Nice discount on an essential woodworking tool. The modern Stanley Sweetheart line is often recommended as a best value bench plane and competitive in quality with planes twice the cost.
For price comparison, the list price for this is currently $240, and is on sale at Rockler for $180.
Amazon global store listings include customs, taxes and shipping in the price and are priced in dollars so there are no foreign transaction fees
Don't have Amazon Prime? Students can get a free 6-Month Amazon Prime trial with free 2-day shipping, unlimited video streaming & more.
If you're not a student, there's also a free 1-Month Amazon Prime trial available.
You can also earn cash back rewards on Amazon and Whole Foods purchases with the Amazon Prime Visa credit card. Read our review to see if it’s the right card for you.
Honestly, if you're into hand woodworking, this will be one of the most used planes. Might as well buy the Lie-Nelsen. I get its not a slickdeal, but hand woodworking is a hobby.
Yes, Woodriver is Woodcraft's brand manufactured in China. These Stanley Sweetheart planes are manufactured in Mexico, while Lee Valley / Veritas are manufactured in Canada. All three are quality options with some fine tuning but some are hyper focused on country of origin.
Maybe. But probably not.
This is a tool that should work out of the box. But to use it for what it is intended, and for it to do a good job, requires quite a bit of work and know-how. Nothing extreme. But enough to deter most from learning and performing the steps to do things like flatten the sole, file down any bits with slight imperfections, and perform initial and regular sharpening.
It's a bench plane. It's intended to be used on a sturdy bench with the wood secured properly. And it's intended to be used for finer woodworking tasks like making nice furniture. It can be used to flatten and smooth any wood. But ergonomically, it's not ideal typical carpentry types of tasks where you are either on the move or not focused on butter-smooth perfection.
If woodworking in a shop is a hobby or your profession, then learning about and using bench planes could be a great addition. If not, I'd recommend you start out with a block plane for normal homeowner tasks.
A block plane is a much smaller investment. It's also much smaller all around. That means it is much easier to store, transport, and even carry in a pocket or apron. It also takes less time to flatten and setup if you'd like to try that out.
(Source: I picked up hand tool woodworking as a Pandemic hobby. I'm still very much a novice on the subject. But I'm hoping to provide realistic advice where I can.
I actually own this exact Stanley plane. While I can answer some hands-on question about it, I haven't used any Veritas, Lee Neilson, or vintage Stanleys to compare with.)
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
No. Not to the plain eye at least. What hand tools lack most is efficiency.
They are most of a hobby and they create far less dust compared to power tools.
In the right hands, a woodworker can be more efficient with hand tools. Power tools excel in batching out multiples of something, but since most woodworking projects are one-offs aka "bespoke", hand tools are a great way to efficiently get your work done.
Why is this so expensive? It was invented thousands of years ago, and looks the same as those Roman's artifacts. A blade on a block.
Matt Estla[youtube.com] made a video that talks about this. He takes a ~$30 Amazon Basics plane, and does what he can to make it perform like a Lie Nielson plane that probably costs 10x the price. He spends 9+ hours one the project. Granted, some of the improvements he made to the plane were cosmetic, and not necessary.
A hand plane is meant to be a precise tool. Especially a smoothing plane (No 4). People using these aren't trying to make things kinda flat. They want to be able to reliably cut through the wood. And they want to be able to make adjustments quickly.
I own the Amazon plane in Matt's video. I purchased it specifically to be converted into a scrub plane[youtube.com]. It works fine for this, since a scrub plane may not even need adjusting. But I can tell you that trying to use it as a smoother is a nightmare.
If you just need to use it occasionally, I think you can get buy with a cheap block plane just fine. But if you are trying to use a No 4 as intended, you really want it to work well. That means spending a lot of time, money, or a mix of both.
My money would be better put towards bridgecitytools.com hand planes. They have sales all the time, so don't be put off by the high prices. They are super-refined hand tools bordering on works of art.
Stanley's quality control is very hit or miss and seems to have gotten worse in recent years. The Sweetheart No. 62 is an excellent values if you get a good one. I thought the #4 would be good because its design is more like the #62 than a typical #4. The frog is cast into the body instead of a separate piece, the mouth is adjusted with a sliding plate on the bottom, and there is a single control for the depth and lateral adjustment. But the lateral adjustment is way too touchy with the much higher 45° bed angle (as opposed to 12°.) On the #4, they added a knob so you can lock the lateral adjustment but it's so touchy that you can't just set and forget the lateral adjustment while you adjust the depth. The design of this plane just doesn't work that well and that's not something you can fix with some elbow grease.
Plus the quality control was terrible on the one I received. There was about 8 turns worth of backlash in the depth adjustment. And when I blew the sawdust off before I sent it back, the paint came off in big flakes. This is probably one of the worst hand tools I've owned.
My money would be better put towards bridgecitytools.com hand planes. They have sales all the time, so don't be put off by the high prices. They are super-refined hand tools bordering on works of art.
I have their block plane. I like the thickness planing skids but their planes are gimmicky otherwise – aluminum bodies, metal handles that are open on the side, double sided irons with just a magnetic guard to keep your hand safe from the unused end. All arguably not great things. 😂 And insanely expensive, especially considering that Bridge City was sold to a Chinese company in 2018 and all their tools are made there.
