Slickdeals is community-supported.  We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
Missed This Deal? Get alerts when similar deals are posted.
expired
osrojas 101K Views
Oct 18, 2020 10:38 PM

Sam's Club Members: 14-Piece Tramontina Tri-Ply Clad Cookware Set

$200

+ S/H (Varies by Location)at Sam's Club
Visit Sam's Club

Why are you downvoting this deal?

Good Deal?
133Comments
Save
Share
Deal Details
Sam's Club has for its Members: 14-Piece Tramontina Tri-Ply Clad Cookware Set on sale for $199.98. Shipping is free for Plus Members, otherwise shipping varies by location. Thanks osrojas

Includes:
  • 8" Sauté Pan
  • 10" Sauté Pan
  • 12" Sauté Pan
  • 6-Quart Deep Sauté Pan w/ Lid
  • 2-Quart Sauce Pan w/ Lid
  • 3-Quart Sauce Pan w/ Lid
  • 5-Quart Dutch Oven w/ Lid
  • 8-Quart Stock Pot w/ Lid
  • Stainless Steel Steamer (Fits 3-Quart Sauce Pan)

Editor's Notes

Written by oceanlake
Comes with a lifetime warranty. -oceanlake

Original Post

Written by osrojas
Community Notes
About the Poster
Deal Details
Community Notes
About the Poster
Sam's Club has for its Members: 14-Piece Tramontina Tri-Ply Clad Cookware Set on sale for $199.98. Shipping is free for Plus Members, otherwise shipping varies by location. Thanks osrojas

Includes:
  • 8" Sauté Pan
  • 10" Sauté Pan
  • 12" Sauté Pan
  • 6-Quart Deep Sauté Pan w/ Lid
  • 2-Quart Sauce Pan w/ Lid
  • 3-Quart Sauce Pan w/ Lid
  • 5-Quart Dutch Oven w/ Lid
  • 8-Quart Stock Pot w/ Lid
  • Stainless Steel Steamer (Fits 3-Quart Sauce Pan)

Editor's Notes

Written by oceanlake
Comes with a lifetime warranty. -oceanlake

Original Post

Written by osrojas

Community Voting

Deal Score
+92
Good Deal
Bad Deal

Why are you downvoting this deal?

Top Comments

Join The Conversation

Share your experience with the Slickdeals community

Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!

134 Comments

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Oct 30, 2020 12:24 PM
1.9K Comments
Joined Oct 2008
rgadowskiOct 30, 2020 12:24 PM
1.9K Comments
you're better off buying the Costco 199 set. the Costco set has copper core for better heat distribution. The Costco set compare to the All-Clad copper core set that goes for $1000. I've had both sets and both are great, but I returned my All-Clad that i got for a wedding present because they did not have conduction capability at the time. I ended up getting the Demeyere set from bad bath and beyond that are absolutely incredible.

Costco brand
https://www.costco.com/kirkland-s...15142.html

Demeyere
https://www.bedbathandbeyond.com/...t-and-pans
Last edited by rgadowski October 30, 2020 at 05:31 AM.
1
Oct 30, 2020 1:49 PM
2.9K Comments
Joined Jun 2014
rczriderOct 30, 2020 1:49 PM
2.9K Comments
Quote from dslrSearcher View quoted comment :
I posted that question on Sam's club and Tramontia replied that they are induction compatible. Any one have this specific set that can confirm?
They're induction compatible, I promise.
Quote from mmacdon3 View quoted comment :
Are you sure?
When I look at this deal...here's the disclaimer they give. "Offer must be redeemed in a club location on a register [Store Locator]. Offer cannot be used on SamsClub.com, with Scan & Go or with Club Pickup."

https://slickdeals.net/f/14449316-get-45-off-your-first-in-club-purchase-when-you-become-a-sam-s-club-member-for-45

I think I'm leaning towards the Cuisinart Multiclad proset now...just waiting for the price to drop on it.
Ignore the garbage Slickdeals deal page and skim link. I'm guessing SD will strip the link, so copy and paste this, get rid of spaces:

https ://www.samsclub .com/ join/club ?couponId=12365

I'm conflicted. I got the $125 Multiclad set during Prime Day, but after the fact decided I'd rather have an 8-quart pot (I've had a 6-quart forever but frequently get annoyed that it's not bigger), the largest MCP pan in the set is 10", and the largest pot is 2.5qt. Those are smaller than what I have now, and while I'm at it, I'd rather have a larger saute pan. In short, I'm happy with my choice to buy the $125 MCP set.

