Slickdeals is community-supported. We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
We’ve all been there. You head over to Jiffy Lube for what you think will be a $30 oil change, and then the attendant hits you with the question: "Want to upgrade to synthetic?" Suddenly you're staring down a $70 bill and wondering if you're being cheap, getting ripped off, or if the stuff is actually worth it.
We get this question a lot, and honestly, the answer isn't as straightforward as the quick lube places make it seem. The whole synthetic oil vs regular oil thing has gotten pretty confusing over the years, with everyone from your mechanic to your neighbor having their opinions about what you should put in your car.
So we decided to dig into this ourselves. What we found is that sometimes synthetic oil is totally worth the extra money and sometimes it's just an expensive way to make yourself feel better about car maintenance.
Conventional oil is pretty much what you'd expect – it starts as crude oil that gets pulled out of the ground, then refined and mixed with other chemicals (additives) to adapt it to your engine. The additives have a number of important functions, from keeping everything clean to helping the oil flow properly when it's cold outside.
Regular oil has been doing this job for decades and for people driving normal cars in normal conditions, it still works just fine.
Synthetic oil is a little different in that it doesn’t start with crude oil. Chemists build synthetic oil from scratch, molecule by molecule. This gives them control over exactly how it behaves, which is why it tends to be more consistent than conventional oil.
Think of it like the difference between a hand-knitted sweater and one made in a factory – both keep you warm, but the factory one is going to be more uniform every time.
Then there's synthetic blend, which is basically conventional oil with some synthetic mixed in. It's like getting a car that's mostly economy but with a few luxury features thrown in. You get some benefits without paying premium prices.
This is where we get into whether synthetic oil is actually better, and the answer is... it depends on what you mean by "better."
If you live somewhere with brutal winters or scorching summers, synthetic oil definitely has an advantage. Conventional oil can get as thick as honey on really cold mornings, making your engine work way harder than it should to run. Synthetic oil stays fluid and protective even when it's freezing outside.
On the hot end, if you do a lot of towing or live in Arizona, conventional oil starts breaking down when things get really toasty. Synthetic oil is also much better at staying cool.
Here's something we noticed when looking at engines that run different oil types: the ones using synthetic oil tend to be cleaner inside. Conventional oil has this habit of forming sludge and deposits, especially if you're not perfect about oil changes (and, let's be honest, who is?).
This may be the biggest difference. Conventional oil starts losing its effectiveness pretty quickly under normal driving conditions. Synthetic oil keeps working longer because of how it's made – those engineered molecules just hold up better over time.
The fuel economy thing is real but don't get too excited. We're talking maybe 1-2% improvement, which isn't going to revolutionize your gas budget but does add up over thousands of miles.
A basic oil change runs anywhere from $25-40 depending on where you go. Bump up to synthetic and you're looking at anything from $50-80, sometimes more if you drive a fancy car. It definitely stings when you see the bill.
Conventional oil typically needs changing every 3,000-5,000 miles. Your manual might say 5,000, but lots of people still follow the old 3,000-mile rule their dad taught them.
Synthetic oil? Most manufacturers say you can go 7,500-10,000 miles, sometimes longer. Testing on some newer cars has shown they can legitimately go 12,000+ miles on synthetic without any issues.
Say you drive about 15,000 miles a year (pretty typical):
With conventional oil:
You're looking at about 4 oil changes per year
At $35 each, that's $140 annually
With synthetic:
Maybe 2 oil changes per year
At $65 each, that's $130 annually
So you're actually saving money and dealing with fewer oil changes. That sounds like a win-win to us.
This is harder to put a number on, but better oil protection might mean your engine lasts longer and runs better. We can't promise anything, but the consensus is that engines that get good oil and the right maintenance hold up better over time.
Synthetic isn't always the right answer, but there are definitely times when it's worth the extra cost.
On the flip side, there are plenty of situations where spending extra on synthetic is basically throwing money away.
Changing your own oil isn't rocket science and the savings can be substantial. You can often buy synthetic oil and a filter for what shops charge for a conventional oil change. Plus you know it's done right.
Costco and Sam's Club have great prices on motor oil if you buy in bulk. Online retailers run sales pretty regularly – we've seen some killer deals on Amazon and AutoZone's website.
Don't forget about manufacturer rebates either. Valvoline, Mobil 1 and Castrol all run programs that can save you $5-15 per oil change. See our Valvoline coupons to find a great deal on their products.
Oil goes on sale just like everything else. Spring and fall are usually good times to stock up, and Black Friday often includes automotive items.
After looking at all this, here's what we think: if you drive a lot, keep your cars for a long time, or drive in demanding conditions, synthetic oil probably makes sense. The convenience alone – requiring fewer oil changes per year – may make it worth your while.
If budget is your main concern, you don't drive much, or you have an older car, conventional oil is perfectly fine. Don't let anyone make you feel guilty about it.
The most important thing? Just change your oil regularly, whatever type you choose. We've seen way more engines destroyed by neglect than by using the "wrong" type of oil.
The synthetic vs conventional debate doesn't have to keep you up at night. Synthetic generally performs better and lasts longer, but whether it makes financial sense depends on your own situation.
Do the math based on your own driving habits. Think about your car's age, how many miles you put on per year, and how long you plan to keep it. Most importantly, check what your owner's manual actually says.
Both types will keep your engine happy when changed regularly. The "best" choice is usually just the one that fits your needs and budget without causing you stress.
Whatever you choose, keep an eye out for those deals and rebates. The best oil is the one that keeps your car running great without emptying your wallet.
Absolutely. The old myth about synthetic causing leaks in older engines is not true. If your engine already has small leaks, synthetic might make them slightly more noticeable because it's better at cleaning, but it won't create new problems.
In your owner’s manual, look for the viscosity number (e.g. 5W-30) and whether it says synthetic is required. Can't find your manual? Most auto parts stores can look it up, or you can check the manufacturer's website.
It depends on your car and how you drive. Many manufacturers do say 7,500-10,000 miles with synthetic, but if you do a lot of short trips, towing, or you live in an area which goes through extreme temperature changes, you might need to change it more often regardless. When in doubt, check your oil regularly.
Nothing terrible. They're compatible and won't hurt anything. It's not ideal for performance, but if you need to top off with whatever's available, your engine will be fine. Just try to stick with one type for regular changes.
Nope, using better oil won't void your warranty. Actually, some newer cars require synthetic to keep the warranty valid. Using higher-quality oil than required is fine – it's using cheaper oil that could potentially cause issues.