Slickdeals is community-supported.  We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
frontpage
charliebats | Staff 3.6K Views
Yesterday 11:50 PM

Select Accts: 16-Oz 365 by Whole Foods Market Crunchy Peanut Butter (Unsweetened)

$2.00

$2.99

33% off
w/ S&Sat Amazon
Get Deal at Amazon
Good Deal?
18Comments
Save
Share
Deal Details
Amazon has for Select Accounts: 16-Oz 365 by Whole Foods Market Crunchy Peanut Butter (Unsweetened) for $2.49 - 15% when you 'clip' the coupon on product page - 5% off when you check out via Subscribe & Save = $2. Shipping is free with Prime or on $35+ orders.

Thanks to Deal Hunter charliebats for sharing this deal.

Note: You must be logged into your account. Coupons are typically one-time use and availability may vary by account. Manage subscriptions anytime after your order ships. Add filler/deals & save up to 15% w/ 5+ monthly items.

Product Details:
  • Made with dry roasted peanuts and sea salt
  • Kosher and Non-GMO certified
  • Natural oil separation - stir before using
  • Refrigerate after opening to slow separation
  • No added preservatives or sugar
  • Perfect for sandwiches and recipes
  • Crunchy texture with real peanut pieces
  • Natural oil separation - stir before using
  • Refrigerate after opening to slow separation

Editor's Notes

Written by ValPal2011 | Staff

Original Post

Community Notes
About the Poster
Deal Details
Community Notes
About the Poster
Amazon has for Select Accounts: 16-Oz 365 by Whole Foods Market Crunchy Peanut Butter (Unsweetened) for $2.49 - 15% when you 'clip' the coupon on product page - 5% off when you check out via Subscribe & Save = $2. Shipping is free with Prime or on $35+ orders.

Thanks to Deal Hunter charliebats for sharing this deal.

Note: You must be logged into your account. Coupons are typically one-time use and availability may vary by account. Manage subscriptions anytime after your order ships. Add filler/deals & save up to 15% w/ 5+ monthly items.

Product Details:
  • Made with dry roasted peanuts and sea salt
  • Kosher and Non-GMO certified
  • Natural oil separation - stir before using
  • Refrigerate after opening to slow separation
  • No added preservatives or sugar
  • Perfect for sandwiches and recipes
  • Crunchy texture with real peanut pieces
  • Natural oil separation - stir before using
  • Refrigerate after opening to slow separation

Editor's Notes

Written by ValPal2011 | Staff

Original Post

Community Voting

Deal Score
+27
Good Deal
Bad Deal

Join The Conversation

Share your experience with the Slickdeals community

Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!

18 Comments

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Today 12:50 AM
1.5K Comments
Joined Mar 2012
dogtagz12Today 12:50 AM
1.5K Comments
How is it unsweetened but has sugar from salt and peanuts only?
1
2
Today 12:54 AM
1.5K Comments
Joined Jan 2017
andrewmc23Today 12:54 AM
1.5K Comments
Quote from dogtagz12 View quoted comment :
How is it unsweetened but has sugar from salt and peanuts only?
No added sugar
Today 1:13 AM
2.7K Comments
Joined Oct 2003
HRocketsToday 1:13 AM
2.7K Comments
No 15% off S&S for me but it does show a 10% off 4 (click "shop items" if you want 4 different things instead of 4 PB).
Pro
Global Mod
Today 1:27 AM
1.4K Comments
Joined Jun 2006
Mbilo
Pro
Global Mod
Today 1:27 AM
1.4K Comments
Quote from dogtagz12 View quoted comment :
How is it unsweetened but has sugar from salt and peanuts only?
looks like peanuts have a little sugar in them:
https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/food-det.../nutrients
Today 2:27 AM
239 Comments
Joined Feb 2018
Macseed07Today 2:27 AM
239 Comments
The reviews aren't encouraging.
Expert
This user is an Expert in Home & Home Improvement
Today 2:32 AM
7.8K Comments
Joined Oct 2014
firebirdude
Expert
This user is an Expert in Home & Home Improvement
Today 2:32 AM
7.8K Comments
Quote from dogtagz12 View quoted comment :
How is it unsweetened but has sugar from salt and peanuts only?
Wait until you see how much sugar a raw apple has.
1
Today 2:44 AM
1.1K Comments
Joined Oct 2004
nissinToday 2:44 AM
1.1K Comments
If you have a Aldi's or grocery outlet nearby. They are probably similar in pricing.
1

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Today 2:54 AM
3.2K Comments
Joined May 2011
Guy767Today 2:54 AM
3.2K Comments
Beware, Oily Horror awaits! This is the type of peanut butter you need to stir about 1 inch of oil that unappetizingly floats to the top. In my experience, no matter how much you mix, the slimy greasy abomination remains. I'm staying the heck away that's for sure laugh out loud
7
Today 3:48 AM
1.3K Comments
Joined Dec 2005
candelabraToday 3:48 AM
1.3K Comments
Quote from dogtagz12 View quoted comment :
How is it unsweetened but has sugar from salt and peanuts only?
Quote from andrewmc23 View quoted comment :
No added sugar
I bought the No Sugar Added Klondike Bars the other day. WTF. Picked naturally from the Klondike Bar Tree I guess. Meaningless. I guess that's not a regulated statement yet.
1
Today 3:50 AM
1.3K Comments
Joined Dec 2005
candelabraToday 3:50 AM
1.3K Comments
Quote from Guy767 View quoted comment :
Beware, Oily Horror awaits! This is the type of peanut butter you need to stir about 1 inch of oil that unappetizingly floats to the top. In my experience, no matter how much you mix, the slimy greasy abomination remains. I'm staying the heck away that's for sure laugh out loud
I asked the AMZN AI does it separate, and it said up to 2-3 in oil. No way. I had Costco almond butter like that, kept it in the fridge, which made it awful to mix. It migrated to the back of the fridge then got the heave ho and space recovery after a few years of non-use.