I do like the flared rims, though.
Quote from BloodGain View quoted comment :
Yes, one downside to this set is the lack of flared edges. It just requires treating them a little differently and will be slightly less convenient for things like slowly pouring hot stock into risotti, but you can find workarounds like ladling at first and pouring the last bit. I have a really nice Demeyere saucier with flared edges that I use when I need that, but I paid $100 on sale for that pan alone. I haven't seen a pan with properly designed flared edges for pouring that is also as high quality as these for less than that, except maybe a factory second at TJ Maxx. The All-Clad "damaged box" 6 qt saute pan that has flared edges was $150.
It's the lack of flared edges that's giving me pause on this set. I think I'd really hate going from flared to non-flared. Maybe I'm overthinking it, though.
Quote from rgadowski View quoted comment :
you're better off buying the Costco 199 set. the Costco set has copper core for better heat distribution. The Costco set compare to the All-Clad copper core set that goes for $1000.

Costco brand
https://www.costco.com/kirkland-s...15142.html
Yes, copper is better for heat distribution, but I don't think buying a set with a pretty high complaint rate for warping is worth it. It's not like the Kirkland brand is the same as the All-Clad. There's clearly a difference here (not the least of which is that the Kirkland set is made in China, while All-Clad is made in the US).

Warping in multi-ply cookware is what happens when the differences in thermal expansion aren't taken into consideration. It's poor design. The Costco set is pretty enough, but the notorious warping issues (even with correct use) and exposed copper (ie. not fully encapsulated) is just asking for trouble. At these prices, fully encapsulated tri-ply is the better bet.
Oct 30, 2020 1:56 PM
828 Comments
Joined Dec 2012
comprxOct 30, 2020 1:56 PM
828 Comments
Quote from neauone View quoted comment :
They are assembled in Brazil, but manufactured in China, if that makes any sense.
The questions about country of manufacture was asked on the product page, and Tramontina replied "This set is Made in Brazil. The handles come from China to be assembled in the final production stage. "
Oct 30, 2020 2:21 PM
1.9K Comments
Joined Oct 2008
rgadowskiOct 30, 2020 2:21 PM
1.9K Comments
Quote from rczrider View quoted comment :
They're induction compatible, I promise.

Ignore the garbage Slickdeals deal page and skim link. I'm guessing SD will strip the link, so copy and paste this, get rid of spaces:

https ://www.samsclub .com/ join/club ?couponId=12365

I'm conflicted. I got the $125 Multiclad set during Prime Day, but after the fact decided I'd rather have an 8-quart pot (I've had a 6-quart forever but frequently get annoyed that it's not bigger), the largest MCP pan in the set is 10", and the largest pot is 2.5qt. Those are smaller than what I have now, and while I'm at it, I'd rather have a larger saute pan. In short, I'm happy with my choice to buy the $125 MCP set.

I do like the flared rims, though.

It's the lack of flared edges that's giving me pause on this set. I think I'd really hate going from flared to non-flared. Maybe I'm overthinking it, though.

Yes, copper is better for heat distribution, but I don't think buying a set with a pretty high complaint rate for warping is worth it. It's not like the Kirkland brand is the same as the All-Clad. There's clearly a difference here (not the least of which is that the Kirkland set is made in China, while All-Clad is made in the US).

