This collaborative space allows users to contribute additional information, tips, and insights to enhance the original deal post. Feel free to share your knowledge and help fellow shoppers make informed decisions.
In for Wings of Desire, Double Indemnity, and Wall-E.
Always painful to have champagne tastes on a beer budget -- to spend $75 on 3 flicks.
But what pleasure they bring.
amazon comment on Wings:
"- Criterion version has good English subtitles, not the bad ones from the British Curzon version.
- The SOUND is actually the most noteworthy thing to me, if you have a good setup. It is NOT the same as even the new Bluray version. The key feature here is that the whispering angels in scenes like the library now completely surround you in 5.1. It's really an amazing effect. Later, when they awkwardly euro-dance at the club, the sound is again dramatically improved. The whole soundtrack is much, much clearer in a way that even the CD really is not--they must have remastered it. There's no subwoofer boom, but these small atmospheric effects add a great deal and are totally absent in the Bluray (I checked to confirm). Three cheers for art-house sound.
- The 4K picture is clearer than the new Bluray, but not as dramatic as I'd been led to expect. Some improvements in contrast and grading are visible but not gigantic. E.g., the guy dying on the bridge looks washed out on Bluray and comes through much clearer in 4K. (Die Insel Tristan da Cunha...)
Cons:
- No HDR. I just disagree that this is ever acceptable. Adding HDR isn't like adding CGI or a bombastic new soundtrack. Making the blacks actually black and extending peak highlights is more like adding some surround ambiance, which they already did here. And imagine Damiel's garish red jacket and Marion's dress popping in HDR at the end, during their bizarre eurologue!
- The picture was always pretty noisy and it remains so. I'm glad they didn't try to clear this up, but it really is very noisy, especially in early outdoor special effects shots where there are all kinds of weird compositing artifacts. Again, it's not that they should have fixed this, but be aware of source limitations--don't be expecting some pristine restoration or anything.
- I was somewhat misled by the PR into thinking there would be radical changes in the character of the BW from a sepia tone to something new, radically clearer picture, etc., and relative to the Bluray I would suggest tempering expectations a bit. This is better, but not shock and awe.
..."
Three Colors does not appear to be $24.99 at this time (though it does appear to be half price at $62.49).
Regardless, let's agree that that Kieslowski was a cinematographic genius and Three Colors is brilliant / must see.
Three Colors does not appear to be $24.99 at this time (though it does appear to be half price at $62.49).
Regardless, let's agree that that Kieslowski was a cinematographic genius and Three Colors is brilliant / must see.
In for Wings of Desire, Double Indemnity, and Wall-E.
Always painful to have champagne tastes on a beer budget -- to spend $75 on 3 flicks.
But what pleasure they bring.
amazon comment on Wings:
"- Criterion version has good English subtitles, not the bad ones from the British Curzon version.
- The SOUND is actually the most noteworthy thing to me, if you have a good setup. It is NOT the same as even the new Bluray version. The key feature here is that the whispering angels in scenes like the library now completely surround you in 5.1. It's really an amazing effect. Later, when they awkwardly euro-dance at the club, the sound is again dramatically improved. The whole soundtrack is much, much clearer in a way that even the CD really is not--they must have remastered it. There's no subwoofer boom, but these small atmospheric effects add a great deal and are totally absent in the Bluray (I checked to confirm). Three cheers for art-house sound.
- The 4K picture is clearer than the new Bluray, but not as dramatic as I'd been led to expect. Some improvements in contrast and grading are visible but not gigantic. E.g., the guy dying on the bridge looks washed out on Bluray and comes through much clearer in 4K. (Die Insel Tristan da Cunha...)
Cons:
- No HDR. I just disagree that this is ever acceptable. Adding HDR isn't like adding CGI or a bombastic new soundtrack. Making the blacks actually black and extending peak highlights is more like adding some surround ambiance, which they already did here. And imagine Damiel's garish red jacket and Marion's dress popping in HDR at the end, during their bizarre eurologue!
- The picture was always pretty noisy and it remains so. I'm glad they didn't try to clear this up, but it really is very noisy, especially in early outdoor special effects shots where there are all kinds of weird compositing artifacts. Again, it's not that they should have fixed this, but be aware of source limitations--don't be expecting some pristine restoration or anything.
