Slickdeals is community-supported.  We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
36 results found matching
RSS
Filtering Options
Show results for
$ - $
Filters
Filters
Filters
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138104951 added 06-18-2020 1:18 PM by RevOne in Deal Talk
Amazon has 11.8 oz Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies on sale for $2.30 when you checking via Subscribe & Save. Shipping is free with Prime or on $25+ orders. Thanks tunabreath Note, you...
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105041 added 06-18-2020 2:08 PM by YOURNUMBA1FAN in Deal Talk
In for 2 Thanks OP...
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105281 added 06-18-2020 2:16 PM by magneticmagnum in Deal Talk
They still are. These just seem like a variant of the original in terms of shape. I usually buy the 16 oz at Walmart and they're still peanut shaped
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105428 added 06-18-2020 2:22 PM by Chasthunders in Deal Talk
In for 27. Diabeetus here i come
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138106124 added 06-18-2020 2:46 PM by JSP0421 in Deal Talk
$2.83 on S&S now.
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138106142 added 06-18-2020 2:47 PM by someoneslick in Deal Talk
People usually say food items from amazon end up arriving with horrible dates. And nutter butters already don't have as good of dates as oreos, if I am not mistaken, to begin with. They do taste...
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105995 added 06-18-2020 2:42 PM by J.Peterman in Deal Talk
S&S dead, still available for one time purchase though. Edit: back for S&S but at a higher price
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138107324 added 06-18-2020 3:37 PM by massbean in Deal Talk
Price went up to $2.53 even with 15%
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138106700 added 06-18-2020 3:08 PM by Fazerin in Deal Talk
True, thicker is always better!
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138107066 added 06-18-2020 3:26 PM by mutha_scratcha in Deal Talk
in for a bag of crumbs
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105653 added 06-18-2020 2:29 PM by PriceTheory in Deal Talk
You think Oreo milkshakes are good? Just wait until you've had a nutter butter shake! (like a good oreo shake, they need to be hand spun one of those vertical drink mixers...using a blender, like...
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105743 added 06-18-2020 2:31 PM by cheetosatan in Deal Talk
i guess i can shed my winter weight in a few more months.
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105998 added 06-18-2020 2:42 PM by jamespotato5 in Deal Talk
Yup, thats the full sized 16 oz pack. This is smaller, so cheaper.
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138108488 added 06-18-2020 4:33 PM by someoneslick in Deal Talk
I don't know. i haven't bought food from them, just noticed a lot of people saying it. It could be that they are buying from certain sellers, though. On another note, I was just remembering... I...
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138103535 added 06-18-2020 1:18 PM by tunabreath in Deal Talk
Amazon has Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz for $2.30 when you checkout with Subscribe and Save. Shipping is free. ...
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138103562 added 06-18-2020 1:19 PM by MrDealYoGurl in Deal Talk
Underrated
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105116 added 06-18-2020 2:10 PM by TrollingBy in Deal Talk
I got your nutter butter over here.... I had to make it dirty
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105284 added 06-18-2020 2:17 PM by prankies in Deal Talk
Oh f*** yeah.
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105341 added 06-18-2020 2:19 PM by ninjastyle in Deal Talk
How much are these at your typical grocery store?
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138106547 added 06-18-2020 3:02 PM by new33 in Deal Talk
Once you try the double stuff version ( double nutty) I don't see how you can go back . Not enough peanut butter on the regular version
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138106745 added 06-18-2020 3:11 PM by Investor9872 in Deal Talk
$2.98 now.
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138107099 added 06-18-2020 3:27 PM by armharm in Deal Talk
How many cookies in this?
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138104009 added 06-18-2020 1:33 PM by Bozo in Deal Talk
The "crack" of cookies. LOL! :peace:
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105071 added 06-18-2020 2:09 PM by charredangel in Deal Talk
Truth. I always grab them when they show up at the office but overlook them when at the store.
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105119 added 06-18-2020 2:10 PM by ultra707 in Deal Talk
Fstoppers need to be alerted
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105212 added 06-18-2020 2:14 PM by Dogenx in Deal Talk
Didn't these used to be shaped like a peanut?
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105353 added 06-18-2020 2:19 PM by Met1ck in Deal Talk
In for 3, thanks OP...
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138110978 added 06-18-2020 6:25 PM by Daggerfall in Deal Talk
I'm also in SoCal and have had close to expiring food items. Never actually expired, but a few were less than a month away. I've also had melted chocolates, moldy beef jerky, leaking drinks, and even...
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138106172 added 06-18-2020 2:49 PM by caps in Deal Talk
The Aldi "knockoffs" of these are pretty good.
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138106466 added 06-18-2020 2:59 PM by J.Peterman in Deal Talk
True, and a lot cheaper
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138107420 added 06-18-2020 3:41 PM by cheetosatan in Deal Talk
i've personally ordered a ton of snacks (thanks to SD) from amazon and never had any expired ones...might be because i live in socal and the warehouses fill orders frequently enough that there aren't...
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138107483 added 06-18-2020 3:45 PM by cw6875 in Deal Talk
26 cookies total
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138107759 added 06-18-2020 3:57 PM by duc135 in Deal Talk
I also live in SoCal, but have had a couple occasions where snacks were delivered with an expiration date within a few days. I contacted Customer Support and they just refunded my money. I just take...
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138104324 added 06-18-2020 1:43 PM by paul1097 in Deal Talk
Got 2. Thank ya brotha
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138103904 added 06-18-2020 1:30 PM by k2486 in Deal Talk
Deal! Thanks OP
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 11.8 oz, $2.30 w/ S&S, Amazon
Expired
Thread created 06-18-2020 by tunabreath
+65 Score 35 Replies 13,194 Views
Post #138105554 added 06-18-2020 2:25 PM by kychacat in Deal Talk
When did they start making Nutter Butters round and not peanut shaped?

More Results from Amazon.com See more at Amazon

More Results from Walmart.com See more at Walmart

More Results from Ebay.com

Didn't find what you were looking for?

We're displaying limited results because of the following settings:

  • Deals with Any Rating
  • Deals from Any Time
  • Deals from 25 forums
  • Deals filtered by and
  • Searching within Entire Threads

If you want to relax this search, click here to reset all search parameters. You can also adjust them by using the filtering options on the left.