Warping in multi-ply cookware is what happens when the differences in thermal expansion aren't taken into consideration. It's poor design. The Costco set is pretty enough, but the notorious warping issues (even with correct use) and exposed copper (ie. not fully encapsulated) is just asking for trouble. At these prices, fully encapsulated tri-ply is the better bet.

I would take the Costco branded version over any brand in it's class. my last Costco set lasted 21 years and only reason I returned them was due to me purchasing an induction range.

I tried this new pot set and can confidently say it's a great set. They are extremely well made and my wife did not want me to return them. Negative reviews come from people that have no clue on how to cook and don't follow factory instructions on heat limits. People just take pots out of the box and do what they want and warp the pots. there are heat limits you need to follow on any set.

Go to Costco and handle this set and see for yourself. you have to be extremely bad at cooking to warp this set. You should also consider the fact that they might have had a bad batch.

The fact that they are made in china should not be considered a bad thing, because some products out of china are amazing. the only reason all-clad cost so much is because of labor costs. And All-clad does sell a China made product called Emerilware.
2
Oct 30, 2020 2:35 PM
2.9K Comments
Joined Jun 2014
rczriderOct 30, 2020 2:35 PM
2.9K Comments
Quote from rgadowski View quoted comment :
Negative reviews come from people that have no clue on how to cook and don't follow factory instructions on heat limits. People just take pots out of the box and do what they want and warp the pots. there are heat limits you need to follow on any set.
Read the reviews, people seem quite aware of how you can damage cookware and swear they did exactly what they were supposed to. I guess you're saying all of these people are liars or idiots?
Quote :
Go to Costco and handle this set and see for yourself. you have to be extremely bad at cooking to warp this set. You should also consider the fact that they might have had a bad batch.
Yep, it could have been a bad batch...and if so, it was a large number that were produced, and recently. My time is worth something and I don't see any actual benefit to the Kirkland set. Just "Oh, it's heavier, it must be better!" and "The itty bitty amount of copper in this set makes me food 10 billion times better and it's sooooooooooo pretty!" To each their own.
Quote :
The fact that they are made in china should not be considered a bad thing, because some products out of china are amazing. the only reason all-clad cost so much is because of labor costs. And All-clad does sell a China made product called Emerilware.
Oh, I know...I'm replacing my China-made All-Clad Emeril stainless/"copper" from more than 10 years ago, in fact. It's a fine set, but the copper is a joke and I want a larger stock pot and deep saute pan, anyway.

Again, to each their own. I'm not saying the Costco set is bad, I just read reviews and there's nothing compelling about it over this Tramontina set. And as I said in my other post, exposed / non-encapsulated layer is just asking for trouble. Thermodynamics says so. I'd take fully encapsulated any day.
Last edited by rczrider October 30, 2020 at 01:25 PM.
Oct 30, 2020 2:57 PM
518 Comments
Joined Nov 2010
sd8384Oct 30, 2020 2:57 PM
518 Comments
Quote from Kensic View quoted comment :
is it easy to fry with SS vs non-stick? only have owned nonstick in my life
It is something you will have to learn, because it is certainly different than using non-stick. In my experience SS uses slightly more oil and you have to temper the SS before you put anything else. I usually put the SS pan on the medium heat and then add the oil, once the oil is hot, I swirl the pan so the oil coats the side of the pans slightly before I start frying. It has worked well for me this way. I have never actually tried to "fry" things though, it is usually just sautéed.

And I don't have this exact set.
Oct 30, 2020 4:34 PM
326 Comments
Joined Jul 2014
memfisdesignsOct 30, 2020 4:34 PM
326 Comments
Bought this set from this deal and absolutely love it so far. Definitely have to change your methods of cooking a little (and cleaning) if you are used to nonstick but not too hard to get used to.

