This collaborative space allows users to contribute additional information, tips, and insights to enhance the original deal post. Feel free to share your knowledge and help fellow shoppers make informed decisions.
That's EDT, not parfum like OP's link. EDT isn't as strong, doesn't have as high a percentage of the oils. It's also a third party seller, not directly from Walmart. They could very well be legitimate and this isn't meant to say they aren't, I just personally only buy fragrances directly from large retailers. Too many fakes, the stuff is too expensive per ounce to risk that. But again, probably legit. The main price difference is because it's EDT.
That's EDT, not parfum like OP's link. EDT isn't as strong, doesn't have as high a percentage of the oils. It's also a third party seller, not directly from Walmart. They could very well be legitimate and this isn't meant to say they aren't, I just personally only buy fragrances directly from large retailers. Too many fakes, the stuff is too expensive per ounce to risk that. But again, probably legit. The main price difference is because it's EDT.
Quite a bit of words for not doing the first thing anyone should be doing with 3rd party sellers.
Seems to be quite a few feedbacks (at least some of their stock) is fake.
Quite a bit of words for not doing the first thing anyone should be doing with 3rd party sellers. Seems to be quite a few feedbacks (at least some of their stock) is fake.
The first thing I personally do with third party sellers of fragrance is just not buy from them. No need to read the reviews.
The first thing I personally do with third party sellers of fragrance is just not buy from them. No need to read the reviews.
Then don't give a babbling opinion about this seller "could be legit" without anything to back it up.
Given their small feedback number (along with the fact about numerous claims of fakes) per their feedback, people should probably not even consider this seller.
That's EDT, not parfum like OP's link. EDT isn't as strong, doesn't have as high a percentage of the oils. It's also a third party seller, not directly from Walmart. They could very well be legitimate and this isn't meant to say they aren't, I just personally only buy fragrances directly from large retailers. Too many fakes, the stuff is too expensive per ounce to risk that. But again, probably legit. The main price difference is because it's EDT.
It's Discount Mart. A quick search returns positive results for the seller. They appear legit. I don't know why more people don't do a little research with these sellers.
It's Discount Mart. A quick search returns positive results for the seller. They appear legit. I don't know why more people don't do a little research with these sellers.
Great skills, detective. Even from 30 seconds of "research" from just their first page:
-"This product is NOT Oscar de la Renta. I have worn the actual Oscar for forty years and this scent is not the real thing. The bottle looks authentic too but the scent is horrible"
-"Sells fake perfume, should be ashamed of yourself."
-I am very disappointed with my purchase since the product I received was a clear counterfeit and the return process has been very complicated for me
etc, etc.
---"Address" is also an internet cafe in NY. Again, great job
Last edited by SDLooper April 8, 2026 at 06:41 PM.
Great skills, detective. Even from 30 seconds of "research" from just their first page:-"This product is NOT Oscar de la Renta. I have worn the actual Oscar for forty years and this scent is not the real thing. The bottle looks authentic too but the scent is horrible"-"Sells fake perfume, should be ashamed of yourself."-I am very disappointed with my purchase since the product I received was a clear counterfeit and the return process has been very complicated for meetc, etc. ---"Address" is also an internet cafe in NY. Again, great job
Your research is extremely narrow and quite incomplete. Doing a broader search shows more results and a positive overall review. In reviews, there are always disgruntled people and thy may have legit feedback but I find often it's just them being an overt disgruntled person. I see people, possibly even you, who claim completely legitimate sites who sell authentic fragrances, getting comments about selling fakes. The Scent Guy, the best reviewer by far on YT even comments about getting weak scents on occasion and wondering if he got a fake, but he doesn't knock the sites because he knows it could just be his batch or his nose that is the issue.
1
Like
Helpful
Funny
Not helpful
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
11 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Quite a bit of words for not doing the first thing anyone should be doing with 3rd party sellers.
Seems to be quite a few feedbacks (at least some of their stock) is fake.
Given their small feedback number (along with the fact about numerous claims of fakes) per their feedback, people should probably not even consider this seller.
Seems cheaper on Fragrancenet.com
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
-"This product is NOT Oscar de la Renta. I have worn the actual Oscar for forty years and this scent is not the real thing. The bottle looks authentic too but the scent is horrible"
-"Sells fake perfume, should be ashamed of yourself."
-I am very disappointed with my purchase since the product I received was a clear counterfeit and the return process has been very complicated for me
etc, etc.
---"Address" is also an internet cafe in NY. Again, great job
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!