- I was somewhat misled by the PR into thinking there would be radical changes in the character of the BW from a sepia tone to something new, radically clearer picture, etc., and relative to the Bluray I would suggest tempering expectations a bit. This is better, but not shock and awe.
..."
14
Like
Helpful
Funny
Not helpful
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
I have not seen most of these and never bought a Criterion version. What's the top one (or three) that I should get and watch? I don't have a favorite type of movie, I watch anything.
I have not seen most of these and never bought a Criterion version. What's the top one (or three) that I should get and watch? I don't have a favorite type of movie, I watch anything.
This is such a difficult question to answer. It's like saying I love all kinds of food, recommend me something to eat. I eat anything.
You might want to take a look at Criterion Collection Essentials. Kinda like their starter packs. But one film that I can say gets folks into the hobby is Seven Samurai.
Edit: Sorry if you were talking about the 4Ks above , then I strongly recommend In the mood for love by Wong Kar Wai. The shots are absolutely gorgeous. The story is a poetic look at loneliness and wayward souls. I'd you like that then you can see his other works like Chung King Express or shoot for the Boxset. On the other end of spectrum, Menace II Society is a gem.
I'll never forgive The Criterion Collection for refusing to release in UHD-4k for years, claiming that it would be "too expensive" for them and that there's not enough demand, when in reality (we all knew) the incremental cost of them just flipping their existing 4k master files onto UHD discs was a nothingburger. The company is pretty f'ing elitist that way.
I have not seen most of these and never bought a Criterion version. What's the top one (or three) that I should get and watch? I don't have a favorite type of movie, I watch anything.
Dazed and confused look like it has good extras. They're all excellent movies though. If you haven't seen rules of the game or double indemnity they're must see classics.
This is such a difficult question to answer. It's like saying I love all kinds of food, recommend me something to eat. I eat anything.
You might want to take a look at Criterion Collection Essentials. Kinda like their starter packs. But one film that I can say gets folks into the hobbit is a Seven Samurai.
Edit: Sorry if you were talking about the 4Ks above , then I strongly recommend In the mood for love by Wong Kar Wai. The shots are absolutely gorgeous. The story is a poetic look at loneliness and wayward souls. I'd you like that then you can see his other works like Chung King Express or shoot for the Boxset. On the other end of spectrum, Menace II Society is a gem.
Haha true good point. But yes I did mean out of the options available here. In The Mood For Love seemed to have popped up several time between here and the B&N thread. I haven't purchased many 4k movies recently so I'm looking for different things to watch and I'm always up for some classics.
I'll never forgive The Criterion Collection for refusing to release in UHD-4k for years, claiming that it would be "too expensive" for them and that there's not enough demand, when in reality (we all knew) the incremental cost of them just flipping their existing 4k master files onto UHD discs was a nothingburger. The company is pretty f'ing elitist that way.
I decided against going to 4K and my fear of Criterion releasing 4K films has happened. They are re-leasing fewer new titles and instead upgrading existing films to 4K.
I have over 300 Criterion blurays but I've been purchasing fewer films the last 6 months or so. In my case it has cost them sales.
Like
Helpful
Funny
Not helpful
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
Top Comments
Always painful to have champagne tastes on a beer budget -- to spend $75 on 3 flicks.
But what pleasure they bring.
amazon comment on Wings:
"- Criterion version has good English subtitles, not the bad ones from the British Curzon version.
- The SOUND is actually the most noteworthy thing to me, if you have a good setup. It is NOT the same as even the new Bluray version. The key feature here is that the whispering angels in scenes like the library now completely surround you in 5.1. It's really an amazing effect. Later, when they awkwardly euro-dance at the club, the sound is again dramatically improved. The whole soundtrack is much, much clearer in a way that even the CD really is not--they must have remastered it. There's no subwoofer boom, but these small atmospheric effects add a great deal and are totally absent in the Bluray (I checked to confirm). Three cheers for art-house sound.
- The 4K picture is clearer than the new Bluray, but not as dramatic as I'd been led to expect. Some improvements in contrast and grading are visible but not gigantic. E.g., the guy dying on the bridge looks washed out on Bluray and comes through much clearer in 4K. (Die Insel Tristan da Cunha...)
