Select Costco Wholesale Stores (link for reference only) have for its
Members: Kirkland Signature USDA Prime Beef Bone-In Ribeye Steak on sale for
$16.99 per pound. Valid for
in-warehouse purchase only. You may check the warehouse section of the
Costco App and search for local inventory using item number
12233.
Thanks to community member
c2nah777 for sharing this deal.
Note: Availability may vary by location.
Top Comments
Here is a guy that cooked both and said there was really no difference other than presentation
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZm4axg
If i were to buy these i would probably cut off the frenched part of the Ribeye to make it easier to manage.
Community Reviews
Costco's USDA Prime tomahawk-style bone-in ribeye is being treated as a big, showy steak that grills well and can deliver rich flavor, tenderness, and strong presentation. The thick cuts are good for sharing, reverse searing, or smoker workflows, and the bone can help with handling and keep the meat from overcooking near the edge. The main knock is value, since the bone adds weight and the effective meat price can feel closer to a much higher boneless ribeye. It is a better fit for special occasions than for everyday steak buying.
Common Questions (5)
Reported in-store prices ranged from $15.99/lb to about $19.97/lb depending on location and listing, with some orders showing $16.99/lb or $18.15/lb online. Several shoppers also noted package discounts and that the price can update in the Costco app.
Buying the whole Prime ribeye roast or primal and cutting your own steaks is often the better value because you avoid paying for the bone and can choose your thickness. The boneless Prime ribeye loin/primal was repeatedly mentioned around $14.99/lb to $15/lb, which is cheaper than the bone-in tomahawk-style cut.
The bone is counted in the weight, so the effective meat price is higher than the sticker price suggests. For a lot of shoppers it's mainly a presentation cut, though the bone-in format can add some flavor and makes a dramatic steak for grilling or special occasions.
The bone itself usually does not change the flavor much during a quick steak cook; the main difference is presentation, and any extra flavor is mostly near the bone. Some people still prefer bone-in for the richer bite around the bone and the way it cooks and looks on the grill.
The item is labeled USDA Prime, and several comments note that Prime is the top grade with more marbling than Choice. A few shoppers still questioned the marbling in specific packages, so it's worth checking the package before buying.
AI-generated summary based on comments from the community. Updated ago
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
209 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
I cook low/slow on a smoker and finish with a high heat sear and have found easy handling with the bone vs grill tools. Also, a similar sized boneless ribeye steak could be mistaken for other cuts of meat so the bone does help there when looking back at photos of BBQ, fathers day, etc.
That all being said, I'm probably just trying to justify my laziness to not order/pickup from a butcher or cut my own steaks lol
https://www.samsclub.co
But Angus Certified is not guaranteed Prime grade.
I bet that for $10 lb recently, it was their choice grade. Still as good or better than non-certified Angus beef. The key is inspecting the package for good marbling. I've thrown back plenty of their steaks, looking hard for a very good one. Sometimes I walk away empty-handed. I'm sure you'd agree you have to choose wisely, especially in this economy.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
## What the Grades Mean
The USDA grades beef based on two factors: **marbling** (intramuscular fat) and the **maturity** of the cattle. Marbling is the white flecks and streaks of fat you see running through the red muscle — the more of it, the more tender, juicy, and flavorful the steak. Both Prime and Choice must come from young cattle; older cattle can't qualify for either grade.[1][2][3]
## USDA Prime Bone-In Ribeye
Prime is the top tier — only about 5–12% of all beef in the U.S. earns this grade. A bone-in Prime ribeye has **abundant to slightly abundant marbling**, which means fat is evenly laced throughout the entire cut. When cooked, that intramuscular fat melts into the meat, delivering a **buttery, rich flavor** and an almost effortless tenderness. You'll find Prime bone-in ribeyes at high-end steakhouses; they're the standard for upscale dining.[1][4][5][6][7]
## USDA Choice Bone-In Ribeye
Choice is still excellent beef — it accounts for roughly 70–75% of graded cattle in the U.S. — but has **moderate to small marbling** compared to Prime. A bone-in Choice ribeye will still be juicy and flavorful, but you may notice a slightly firmer chew and less of that melt-in-your-mouth richness. Importantly, Choice has a wide range within itself: **"Top Choice"** (with modest marbling) can actually rival lower-end Prime steaks. This is what you'll typically find at Costco or a good grocery store.[1][5][6][8]
## The Bone-In Factor
The bone itself doesn't change the grade, but it does enhance flavor for **both** grades. The marrow and surrounding connective tissue release fat and collagen during cooking, adding depth to the crust and the meat closest to the bone. For a Prime bone-in ribeye (sometimes called a cowboy ribeye or tomahawk), the bone amplifies an already rich steak. For a Choice bone-in, the bone helps compensate slightly for the lower fat content.[9]
## Practical Breakdown
| Feature | USDA Prime | USDA Choice |
|---|---|---|
| Marbling | Abundant to slightly abundant | Moderate to small |
| Tenderness | Exceptional, melt-in-mouth | Very good, slight chew |
| Flavor | Deep, buttery, rich | Flavorful, less intense |
| Availability | Specialty butchers, steakhouses | Grocery stores, Costco |
| Price premium | Significantly higher | More wallet-friendly |
| Best for | Grilling, dry-heat, special occasions | Grilling, everyday cooking |
For a special occasion where you're cooking bone-in ribeyes at home, Prime is worth the splurge. However, if you find **upper-tier Choice** (look for heavy marbling in the package), you can get very close to a Prime experience at a meaningfully lower price.[5][7]
Sources
[1] What are the differences between Prime, Choice and Select Steaks? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g28kEW0
[2] Do the different USDA grades of beef indicate anything but marbling ... https://www.reddit.com/r/AskCulin..._ind
[3] Beef Grading Shields | Agricultural Marketing Service - USDA https://www.ams.usda.go
[4] USDA Prime vs Choice Beef: Which One is Better? https://www.sullivansst
[5] USDA Beef Grades Explained: Prime, Choice, & More : BBQGuys https://www.bbqguys.com/a/39929/g...eef-grades
[6] USDA Beef Grading Scale: A Comprehensive Guide https://www.flannerybee
[7] What's Your Beef – Prime, Choice or Select? - USDA https://www.usda.gov/about-usda/n...-or-select
[8] Understanding USDA Beef Grading with Carnez: Prime, Choice, and ... https://carnezmeats.com/blogs/cle...-explained
[9] How big of a taste difference is there between Prime and Choice ... https://www.reddit.com/r/AskCulin...e_be
[10] CHOICE vs. PRIME Ribeye: A Visual Comparison https://www.wildcountry
[11] Professional Butcher Chris Gabriel explains the different grades https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LUwqPA2
[12] USDA Select vs Choice vs Prime, what's the difference ... - Instagram https://www.instagram.c
[13] Does choice vs prime matter for prime rib? - Facebook https://www.facebook.co
[14] Did you know the difference between Prime, Choice, and Select ... https://www.instagram.c
[15] USDA Beef Grades and Marbling Scores - Facebook https://www.facebook.co
https://www.samsclub.co
I love filet mignon which is how they advertise these smaller packages. But a ribeye has more flavor because of the fat. I don't eat the fat though, so a little more wasteful for a ribeye. Olive oil is not the same as rendered beef fat for flavor. Definitely more flavor from having it cook with the fat, then removing excess fat before eating.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!