For a fraction of the price, you could buy an superior Lie-Nielsen made in the US or a Canadian-made Veritas with a PM-V11 blade, which is pretty much the best alloy there is for an iron.
I have some of the new Stanley, Old Stanley, Lee Valley, and Lie Nielsen planes. The new new Stanley planes are decent quality materials and I have not had any problems with the quality of construction. I find I use an Old Stanley No 6 the most, followed by the Lie Nielsen No 4, and then the New Stanley Block plane. I purchased worn out old planes and reconditioned them to see which I would use the most and slowly replaced them with higher quality newer planes. I just like the Old Stanley No 6 so much I just don't want to replace it.
Can anyone that actually used all 3 brands to give a fair comparison?
Lee Vally, Lie Nielsen and Stanley
LV Veritas and LN are essentially six of one and half a dozen of the other. There are some minor differences here and there but both are extremely high quality and will be ready to use out of the box. I prefer the steel of LV's upper tier blades- the pmv11- but the a2 LN uses isn't by any means bad. Most testing,such as woodworking by Wright on youtube, will show the pmv11 to be generally superior but not by an insurmountable margin.
The adjusters are a little different between the planes; LV favors "norris" adjusters where LN are more like vintage stanley bailey's. Both work and there is nothing wrong with either.
The LN is slightly more expensive but also holds value a bit more. Both are definitely premium brands, I'd say LN probably garners slightly more esteem, but they're definitely punching in the same weight class and a user of one will appreciate the other.
The Stanley's will likely require some cleanup, the sole will need flattening, the blade back may not be flat, the grind of the blade may not be as good, the sharpness may not be as well done. All stuff you as the end user can fix, but having one with all the busy work done for an extra hundred bucks may be worth it... especially when you retain a lot of resale value with LN and LV, but collectors don't care at all about new stanley.
My most used planes are an LV 4, and LV low angle jack, and LV dx60 block, and a vintage Stanley 4 1/2 with a hock blade. They're all good at different tasks and I often use them together.
69 Comments
Your comment cannot be blank.
Featured Comments
This is a tool that should work out of the box. But to use it for what it is intended, and for it to do a good job, requires quite a bit of work and know-how. Nothing extreme. But enough to deter most from learning and performing the steps to do things like flatten the sole, file down any bits with slight imperfections, and perform initial and regular sharpening.
It's a bench plane. It's intended to be used on a sturdy bench with the wood secured properly. And it's intended to be used for finer woodworking tasks like making nice furniture. It can be used to flatten and smooth any wood. But ergonomically, it's not ideal typical carpentry types of tasks where you are either on the move or not focused on butter-smooth perfection.
If woodworking in a shop is a hobby or your profession, then learning about and using bench planes could be a great addition. If not, I'd recommend you start out with a block plane for normal homeowner tasks.
A block plane is a much smaller investment. It's also much smaller all around. That means it is much easier to store, transport, and even carry in a pocket or apron. It also takes less time to flatten and setup if you'd like to try that out.
(Source: I picked up hand tool woodworking as a Pandemic hobby. I'm still very much a novice on the subject. But I'm hoping to provide realistic advice where I can.
I actually own this exact Stanley plane. While I can answer some hands-on question about it, I haven't used any Veritas, Lee Neilson, or vintage Stanleys to compare with.)
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
They are most of a hobby and they create far less dust compared to power tools.
Lee Vally, Lie Nielsen and Stanley
A hand plane is meant to be a precise tool. Especially a smoothing plane (No 4). People using these aren't trying to make things kinda flat. They want to be able to reliably cut through the wood. And they want to be able to make adjustments quickly.
I own the Amazon plane in Matt's video. I purchased it specifically to be converted into a scrub plane [youtube.com]. It works fine for this, since a scrub plane may not even need adjusting. But I can tell you that trying to use it as a smoother is a nightmare.
If you just need to use it occasionally, I think you can get buy with a cheap block plane just fine. But if you are trying to use a No 4 as intended, you really want it to work well. That means spending a lot of time, money, or a mix of both.
Plus the quality control was terrible on the one I received. There was about 8 turns worth of backlash in the depth adjustment. And when I blew the sawdust off before I sent it back, the paint came off in big flakes. This is probably one of the worst hand tools I've owned.
For a fraction of the price, you could buy an superior Lie-Nielsen made in the US or a Canadian-made Veritas with a PM-V11 blade, which is pretty much the best alloy there is for an iron.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Lee Vally, Lie Nielsen and Stanley
The adjusters are a little different between the planes; LV favors "norris" adjusters where LN are more like vintage stanley bailey's. Both work and there is nothing wrong with either.
The LN is slightly more expensive but also holds value a bit more. Both are definitely premium brands, I'd say LN probably garners slightly more esteem, but they're definitely punching in the same weight class and a user of one will appreciate the other.
The Stanley's will likely require some cleanup, the sole will need flattening, the blade back may not be flat, the grind of the blade may not be as good, the sharpness may not be as well done. All stuff you as the end user can fix, but having one with all the busy work done for an extra hundred bucks may be worth it... especially when you retain a lot of resale value with LN and LV, but collectors don't care at all about new stanley.
My most used planes are an LV 4, and LV low angle jack, and LV dx60 block, and a vintage Stanley 4 1/2 with a hock blade. They're all good at different tasks and I often use them together.