Slickdeals is community-supported.  We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
forum thread Posted by Suryasis • Last Saturday
forum thread Posted by Suryasis • Last Saturday

Minisforum MS-A1 Cert Refurb Barebone Mini PC: /w AM5 Ryzen 7000/8000/9000 Support, OCuLink, USB4, Dual 2.5G @ $174 + F/S

$574

$599

4% off
Minisforum
24 Comments 6,296 Views
Get Deal at Minisforum
Good Deal
Save
Share
Deal Details
Coupon: $25 Off via Deal-25

Barebone (No CPU, Ram, Storage and SSD) [minisforum.com]: @ $174 OOS

Also Available:Spec:
  • AM5 CPU socket supporting Ryzen 7000 and 8000 series Desktop Processors (9000 series /w BIOS Update)
  • 2x DDR5 SODIMM Slot, up to 96GB 5200 MT/s
  • 2x PCIe Gen 4x4 M.2 2280 Slot
  • 1x PCIe Gen 3x4 M.2 2280 Slot
  • 1x PCIe Gen 4x1 M.2 2280 Slot
  • 1x M.2 2230 for NIC (Populated)
  • Wi-Fi 6E 2x2 + Bluetooth 5.2
  • Front Ports:
    • 2x USB-A 3.2 Gen 1
    • 1x USB-A 2.0
    • 1x 3.5mm Audio Combo Jack
  • Rear Ports:
    • 1x DC-In (19V 12.63A, 240W)
    • 1x HDMI 2.1
    • 1x DisplayPort 2.0
    • 1x OCulink Dedicated Port
    • 1x USB 4.0 Type-C 40 Gbps (Data + DisplayPort)
    • 1x USB-A 3.2 gen 2 10 Gbps
    • 1x USB-A 2.0
    • 2x Realtek 2.5G RJ-45 supporting link aggregation
Features:
  • Supports Raphael (Ryzen 7000 desktop), Phoenix (Ryzen 8000 series Desktop) and Granite Ridge (Ryzen 9000 series Desktop) Processor. 9000 series will be supported with BIOS Update
  • The 3 M.2 PCIe Gen 4 SSD bandwidth depends upon the CPU choice as the Phoenix APUs don't offer as many PCIe Gen 4 lanes as the Ryzen 7000 series Desktop Processors. If 8000 series is used, the 2nd PCIe Gen 4x4 Slot will run at Gen 4x2 speed. Check the link https://www.minisforum.cn/new/sup...ort/faq/41
Community Notes
About the Poster
Deal Details
Community Notes
About the Poster
Coupon: $25 Off via Deal-25

Barebone (No CPU, Ram, Storage and SSD) [minisforum.com]: @ $174 OOS

Also Available:Spec:
  • AM5 CPU socket supporting Ryzen 7000 and 8000 series Desktop Processors (9000 series /w BIOS Update)
  • 2x DDR5 SODIMM Slot, up to 96GB 5200 MT/s
  • 2x PCIe Gen 4x4 M.2 2280 Slot
  • 1x PCIe Gen 3x4 M.2 2280 Slot
  • 1x PCIe Gen 4x1 M.2 2280 Slot
  • 1x M.2 2230 for NIC (Populated)
  • Wi-Fi 6E 2x2 + Bluetooth 5.2
  • Front Ports:
    • 2x USB-A 3.2 Gen 1
    • 1x USB-A 2.0
    • 1x 3.5mm Audio Combo Jack
  • Rear Ports:
    • 1x DC-In (19V 12.63A, 240W)
    • 1x HDMI 2.1
    • 1x DisplayPort 2.0
    • 1x OCulink Dedicated Port
    • 1x USB 4.0 Type-C 40 Gbps (Data + DisplayPort)
    • 1x USB-A 3.2 gen 2 10 Gbps
    • 1x USB-A 2.0
    • 2x Realtek 2.5G RJ-45 supporting link aggregation
Features:
  • Supports Raphael (Ryzen 7000 desktop), Phoenix (Ryzen 8000 series Desktop) and Granite Ridge (Ryzen 9000 series Desktop) Processor. 9000 series will be supported with BIOS Update
  • The 3 M.2 PCIe Gen 4 SSD bandwidth depends upon the CPU choice as the Phoenix APUs don't offer as many PCIe Gen 4 lanes as the Ryzen 7000 series Desktop Processors. If 8000 series is used, the 2nd PCIe Gen 4x4 Slot will run at Gen 4x2 speed. Check the link https://www.minisforum.cn/new/sup...ort/faq/41

Community Voting

Deal Score
+5
Good Deal
Get Deal at Minisforum
Leave a Comment
To participate in the comments, please log in.