Good luck!

Edit: Here you go best use of AI ever IMO, gross:

does it separate
Yes, the separation is natural. The 365 by Whole Foods Market Crunchy Peanut Butter has no stabilizers, so oil rises to the top. The listing says to stir before using and refrigerate after opening to slow the separation.
Customer experience:
• Stirring: customers report it's hard to stir back in; some say it took several minutes
• Oil on top: many describe a quarter to half inch, and some report 2 to 3 inches
• Consistency: the most common complaint is that it's runny

Customers who like it praise the simple ingredients: peanuts and salt only.
Overall: if you don't mind stirring, it works. If you want a smooth, no-stir spread, look for a peanut butter with stabilizers.
Last edited by candelabra November 17, 2026 at 08:53 PM.
1
Today 3:54 AM
753 Comments
Joined Dec 2012
litesdsdToday 3:54 AM
753 Comments
Quote from Guy767 View quoted comment :
Beware, Oily Horror awaits! This is the type of peanut butter you need to stir about 1 inch of oil that unappetizingly floats to the top. In my experience, no matter how much you mix, the slimy greasy abomination remains. I'm staying the heck away that's for sure laugh out loud
Ahh, spoken like a typical American. When you open the jar, mix the oil and peanuts, then refrigerate. That's the price you pay for treating your body to unprocessed food. Oil separation is natural. When oil doesn't separate from the peanut butter, it indicates the peanut butter has been hydrogenated.
1
Today 4:09 AM
1.5K Comments
Joined Jan 2017
andrewmc23Today 4:09 AM
1.5K Comments
Quote from candelabra View quoted comment :
I bought the No Sugar Added Klondike Bars the other day. WTF. Picked naturally from the Klondike Bar Tree I guess. Meaningless. I guess that's not a regulated statement yet.
That's different. They have to add some sort of sweetener in ice cream
Today 4:37 AM
3.2K Comments
Joined May 2011
Guy767Today 4:37 AM
3.2K Comments
Quote from litesdsd View quoted comment :
Ahh, spoken like a typical American. When you open the jar, mix the oil and peanuts, then refrigerate. That's the price you pay for treating your body to unprocessed food. Oil separation is natural. When oil doesn't separate from the peanut butter, it indicates the peanut butter has been hydrogenated.
Yeah, yeah, I know all about the benefits of unappetizing oily peanut butter so get off your greasy high horse laugh out loud

What's the point of it being healthier if you find it absolutely disgusting? I think it's a generational thing, I grew up in the late 80's and early 90's and peanut butter was never so oily that it looked like something from Slimer's butthole (Ghostbusters) .I never can become acclimated to such lubricious horrors, health be dammed...
1
Today 4:46 AM
654 Comments
Joined Aug 2008
taipanToday 4:46 AM
654 Comments
You can stir and refrigerate natural peanut butter, or you can choose to eat fully hydrogenated oils they use to replace the natural peanut oil. They then sell the peanut oil at a premium, since it is a healthier oil option for things like frying, and then sell you the same peanuts but mixed with cheaper rapeseed, cottonseed, palm, and/or soybean oils. If you eat peanut butter, you're going to eat the oil either way but the "no-stir" is just a version containing fats that are solid at room temperature and more likely to raise cholesterol and increase risk for heart disease.

The PB2 or PBFit peanut powders allow you to mix in water or hydration option of your choice and sell the peanut oil pressed from those powdered peanuts. Both the pressed out peanut oil and oil-free peanut powder are sold as "healthier" options, so you can find a peanut option that works for you. From fat-free peanut/water paste to no-stir peanut butter with fully-hydrogenated oils and everything in between.

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Today 5:09 AM
2.7K Comments
Joined Oct 2003
HRocketsToday 5:09 AM
2.7K Comments
Quote from Guy767 View quoted comment :

Yeah, yeah, I know all about the benefits of unappetizing oily peanut butter so get off your greasy high horse laugh out loud

What's the point of it being healthier if you find it absolutely disgusting? I think it's a generational thing, I grew up in the late 80's and early 90's and peanut butter was never so oily that it looked like something from Slimer's butthole (Ghostbusters) .I never can become acclimated to such lubricious horrors, health be dammed...
"Yeah, yeah, I know all about the benefits of unappetizing oily peanut butter so get off your greasy high horse"

I prefer the natural 1 to 2 ingredient peanut butters (the ones that separate...important to note that there are "natural" peanut butters with added stablizing oils/ingredients). It actually tastes like peanuts and has a natural, textured mouthfeel. To me, the "regular" peanut butters may as well be candle wax in flavor and in feel. And you're basically having to slab on twice as much just to get any flavor compared to the more potent flavor in a smaller portion of the 2 ingredient peanut butters.

As for the 80's I remember my Mom getting Laura Scudder's natural peanut butter. It was definitely a universal ordeal about stirring it together once you've cracked the seal.

Join The Conversation

Share your experience with the Slickdeals community

Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!