Black Friday/Cyber Monday.<br />
<br />
https://www.tomshardwar
<br />
https://www.techpowerup
<br />
https://www.tweaktown.c
<br />
This is IMO an incredible value for 4tb at similar value to other drives priced at $220~250, and it's sold from Costco, with 5yr warranty included from Lexar. <br />
<br />
I'm not sure about using it in a PS5 or Rog Ally or something cause the random write/read is mid and HMB. <br />
<br />
Any heat issues are negated from the included heatsink IMO, but again it will run hot on heavy loads regardless cause of the controller version. But to be honest it's still way better than anything else in the same price range.
QLC Drive
Is it dramless too? Oh god it is, RUN AWAY. Trashtier
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
edit: this wasn't in the description when I added this comment.
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!