Cons:
- No HDR. I just disagree that this is ever acceptable. Adding HDR isn't like adding CGI or a bombastic new soundtrack. Making the blacks actually black and extending peak highlights is more like adding some surround ambiance, which they already did here. And imagine Damiel's garish red jacket and Marion's dress popping in HDR at the end, during their bizarre eurologue!
- The picture was always pretty noisy and it remains so. I'm glad they didn't try to clear this up, but it really is very noisy, especially in early outdoor special effects shots where there are all kinds of weird compositing artifacts. Again, it's not that they should have fixed this, but be aware of source limitations--don't be expecting some pristine restoration or anything.
- I was somewhat misled by the PR into thinking there would be radical changes in the character of the BW from a sepia tone to something new, radically clearer picture, etc., and relative to the Bluray I would suggest tempering expectations a bit. This is better, but not shock and awe.
..."
Regardless, let's agree that that Kieslowski was a cinematographic genius and Three Colors is brilliant / must see.
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
35 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Regardless, let's agree that that Kieslowski was a cinematographic genius and Three Colors is brilliant / must see.
If you're willing to go up a few dollars, The Sound of Metal is about $26.50
Always painful to have champagne tastes on a beer budget -- to spend $75 on 3 flicks.
But what pleasure they bring.
amazon comment on Wings:
"- Criterion version has good English subtitles, not the bad ones from the British Curzon version.
- The SOUND is actually the most noteworthy thing to me, if you have a good setup. It is NOT the same as even the new Bluray version. The key feature here is that the whispering angels in scenes like the library now completely surround you in 5.1. It's really an amazing effect. Later, when they awkwardly euro-dance at the club, the sound is again dramatically improved. The whole soundtrack is much, much clearer in a way that even the CD really is not--they must have remastered it. There's no subwoofer boom, but these small atmospheric effects add a great deal and are totally absent in the Bluray (I checked to confirm). Three cheers for art-house sound.
- The 4K picture is clearer than the new Bluray, but not as dramatic as I'd been led to expect. Some improvements in contrast and grading are visible but not gigantic. E.g., the guy dying on the bridge looks washed out on Bluray and comes through much clearer in 4K. (Die Insel Tristan da Cunha...)
Cons:
- No HDR. I just disagree that this is ever acceptable. Adding HDR isn't like adding CGI or a bombastic new soundtrack. Making the blacks actually black and extending peak highlights is more like adding some surround ambiance, which they already did here. And imagine Damiel's garish red jacket and Marion's dress popping in HDR at the end, during their bizarre eurologue!
- The picture was always pretty noisy and it remains so. I'm glad they didn't try to clear this up, but it really is very noisy, especially in early outdoor special effects shots where there are all kinds of weird compositing artifacts. Again, it's not that they should have fixed this, but be aware of source limitations--don't be expecting some pristine restoration or anything.
- I was somewhat misled by the PR into thinking there would be radical changes in the character of the BW from a sepia tone to something new, radically clearer picture, etc., and relative to the Bluray I would suggest tempering expectations a bit. This is better, but not shock and awe.
..."
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Last Waltz is another great choice but I keep hoping for another version with remastered audio.
You might want to take a look at Criterion Collection Essentials. Kinda like their starter packs. But one film that I can say gets folks into the hobby is Seven Samurai.
Edit: Sorry if you were talking about the 4Ks above , then I strongly recommend In the mood for love by Wong Kar Wai. The shots are absolutely gorgeous. The story is a poetic look at loneliness and wayward souls. I'd you like that then you can see his other works like Chung King Express or shoot for the Boxset. On the other end of spectrum, Menace II Society is a gem.
You might want to take a look at Criterion Collection Essentials. Kinda like their starter packs. But one film that I can say gets folks into the hobbit is a Seven Samurai.
Edit: Sorry if you were talking about the 4Ks above , then I strongly recommend In the mood for love by Wong Kar Wai. The shots are absolutely gorgeous. The story is a poetic look at loneliness and wayward souls. I'd you like that then you can see his other works like Chung King Express or shoot for the Boxset. On the other end of spectrum, Menace II Society is a gem.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
I have over 300 Criterion blurays but I've been purchasing fewer films the last 6 months or so. In my case it has cost them sales.
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!