Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
Allen Edmonds Park Ave's are also on sale in black for $223.36 + 20% off with email...
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
Any comments on the quality and comfort of the shoe?
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
For anyone still coming across this thread, it appear that most sizes of the Melton shoe in the BORDEAUX COLOR ONLY are now priced at $103.61.
If you get the 20% off coupon, that brings the price...
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
Couldn't agree more, have never spent as much on shoes until I found these and can't go back. They last and they are brilliant, simple, well made, and worth every penny.
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
Was $99.81 shipped for me. A great deal! Thanks OP
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
Wow, I got mine in today and these things are horrible compared to my ankle boots I got from J&M only a few years ago. The insides of these are nothing like my boots and there are visible flaws in...
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
I had the Georgetown II back in the day. It was in that $350 range and about as well made as a cap toed oxford could be. Had them redone at the J&M factory for about $100. They lasted another 4 years...
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
In for a pair of the Pattison Oxfords...thanks OP + rep'd!
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
Just FYI, I have both and Allen Edmonds tends to run smaller and definately much more narrow. These shoes are sized to what I would consider standard sizing.
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
How is their sizing? Is 3E REALLY wide?
I've gotten 2E in other brands and based on that, I'm thinking 3E would be excessive but I don't know about this brands sizing.
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
shoe tree would have definitely helped with creasing, I always use them from day 1 of new shoes. once you get the creases, using shoe trees after the fact won't help.
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
I'd have to agree that the AE's are absolutely a better pair of shoes, I own 4 pairs, but I really need a pair of black shoes to replace an older pair of black cap toes from J&M. The ones that are...
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
I purchased these exact shoes as well, and have experienced these issues, albeit to a lesser degree. Leather takes some time to break in--and is relatively uncomfortable during that time--and I've...
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
i have purchased these exact shoes in the past and can say the reviews are inflated
the leather is extremely stiff and seem to crease badly to the point where i think normal wear would cause cracks...
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
Went with the slip on. Great shoe for work super comfy
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
Needed new J&M's since I've worn the soles on the others and it's not much more than getting them resoled.
Thanks and repped
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
Thanks OP... in 4 a Melton & Penn Slip-On... I had trouble receiving the code, but looks like I'd signed up for Amazon Shoes promotional emails sometime last year... I had to first unsubscribe &...
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
this brand use to be good when they made them in the USA, now it isn't worth much. not bad for the price, but I still won't buy it. I will pay extra and purchase allen edmonds that are still made in...
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
thanks op. came out to $80 after the $20 gc i got from amazon preview! repped
Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Oxford Shoe $97 + Free shipping
Expired
Thread created 07-06-2013 by nurdy
+57 Score
68 Replies
34,805 Views
Man this was such a good deal that I went ahead and made another fake account to take advantage of the 20% off and bought another pair. I easily spend $100 on crappy shoes that have rubber soles and...
Page 1 of
4
1
2
3
4