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Oct 30, 2020 7:09 PM
44 Comments
Joined Oct 2018
swamybaleOct 30, 2020 7:09 PM
44 Comments
I need only two 8qt stock pots. Where can I get this brand of individual pieces?
Oct 31, 2020 12:00 AM
2.9K Comments
Joined Jun 2014
rczriderOct 31, 2020 12:00 AM
2.9K Comments
Quote from swamybale View quoted comment :
I need only two 8qt stock pots. Where can I get this brand of individual pieces?
Oct 31, 2020 4:33 AM
150 Comments
Joined May 2018
sabbatublack1Oct 31, 2020 4:33 AM
150 Comments
Quote from rgadowski View quoted comment :
I would take the Costco branded version over any brand in it's class. my last Costco set lasted 21 years and only reason I returned them was due to me purchasing an induction range.

I tried this new pot set and can confidently say it's a great set. They are extremely well made and my wife did not want me to return them. Negative reviews come from people that have no clue on how to cook and don't follow factory instructions on heat limits. People just take pots out of the box and do what they want and warp the pots. there are heat limits you need to follow on any set.

Go to Costco and handle this set and see for yourself. you have to be extremely bad at cooking to warp this set. You should also consider the fact that they might have had a bad batch.

The fact that they are made in china should not be considered a bad thing, because some products out of china are amazing. the only reason all-clad cost so much is because of labor costs. And All-clad does sell a China made product called Emerilware.
You used a set of pots and pans and returned them after 21 years??
Oct 31, 2020 10:56 PM
1.9K Comments
Joined Oct 2008

This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users.

Nov 1, 2020 5:27 PM
15 Comments
Joined Sep 2013
TopChaseNov 1, 2020 5:27 PM
15 Comments
Quote from rgadowski View quoted comment :
Yes. That's an option at Costco. They were in new condition.
And Costco had no issues??
Nov 3, 2020 1:07 PM
1.9K Comments
Joined Oct 2008
rgadowskiNov 3, 2020 1:07 PM
1.9K Comments
no questions asked.
Nov 3, 2020 7:40 PM
2.9K Comments
Joined Jun 2014
rczriderNov 3, 2020 7:40 PM
2.9K Comments
Quote from rgadowski View quoted comment :
Yes. That's an option at Costco. They were in new condition.
They were in "new" condition after 21 years of frequent use? Yeah...odd flex, but okay.

Anyway, just got mine today. I have them side-by-sidethe Cuisinart MCP that was $125 for the 10-piece set on Prime Day. After tax and shipping, difference is about $92.

Cuisinart set pros:
flared rims on pots
measurement marks (though the font looks "cheap")

Tramontina set pros:
stainless lids instead of glass
larger (arguably more useful) sizes
more pieces (but of course you pay more)
handles generally a bit longer

I'm almost certainly going to keep the Tramontina simply for the sizes. I wanted an 8-quart stockpot (instead of 6-quart), a deep saute larger than the 3-quart that the Cuisinart comes with (although the 6-quart of the Tramontina is probably overkill), and the 12" saute pan is nice. I don't particularly care about the stainless lids, but the internet tells me they're preferable to glass (I guess because glass breaks, though I like being able to look into my pot/pan and see what's happening without removing the lid).

Tramontina would be perfect (in my mind) if they just added the flare and measurement marks.

All that said, this set is way more than most people need. Unless you're cooking a lot of food at once (say, Thanksgiving) where having more pieces is better, and/or storage space is of no concern, this is just too much. I'll probably sell a couple of pieces (like the 5-quart Dutch oven) on Craigslist.

I put an * next to the MCP handle comment because the new MCP handles are thin and suck...what was on sale at Amazon was the "classic" handle, which is actually pretty nice, but individual MCP pieces all seem to be the new style.

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Nov 14, 2020 12:42 PM
1.9K Comments
Joined Sep 2008
fanglekaiNov 14, 2020 12:42 PM
1.9K Comments
Quote from rgadowski View quoted comment :
Yes. That's an option at Costco. They were in new condition.
They weren't new and you used them for 21 years. You're the reason why stores quit offering generous return policies.

Join The Conversation

Share your experience with the Slickdeals community

Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!