Select Walmart Stores have Movie Theater Box Candy (2.8-Oz to 5-Oz, various) for $1 each. Select free store pickup where stock permits or purchase in-store.
Thanks to Community Member JohnDubya for posting this deal.
Note: Price/availability for pickup or in-store purchase may vary by location.
Select Target Stores have Movie Theater Box Candy (3.5-Oz to 5-Oz, various) for $1 each. Select free store pickup where stock permits or purchase in-store.
REESE'S PIECES peanut butter candy is as close as you can get to perfection. Imagine taking the classically loved REESE'S peanut butter and smashing it down into tiny pieces of goodness covered with colorful, crunchy candy shells! There's just something about the sound of pouring REESE'S PIECES sweets into your hand during your favorite movie or grabbing some as you walk out the door. Speaking of, keep your covered candy bowls filled with crunchy, delicious REESE'S PIECES peanut butter candy. The peanut candy lovers in your life will empty the dish as fast as you can fill it! Contains one (1) 4-ounce box of REESE'S PIECES Peanut Butter in a Crunchy Shell Candy Dreamy peanut butter candy covered in a crunchy candy shell for all the movie buffs and baking fanatics Kosher certified and gluten free colorful peanut butter candy pieces inside a theater box for easy pouring Use REESE'S candy for filling birthday and retirement party dessert tables or bridal and baby shower candy dishes Enjoy a delicious snack that you can take anywhere, from everyday occasions to seasonal gatherings throughout the year Get into the baking mood with REESE'S PIECES candies inside your cookies, fudge desserts and bars
Model Number:
0003400011470
Product SKU:
10452226
UPC:
34000114702
Community Notes
This collaborative space allows users to contribute additional information, tips, and insights to enhance the original deal post. Feel free to share your knowledge and help fellow shoppers make informed decisions.
Select Walmart Stores have Movie Theater Box Candy (2.8-Oz to 5-Oz, various) for $1 each. Select free store pickup where stock permits or purchase in-store.
Thanks to Community Member JohnDubya for posting this deal.
Note: Price/availability for pickup or in-store purchase may vary by location.
Select Target Stores have Movie Theater Box Candy (3.5-Oz to 5-Oz, various) for $1 each. Select free store pickup where stock permits or purchase in-store.
Deal History includes data from multiple reputable stores, such as Best Buy, Target, and Walmart. The lowest price among stores for a given day is selected as the "Sale Price".
Sale Price does not include sale prices at Amazon unless a deal was posted by a community member.
These used to taste great. Now they taste like plastic. Definite recipe change here.
EDIT: Dug into it and yeah, recipe changed to garbage now.
The old formula had dextrose, milk/whey and relatively little corn-syrup solids. The modern formula has corn-syrup solids as the fourth ingredient, and the newest
version eliminated dextrose and milk entirely.
That could absolutely change sweetness, aroma release and how rich the peanut center seems.
The 2025 dairy-free reformulation could explain a very recent deterioration.
This one is especially interesting if you remember them tasting better even a year or two ago.
The immediately previous recipe contained dextrose and milk. The current recipe contains neither.
Our community has rated this post as helpful. If you agree, why not thank
These used to taste great. Now they taste like plastic. Definite recipe change here.
EDIT: Dug into it and yeah, recipe changed to garbage now.
The old formula had dextrose, milk/whey and relatively little corn-syrup solids. The modern formula has corn-syrup solids as the fourth ingredient, and the newest
version eliminated dextrose and milk entirely.
That could absolutely change sweetness, aroma release and how rich the peanut center seems.
The 2025 dairy-free reformulation could explain a very recent deterioration.
This one is especially interesting if you remember them tasting better even a year or two ago.
The immediately previous recipe contained dextrose and milk. The current recipe contains neither.
Last edited by Wulfrax August 31, 2026 at 06:27 PM.
These used to taste great. Now they taste like plastic. Definite recipe change here.EDIT: Dug into it and yeah, recipe changed to garbage now.The old formula had dextrose, milk/whey and relatively little corn-syrup solids. The modern formula has corn-syrup solids as the fourth ingredient, and the newest version eliminated dextrose and milk entirely.That could absolutely change sweetness, aroma release and how rich the peanut center seems.The 2025 dairy-free reformulation could explain a very recent deterioration.This one is especially interesting if you remember them tasting better even a year or two ago.The immediately previous recipe contained dextrose and milk. The current recipe contains neither.
Noticed this too. I bought one box and thought the taste was chemical and way different than I remember. I won't be buying them again.
