This collaborative space allows users to contribute additional information, tips, and insights to enhance the original deal post. Feel free to share your knowledge and help fellow shoppers make informed decisions.
The are a couple things to note here. The first is that it's always difficult to assess exactly which components are being used in an SSD, as manufactures are always changing things. With that said, it seems that the big (but not only) difference here is that the Crucial drive has DRAM to speed things up a bit. For a boot drive, DRAM is generally preferable.
The second thing to note is the target audience of the drive. Crucial is a premium brand that is owned directly by the manufacturer of the NAND (Micron). PNY is generally a budget brand in the SSD space, buy NAND on the open market. The drive you linked uses Micron NAND, by the way. My suspicion is that Micron retains the stuff with the highest quality control for their house brand.
So, it kind of depends on what you need the drive for. For secondary storage, get either. The PNY is probably fine even as a boot drive if you don't mind it hitting it's limits a little sooner. Your mom would be hard pressed to tell a big difference.
The are a couple things to note here. The first is that it's always difficult to assess exactly which components are being used in an SSD, as manufactures are always changing things. With that said, it seems that the big (but not only) difference here is that the Crucial drive has DRAM to speed things up a bit. For a boot drive, DRAM is generally preferable.
The second thing to note is the target audience of the drive. Crucial is a premium brand that is owned directly by the manufacturer of the NAND (Micron). PNY is generally a budget brand in the SSD space, buy NAND on the open market. The drive you linked uses Micron NAND, by the way. My suspicion is that Micron retains the stuff with the highest quality control for their house brand.
So, it kind of depends on what you need the drive for. For secondary storage, get either. The PNY is probably fine even as a boot drive if you don't mind it hitting it's limits a little sooner. Your mom would be hard pressed to tell a big difference.
Which one would you recommend for reliablility i.e. as an internal data storage option among PNY, Adata, Samsung, Crucial, etc. I won't use it as boot option, but data on it will be syncing to cloud.
I dont see branded ones for the price you talking about. Name a tier 1 brand?
TeamGroup, Silicon Power, PNY, Lexar, etc... all decent brands for the average consumer. None of them is Samsung, but neither is Crucial. In the end, all SSD components are made by the same few manufacturers.
Unless you have very specific performance needs (e.g., for specific professional uses), you'll be fine with any of these.
TeamGroup, Silicon Power, PNY, Lexar, etc... all decent brands for the average consumer. None of them is Samsung, but neither is Crucial. In the end, all SSD components are made by the same few manufacturers.
Unless you have very specific performance needs (e.g., for specific professional uses), you'll be fine with any of these.
According to this reddit flowchart for SSDs (https://ssd.borecraft.com/SSD_Buying_Guide.png) it seems like most of what I'm finding on your link are entry level SATA drives while this Crucial MX500 is a high end drive.
According to this reddit flowchart for SSDs (https://ssd.borecraft.com/SSD_Buying_Guide.png) it seems like most of what I'm finding on your link are entry level SATA drives while this Crucial MX500 is a high end drive.
My point was two-fold:
(1) Why does Crucial price its SSDs the same as Samsung, when I believe Samsung SSDs are better (personal opinion)? In other words, I understand paying the Samsung brand tax when needing a high-end SSD, but I don't understand why Crucial charges a similar, equal tax.
(2) The average user will do fine with a ~30% cheaper SSD, albeit from a lesser brand or product line—especially when on a limited budget.
Unless you have specific needs (technical-specs wise) or you are very particular about what brand/model product you need, you will be fine with an entry-level SSD. SATA SSDs have been around long enough that performance will be virtually the same between most, if not all, current brands and models for the average user and use cases (e.g., video game storage).
I have bought both high-end and entry-level SSDs based on what I needed them for, and I haven't had issues with any of them.
Edit: clarified where I was coming from
Last edited by mihscr September 27, 2023 at 08:47 PM.
Like
Helpful
Funny
Not helpful
Join The Conversation
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
Join The Conversation
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
9 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
I know Crucial is a good brand, but is it noticeably better than what I ordered?
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08GB8S...ct_de
I know Crucial is a good brand, but is it noticeably better than what I ordered?
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08GB8S...ct_de
The second thing to note is the target audience of the drive. Crucial is a premium brand that is owned directly by the manufacturer of the NAND (Micron). PNY is generally a budget brand in the SSD space, buy NAND on the open market. The drive you linked uses Micron NAND, by the way. My suspicion is that Micron retains the stuff with the highest quality control for their house brand.
So, it kind of depends on what you need the drive for. For secondary storage, get either. The PNY is probably fine even as a boot drive if you don't mind it hitting it's limits a little sooner. Your mom would be hard pressed to tell a big difference.
The second thing to note is the target audience of the drive. Crucial is a premium brand that is owned directly by the manufacturer of the NAND (Micron). PNY is generally a budget brand in the SSD space, buy NAND on the open market. The drive you linked uses Micron NAND, by the way. My suspicion is that Micron retains the stuff with the highest quality control for their house brand.
So, it kind of depends on what you need the drive for. For secondary storage, get either. The PNY is probably fine even as a boot drive if you don't mind it hitting it's limits a little sooner. Your mom would be hard pressed to tell a big difference.
Unless you have very specific performance needs (e.g., for specific professional uses), you'll be fine with any of these.
https://pcpartpicker.co
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Unless you have very specific performance needs (e.g., for specific professional uses), you'll be fine with any of these.
https://pcpartpicker.com/products...sort=price [pcpartpicker.com]
(1) Why does Crucial price its SSDs the same as Samsung, when I believe Samsung SSDs are better (personal opinion)? In other words, I understand paying the Samsung brand tax when needing a high-end SSD, but I don't understand why Crucial charges a similar, equal tax.
(2) The average user will do fine with a ~30% cheaper SSD, albeit from a lesser brand or product line—especially when on a limited budget.
Unless you have specific needs (technical-specs wise) or you are very particular about what brand/model product you need, you will be fine with an entry-level SSD. SATA SSDs have been around long enough that performance will be virtually the same between most, if not all, current brands and models for the average user and use cases (e.g., video game storage).
I have bought both high-end and entry-level SSDs based on what I needed them for, and I haven't had issues with any of them.
Edit: clarified where I was coming from
Join The Conversation
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!