4-Pk 2.4-Oz Reese's King Size Peanut Butter Pumpkins (Milk Chocolate or White Creme)

Prngr44

Yesterday 11:53 PM

381 Comments

Joined Apr 2010

Prngr44Yesterday 11:53 PM

381 Comments

Regular pumpkins showing $27 for a 4 pack.

White chocolate is $5.

1

Sklurm

Yesterday 11:59 PM

154 Comments

Joined Dec 2009

SklurmYesterday 11:59 PM

154 Comments

Quote from Prngr44

:

Regular pumpkins showing $27 for a 4 pack.

White chocolate is $5.

Might be regional, both working for me.

1

southsidemike1

Today 12:02 AM

102 Comments

Joined Oct 2017

southsidemike1Today 12:02 AM

102 Comments

Thanks OP.
In for the white chocolate.

1

trulyblest1

Today 12:22 AM

472 Comments

Joined Jan 2007

trulyblest1Today 12:22 AM

472 Comments

I got white chocolate too. $5 Not sure they'll come though! Thx OP

1

Punkydd

Today 3:24 AM

72 Comments

Joined Nov 2021

PunkyddToday 3:24 AM

72 Comments

Ordered the regular ones, said max 3 so for 2.50 each thats a good deal

1

desynergy

Today 6:31 AM

4.8K Comments

Joined Jul 2012

desynergyToday 6:31 AM

4.8K Comments

Is this with the 90% off halloween candy clearance sale?

Edit: Bleh. Not in stock anywhere in KC.

darkangelman1

Today 6:53 AM

90 Comments

Joined Nov 2017

darkangelman1Today 6:53 AM

90 Comments

Just to let you guys know in case you don't know this Reese's and Hershey's are not real chocolate anymore they Shane to a chocolate cream which is more like a baker chocolate it's watered down with vegetable oil instead of cocoa butter like real chocolate should be and the peanut butter is not even real peanut butter it's a peanut butter cream which is more water down too so if you ever noticed the taste of them is not quite right that's why I bought a big old box of them and found out the hard way and then I had friends giving me their reeses candy bars too by the box and they didn't want it either. Supposedly changing back but I don't buy it you know all these companies they're trying to cut corners and what they do they sell the cocoa butter off for skin care and they make their money way more than they do with chocolate so that's why you don't have cocoa butter in your chocolate anymore and that's why I really the only place you can get chocolate for real anymore is either in Switzerland or over in England if they actually say real chocolate you'll look at the tags and they'll say chocolate cream or chocolate imitation then you know you got screwed

jaws8241

Today 7:03 AM

50 Comments

Joined Oct 2018

jaws8241Today 7:03 AM

50 Comments

Quote from darkangelman1

:

Just to let you guys know in case you don't know this Reese's and Hershey's are not real chocolate anymore they Shane to a chocolate cream which is more like a baker chocolate it's watered down with vegetable oil instead of cocoa butter like real chocolate should be and the peanut butter is not even real peanut butter it's a peanut butter cream which is more water down too so if you ever noticed the taste of them is not quite right that's why I bought a big old box of them and found out the hard way and then I had friends giving me their reeses candy bars too by the box and they didn't want it either. Supposedly changing back but I don't buy it you know all these companies they're trying to cut corners and what they do they sell the cocoa butter off for skin care and they make their money way more than they do with chocolate so that's why you don't have cocoa butter in your chocolate anymore and that's why I really the only place you can get chocolate for real anymore is either in Switzerland or over in England if they actually say real chocolate you'll look at the tags and they'll say chocolate cream or chocolate imitation then you know you got screwed

You have no idea what you are talking about; please stop spreading propaganda. The ingredients are clearly listed in the photo on Walmart's site: peanuts, milk chocolate, sugar, dextrose, vegetable oil are the top five (in order) everything else is less than 2%. Some Reese's products did contain more vegetable oil than chocolate but that was never their core line including peanut buttercups or even these seasonal shapes. Only a few novelty items which produced virtually no sales used "watered down" chocolate. There is certainly better chocolate for the money than Hershey's, and there is certainly more expensive chocolate that's significantly better; but there's no need to misrepresent their product.

