This post can be edited by most users to provide up-to-date information about developments of this thread based on user responses, and user findings. Feel free to add, change or remove information shown here as it becomes available. This includes new coupons, rebates, ideas, thread summary, and similar items.
Once a Thread Wiki is added to a thread, "Create Wiki" button will disappear. If you would like to learn more about Thread Wiki feature, click here.
expired
Select BJs Wholesale Expired Accounts: 1-Yr BJs Wholesale Club Membership Renewal
$5.00
$60
91% off
BJs Wholesale
Top Comments
Currently Expires 2/28/2026
Had to open a new private browser otherwise just a blank screen.
(when signed in got the following)
Community Reviews
This BJ's renewal deal is a very cheap way to reactivate an expired membership, with the best results coming from the posted renewal link after signing in first. The $5 price often shows up correctly even when the promo code fails, and some accounts can be renewed through chat or on a phone or computer browser. The main catch is eligibility, since current members, active accounts, and some long expired accounts may be pushed to a $20 Plus upgrade or blocked entirely. Auto renew can also turn back on, so it is worth checking the renewal settings afterward.
Common Questions (5)
The most reliable flow is to sign in first, then click the posted renewal link in a web browser. If the page is blank or the code errors, opening a private window, using a different browser or device, or pasting the direct renewal URL after logging in can make it load correctly.
Yes. Chat support can sometimes redeem the code manually, including for memberships that are not yet expired or that were trying to renew as Club+ for $20. In some cases they also fixed account issues like the wrong membership type or a failed checkout.
Usually yes, but the new expiration date follows BJ's timing rules: renewals within about two months of expiration often extend from the old expiration date, while later renewals can set the new term from the end of the renewal month. That can make the result look shorter than 12 months if you renew near month-end or after a long lapse.
Yes. The offer is for already-expired memberships; current or new members may see a $20 Club+ upgrade or an eligibility error instead. If your account is still active, the deal can apply only to the remaining term rather than extending a full year.
Yes. The renewal can automatically enable Easy Renewal and later charge the standard $60 annual fee unless you disable auto-renew in account settings or cancel before the listed renewal date.
AI-generated summary based on comments from the community. Updated ago
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
251 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
There are several things we detest about Costco - often snotty employees (they usually push across your path rather than deferring to the customer, as an example. It's clear they feel their employment is for life), crappy app, Costco.com (really a different company), and buyers who will sacrifice a vendor for a few pennies. But the fact remains, we spend the most there. And they sell Top Tier gas, pretty much required if you have very common GDI ("Direct Injection") engine vehicles.
Sams has the best app by far of the three - Scan & Go is amazing, as well as the automatic exit arches (you have to use a shopping cart for it to work). But we buy very little at Sams - they've dropped a lot of the stuff we used to buy. And their gas lines, no matter how short, are SLOW, at least around us. One big plus - when they clear out old inventory, they don't mess around - heavy discounts.
BJs has more choices in many grocery categories, but their general merchandise tends toward crappy. You have to live in their "digital coupon hell" to make their prices competitive and sometimes the coupon values are really solid. (I should mention we live in a highly competitive grocery market.) But there are stretches where the coupons are useless for what we buy. We've found their Corporate Customer Service to be mediocre - the fact we know this about BJs and can't really comment about the other two speaks volumes. We laughed out loud when BJs raised their annual fee to $60. The only time we renew is when they offer $25 or less. One key thing about the BJs around us - our closest one is really mediocre - the other further away locations are better. All of them around us were cleared land, ground up new builds.
After repeatedly trying all of the helpful tricks others have posted with no success, I decided to reach out to their support team. I just got off of a looong chat with with a CSR and, even though I have periodically been a member in the past, they have no record it. The poor agent searched by my name, email address, phone number(s), home address, and even my old membership number after I unearthed a membership card from when I joined in 2019. 😅
It seems that I have completely disappeared from their database. Apparently, I am 💀 to them (even though I was getting the pop-up saying I wasn't eligible for the promotion since I'm a current member -- which I'm not).
So, since in their system I have no "past" expired membership, I cannot renew it.
Go figure! 😄
Hopefully, it's just me and others won't be rejected similarly.
(Note: My past membership was from a Groupon voucher, but the agent didn't suggest that this was the issue. And, it was clearly actively used at the time.)
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
"Your One Day Pass Has Expired
Purchase your BJ's Membership to continue to access great savings."
But this renewal offer page says "As a current member, you're not yet eligible for this offer."
Here's what is says under 'My Membership' website page: Your BJ's Membership will automatically renew on 11/01/2026.
A fee of $60 (plus applicable tax) for annual renewal of all memberships on your account will be charged to your default payment method below. If we cannot successfully charge your renewal fee on our initial billing attempt, for your convenience we will make additional attempts using any payment method(s) we have on record for your membership.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!