These used to taste great. Now they taste like plastic. Definite recipe change here.EDIT: Dug into it and yeah, recipe changed to garbage now.The old formula had dextrose, milk/whey and relatively little corn-syrup solids. The modern formula has corn-syrup solids as the fourth ingredient, and the newest version eliminated dextrose and milk entirely.That could absolutely change sweetness, aroma release and how rich the peanut center seems.The 2025 dairy-free reformulation could explain a very recent deterioration.This one is especially interesting if you remember them tasting better even a year or two ago.The immediately previous recipe contained dextrose and milk. The current recipe contains neither.
I thought it was just my taste changing. They were my favorite back in the 80s. I used to chop them up and use as an ice cream topping.
1
Like
Helpful
Funny
Not helpful
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Our community has rated this post as helpful. If you agree, why not thank
Quote
from Wulfrax
:
These used to taste great. Now they taste like plastic. Definite recipe change here.
EDIT: Dug into it and yeah, recipe changed to garbage now.
The old formula had dextrose, milk/whey and relatively little corn-syrup solids. The modern formula has corn-syrup solids as the fourth ingredient, and the newest
version eliminated dextrose and milk entirely.
That could absolutely change sweetness, aroma release and how rich the peanut center seems.
The 2025 dairy-free reformulation could explain a very recent deterioration.
This one is especially interesting if you remember them tasting better even a year or two ago.
The immediately previous recipe contained dextrose and milk. The current recipe contains neither.
Yeah, definitely need to get the word out there. I didn't have reese's pieces for years, but I tried some a few months ago and they were disgusting. It didn't taste much like peanut butter or chocolate. It was just a waxy thing tasting vaguely of peanut that stubbornly coated the inside of my mouth and made me feel sick. I'm never buying this again. The people who decide to do stuff like this are pathologically anti-human and should be made to suffer the consequences of their decisions.
These used to taste great. Now they taste like plastic. Definite recipe change here.
EDIT: Dug into it and yeah, recipe changed to garbage now.
The old formula had dextrose, milk/whey and relatively little corn-syrup solids. The modern formula has corn-syrup solids as the fourth ingredient, and the newest
version eliminated dextrose and milk entirely.
That could absolutely change sweetness, aroma release and how rich the peanut center seems.
The 2025 dairy-free reformulation could explain a very recent deterioration.
This one is especially interesting if you remember them tasting better even a year or two ago.
The immediately previous recipe contained dextrose and milk. The current recipe contains neither.
Recipe by accounting
Like
Helpful
Funny
Not helpful
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
Top Comments
EDIT: Dug into it and yeah, recipe changed to garbage now.
The old formula had dextrose, milk/whey and relatively little corn-syrup solids. The modern formula has corn-syrup solids as the fourth ingredient, and the newest
version eliminated dextrose and milk entirely.
That could absolutely change sweetness, aroma release and how rich the peanut center seems.
The 2025 dairy-free reformulation could explain a very recent deterioration.
This one is especially interesting if you remember them tasting better even a year or two ago.
The immediately previous recipe contained dextrose and milk. The current recipe contains neither.
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
9 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Our community has rated this post as helpful. If you agree, why not thank
EDIT: Dug into it and yeah, recipe changed to garbage now.
The old formula had dextrose, milk/whey and relatively little corn-syrup solids. The modern formula has corn-syrup solids as the fourth ingredient, and the newest
version eliminated dextrose and milk entirely.
That could absolutely change sweetness, aroma release and how rich the peanut center seems.
The 2025 dairy-free reformulation could explain a very recent deterioration.
This one is especially interesting if you remember them tasting better even a year or two ago.
The immediately previous recipe contained dextrose and milk. The current recipe contains neither.
Our community has rated this post as helpful. If you agree, why not thank
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Our community has rated this post as helpful. If you agree, why not thank
EDIT: Dug into it and yeah, recipe changed to garbage now.
The old formula had dextrose, milk/whey and relatively little corn-syrup solids. The modern formula has corn-syrup solids as the fourth ingredient, and the newest
version eliminated dextrose and milk entirely.
That could absolutely change sweetness, aroma release and how rich the peanut center seems.
The 2025 dairy-free reformulation could explain a very recent deterioration.
This one is especially interesting if you remember them tasting better even a year or two ago.
The immediately previous recipe contained dextrose and milk. The current recipe contains neither.
EDIT: Dug into it and yeah, recipe changed to garbage now.
The old formula had dextrose, milk/whey and relatively little corn-syrup solids. The modern formula has corn-syrup solids as the fourth ingredient, and the newest
version eliminated dextrose and milk entirely.
That could absolutely change sweetness, aroma release and how rich the peanut center seems.
The 2025 dairy-free reformulation could explain a very recent deterioration.
This one is especially interesting if you remember them tasting better even a year or two ago.
The immediately previous recipe contained dextrose and milk. The current recipe contains neither.
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!