Slickdeals is community-supported.  We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
forum threadnoeffort posted Yesterday 09:08 PM
forum threadnoeffort posted Yesterday 09:08 PM

Back in stock at Costco. 2025 1 oz American Buffalo Gold Coin $5,099.99

$5,100

Costco Wholesale
12 Comments 1,372 Views
Get Deal at Retailer
Good Deal
Save
Share
Deal Details
Back in stock at Costco. 2025 1 oz American Buffalo Gold Coin $5,099.99 - Costco rewards - 204 = net $4,895.99

Best buy for this... Goes out of stock fast

Back in stock at Costco.

Apmex selling for $5,201.09
https://www.apmex.com/product/299...buffalo-bu



https://www.costco.com/2026-1-oz-...30540.html
Community Notes
About the Poster
Deal Details
Community Notes
About the Poster
Back in stock at Costco. 2025 1 oz American Buffalo Gold Coin $5,099.99 - Costco rewards - 204 = net $4,895.99

Best buy for this... Goes out of stock fast

Back in stock at Costco.

Apmex selling for $5,201.09
https://www.apmex.com/product/299...buffalo-bu



https://www.costco.com/2026-1-oz-...30540.html

Community Voting

Deal Score
-3
Good Deal
Get Deal at Retailer

Leave a Comment

Unregistered (You)

12 Comments

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Yesterday 09:25 PM
1,553 Posts
Joined May 2012
CharlesBarkleyYesterday 09:25 PM
1,553 Posts
Still haven't shipped my metals ordered a week ago, I wonder if they are having trouble keeping up.
Yesterday 09:36 PM
962 Posts
Joined Jun 2011
IsThisRealLifeYesterday 09:36 PM
962 Posts
Be careful don't chase
Yesterday 09:39 PM
70 Posts
Joined Nov 2010
snowlarbearYesterday 09:39 PM
70 Posts
has anyone sold their coin after purchase - do you actually get close to spot price
Yesterday 10:02 PM
958 Posts
Joined Sep 2010
Flawless700Yesterday 10:02 PM
958 Posts
I love golddddd!

Bought this yesterday for 5k flat.

Pro tip!

If you are selling silver and trading it to gold, like a lot of people are doing. Sell your silver to a shop for $5 or $6 back. Do not get the gold there. For a buffalo, they are 250+ premium plus maybe more if you use a CC.

Just give your silver to the shop, take the cash, and buy the gold from Costco for the CC savings and 2% reward.
Yesterday 10:03 PM
958 Posts
Joined Sep 2010
Flawless700Yesterday 10:03 PM
958 Posts
Quote from snowlarbear :
has anyone sold their coin after purchase - do you actually get close to spot price
You will get spot plus some for a buffalo or eagle.
Yesterday 10:13 PM
640 Posts
Joined Jul 2016
jborageYesterday 10:13 PM
640 Posts
Help me do the math on why this is a good deal when the spot price is $4850.

Won't I have to pay tax at Costco?
Yesterday 10:32 PM
1,204 Posts
Joined Nov 2007
cabernetYesterday 10:32 PM
1,204 Posts
Quote from jborage :
Help me do the math on why this is a good deal when the spot price is $4850. Won't I have to pay tax at Costco?
There's no sales tax in California for this but may depend on your state

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Original Poster
Yesterday 10:42 PM
795 Posts
Joined Jan 2007
noeffort
Original Poster
Yesterday 10:42 PM
795 Posts
Quote from CharlesBarkley :
Still haven't shipped my metals ordered a week ago, I wonder if they are having trouble keeping up.
yes they are, you will get it. Took about 6 days before my last order shipped, but got it fedex overnight when it did.
Original Poster
Yesterday 10:46 PM
795 Posts
Joined Jan 2007
noeffort
Original Poster
Yesterday 10:46 PM
795 Posts
Quote from Flawless700 :
I love golddddd!

Bought this yesterday for 5k flat.

Pro tip!

If you are selling silver and trading it to gold, like a lot of people are doing. Sell your silver to a shop for $5 or $6 back. Do not get the gold there. For a buffalo, they are 250+ premium plus maybe more if you use a CC.

Just give your silver to the shop, take the cash, and buy the gold from Costco for the CC savings and 2% reward.
usmint selling buffalo gold 1 oz. proofs for $5,590
https://www.usmint.gov/coins/coin...alo-coins/
Original Poster
Yesterday 10:48 PM
795 Posts
Joined Jan 2007
noeffort
Original Poster
Yesterday 10:48 PM
795 Posts
Quote from jborage :
Help me do the math on why this is a good deal when the spot price is $4850.

Won't I have to pay tax at Costco?
Buffalo's get a premium $5,209.99
https://www.apmex.com/product/299...buffalo-bu
Original Poster
Yesterday 10:50 PM
795 Posts
Joined Jan 2007
noeffort
Original Poster
Yesterday 10:50 PM
795 Posts
Quote from Flawless700 :
I love golddddd!

Bought this yesterday for 5k flat.

Pro tip!

If you are selling silver and trading it to gold, like a lot of people are doing. Sell your silver to a shop for $5 or $6 back. Do not get the gold there. For a buffalo, they are 250+ premium plus maybe more if you use a CC.

Just give your silver to the shop, take the cash, and buy the gold from Costco for the CC savings and 2% reward.
I bought one last month and paid $4,316 after rewards
If you are a Executive member and use Costco CC to purchase, get 4% rewards.
Last edited by noeffort January 21, 2026 at 03:54 PM.
Pro
Today 01:38 AM
39,338 Posts
Joined Nov 2005
Dr. J
Pro
Today 01:38 AM
39,338 Posts
I wouldn't consider this a proof for pricing purposes. Yes it's in plastic but it's not graded.

https://www.monex.com/gold-prices...es7bgoABRj

Buffalo bid is $4788 as I write this.

Leave a Comment

Unregistered (You)

Popular Deals

Trending Deals