24 Comments

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Last Saturday
192 Posts
Joined Dec 2012
Last Saturday
DaveP2444
Last Saturday
192 Posts
Seeing the 32GB/1TB build as $599 not $499
Last Saturday
471 Posts
Joined Nov 2018
Last Saturday
Cataguy
Last Saturday
471 Posts
Quote from DaveP2444 :
Seeing the 32GB/1TB build as $599 not $499

Still relatively good, given the processor is 300 alone, 100 extra for ssd, ram and OS (if you need it) is pretty good.

There's a code for 25 off in the notes.
4
Last Saturday
192 Posts
Joined Dec 2012
Last Saturday
DaveP2444
Last Saturday
192 Posts
Quote from Cataguy :
Still relatively good, given the processor is 300 alone, 100 extra for ssd, ram and OS (if you need it) is pretty good.

There's a code for 25 off in the notes.

Never said it wasn't, any particular issues with this build from them? Normally when their newer model has so many refurb it's something. But agreed if everything is well with it, great price
Original Poster
Pro
Expert
This user is an Expert in Computers
Last Saturday
19,808 Posts
Joined Jul 2015
Last Saturday
Suryasis
Last Saturday
Original Poster
Pro
Expert
This user is an Expert in Computers
19,808 Posts
Quote from DaveP2444 :
Seeing the 32GB/1TB build as $599 not $499
Thanks, corrected it.
Last Saturday
1,118 Posts
Joined Aug 2019
Last Saturday
SlickCrayon1512
Last Saturday
1,118 Posts
Good price for this product but why would you want a 8700g in it? If so just get a mini PC like GMKtec with 7840hs for $300 with 32gb and a cheap ssd. Or pay $400 and get one with 8845hs that also have oculink and whatever this have. IMO this product is only good if you put a real desktop in it such as a 9900x. It cool 12 Core ok but not 9950.
3
Original Poster
Pro
Expert
This user is an Expert in Computers
Last Saturday
19,808 Posts
Joined Jul 2015
Last Saturday
Suryasis
Last Saturday
Original Poster
Pro
Expert
This user is an Expert in Computers
19,808 Posts

Our community has rated this post as helpful. If you agree, why not thank Suryasis

Quote from SlickCrayon1512 :
Good price for this product but why would you want a 8700g in it? If so just get a mini PC like GMKtec with 7840hs for $300 with 32gb and a cheap ssd. Or pay $400 and get one with 8845hs that also have oculink and whatever this have. IMO this product is only good if you put a real desktop in it such as a 9900x. It cool 12 Core ok but not 9950.
This is a different concept where a mobile style Motherboard, with a form factor called STX, is used so that you can upgrade the Processor. For commercial purposes, Dell, HP and Lenovo are using these kind of PCs for a very long time, like Dell Micro, Lenovo Tiny etc. They offer better maintenance and upgradability over soldered Mobile SOC and normally higher number of storage, PCIe lanes as Desktop Processors offer more of those.
For example, if you are not that much concerned about integrated Graphics performance and want to add tons of high speed storage, simply put a Ryzen 7 7000 or 9000 series Desktop CPUs like Ryzen 5 7600 or Ryzen 7 7700, and you will get all the 4 M.2 2280 slots running at Gen 4x4 Speed. Here the concern is not only the absolute performance but the feature set, additional PCIe Lanes, upgradability etc. Say you want to use it in Corporate environment where you need VPro or similar AMD equivalent support, you can just put a Ryzen Pro series CPU on it. These are mainly targeted as Mini Workstation/Homelab servers.
Just check Asrock Deskmini which is available for a very long time for both AMD and Intel Platform and you'll get a good idea.
3
Last Saturday
1,118 Posts
Joined Aug 2019

This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users.