1

darkangelman1

Today 7:16 AM

90 Comments

Joined Nov 2017

darkangelman1Today 7:16 AM

90 Comments

Quote from jaws8241

:

You have no idea what you are talking about; please stop spreading propaganda. The ingredients are clearly listed in the photo on Walmart's site: peanuts, milk chocolate, sugar, dextrose, vegetable oil are the top five (in order) everything else is less than 2%. Some Reese's products did contain more vegetable oil than chocolate but that was never their core line including peanut buttercups or even these seasonal shapes. Only a few novelty items which produced virtually no sales used "watered down" chocolate. There is certainly better chocolate for the money than Hershey's, and there is certainly more expensive chocolate that's significantly better; but there's no need to misrepresent their product.

I hate to break it to you bud but you're wrong it was all over the Internet just a couple months ago and I actually still have the old box where the peanut butter and a chocolate actually say cream on it not real chocolate if you could look online you'll see it for yourself and it's not propaganda it's the truth they did change the formula go look at how the living Reese's family member the grandson actually said he was disgusted with Hershey and Reese's company right now that they were automatically cheating people out of the original recipe so if you don't believe me there go see it for yourself and it's not propaganda when you're telling yourself and it's not wasn't only a few novelties it was the whole damn product line and if you go look at the Hershey candy bar it's the same damn thing

darkangelman1

Today 7:25 AM

91 Comments

Joined Nov 2017

darkangelman1Today 7:25 AM

91 Comments

Quote from darkangelman1

:

I hate to break it to you bud but you're wrong it was all over the Internet just a couple months ago and I actually still have the old box where the peanut butter and a chocolate actually say cream on it not real chocolate if you could look online you'll see it for yourself and it's not propaganda it's the truth they did change the formula go look at how the living Reese's family member the grandson actually said he was disgusted with Hershey and Reese's company right now that they were automatically cheating people out of the original recipe so if you don't believe me there go see it for yourself and it's not propaganda when you're telling yourself and it's not wasn't only a few novelties it was the whole damn product line and if you go look at the Hershey candy bar it's the same damn thing

They're not one chocolate candy maker in America that has real chocolate you actually have to get it imported from overseas over in Europe they have stricter tolerances on chocolate and it has to be pure chocolate to be able to be sold here used to be like that until hersheys changed their trip about ten years ago. Also chocolate baking powder is not real chocolate baking powder either there are tons of videos on it telling you how it's made online. The only way to get real chocolate baking powder you have to buy it from Amazon and a bag and I think they actually say kachava or something like thst. it's in a green and white bag. Not even Nestle house chips are real chocolate anymore. Ghiradelli used to be the last standing true chocolate out there. Canada is now doing the same thing American factories are doing.
Looks like Hershey finally caved. They're pulling the plug on the cheap compound coating and swapping back to the classic milk‑and‑dark chocolate recipe for all Reese's by 2027. The core Peanut Butter Cups have stayed true, but the newer shapes and Fast Break bars were the ones using the imitation stuff. Brad Reese – the grandson of H.B. Reese – went public in early 2026 calling out Hershey for swapping the real milk‑chocolate and peanut‑butter mix for cheaper stuff. The backlash was enough that Hershey said they'll roll the classic recipe back for all Reese's starting next year.

Browse every Black Friday offer we could findBrowse every Black Friday offer we could find

4-Pk 2.4-Oz Reese's King Size Peanut Butter Pumpkins (Milk Chocolate or White Creme)

$2.50

Editor's Notes

Original Post

Editor's Notes

Original Post

Community Voting

Join The Conversation

10 Comments

Join The Conversation

Related Searches