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Last Saturday
621 Posts
Joined Sep 2005
Last Saturday
Nutdotnet
Last Saturday
621 Posts
Quote from SlickCrayon1512 :
still non sense to me. What makes a 8700G over 8845HS? 7840HS and 8845HS are as capable as a 8700G if not more for whatever homelab you need. Is there any home lab setting that only run on desktop CPUs but not their equavelent mobile ones? As far as I know there is no. V Pro is a very niche area that little people use-and even for that there are mini PCs that have v Pros as well, where I have not seen desktop version of vPro myself before. Also, the statement of pcie line is irrelevant. A 8700G only has the same cache and PCIE lane as the mobile ones and mini PCs support 2x or 4x ssd as well.
By all means, using a 8700G in this device is totally non sense to me. For whatever reason you want a 8700G you can be better off with a 7840HS or 8845HS for quite a lot cheaper. if you need 9900x, it does make sense.

Different needs man….
Original Poster
Pro
Expert
This user is an Expert in Computers
6d ago
19,808 Posts
Joined Jul 2015
6d ago
Suryasis
6d ago
Original Poster
Pro
Expert
This user is an Expert in Computers
19,808 Posts
Quote from SlickCrayon1512 :
still non sense to me. What makes a 8700G over 8845HS? 7840HS and 8845HS are as capable as a 8700G if not more for whatever homelab you need. Is there any home lab setting that only run on desktop CPUs but not their equavelent mobile ones? As far as I know there is no. V Pro is a very niche area that little people use-and even for that there are mini PCs that have v Pros as well, where I have not seen desktop version of vPro myself before. Also, the statement of pcie line is irrelevant. A 8700G only has the same cache and PCIE lane as the mobile ones and mini PCs support 2x or 4x ssd as well.By all means, using a 8700G in this device is totally non sense to me. For whatever reason you want a 8700G you can be better off with a 7840HS or 8845HS for quite a lot cheaper. if you need 9900x, it does make sense.
Again, it's not about the performance. If you don't need or don't understand why people need it, you probably don't need it. One thing guess correct, it's for a niche set of people who would love to get hands on these kind of PCs.
And I still don't get why you're so obsessed with 8700G? Just buy the barebone and add whatever CPU you like.
5d ago
734 Posts
Joined Dec 2016
5d ago
Ascender
5d ago
734 Posts
Looks like the bare bones is sold out. I assume the 32gb RAM takes up all the slots? How many threads does this support? I haven't built a PC in 20 years, but I'm looking to use this for a home lab with proxmox.
4d ago
17 Posts
Joined May 2015
4d ago
hzw247
4d ago
17 Posts
soldout
Pro
4d ago
728 Posts
Joined Jun 2006
4d ago
zyberwoof
Pro
4d ago
728 Posts
Quote from Suryasis :
Again, it's not about the performance. If you don't need or don't understand why people need it, you probably don't need it. One thing guess correct, it's for a niche set of people who would love to get hands on these kind of PCs.
And I still don't get why you're so obsessed with 8700G? Just buy the barebone and add whatever CPU you like.
I think you are missing a bit of context. The product of this post, refurbished Minisforum MS-A1, is offered 1 of 2 ways: barebones and with a Ryzen 8700G.

I looked up specs and benchmarks, and to be honest, I think I agree with SlickCrayon1512. The 8700G performs very similarly to the 8845HS. If buying a SFF PC, I agree that saving money and getting a 8845HS makes more sense. Or even better would be if Minisforum offered the MS-A1 with the 8845HS.

I agree with the point your are trying to make. The barebones version of the MS-A1 makes a lot of sense. I keep clicking on these posts because it's tempting for my home lab. But, IMO, it seems to make more sense to pair this with either a much lower-end or higher-end CPU than the 8700G.

A lower-end CPU lets you buy a capable system now while having the option to upgrade later. Or you could start with a much more capable CPU to begin with. But the 8700G seems like an expensive CPU to ditch for a future upgrade.
4d ago
1,740 Posts
Joined Aug 2011
4d ago
stone_
4d ago
1,740 Posts
i assume 9950x + 128gb works with this
Original Poster
Pro
Expert
This user is an Expert in Computers
4d ago
19,808 Posts
Joined Jul 2015
4d ago
Suryasis
4d ago
Original Poster
Pro
Expert
This user is an Expert in Computers
19,808 Posts
Quote from stone_ :
i assume 9950x + 128gb works with this
yes, it will. But the issue is that this platform limits the CPU max TDP to 100W which will severely reduce 9950X perfoermance.

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

4d ago
177 Posts
Joined Nov 2017
4d ago
Baobaodou79
4d ago
177 Posts
Wonder how the thermal is going to be. 8700G is a desktop CPU after all.

Popular Deals

View All

Trending Deals

View All