These responses are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser.
Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser.
It is not the bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.
Opinions expressed here are the author's alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, airline or hotel chain, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities.
A bank/credit union CD will usually give you two options:
- Let the interest collect/reinvest in the CD and take all the money at the end of the term. (Note: Brokered CDs don't do this).
- Collect the interest as-you-go, usually monthly or quarterly.
Then, at the end of the term the bank CD has the big *gotcha*.
You have x number of days after the CD matures to take your money out. You have to do in that timeframe. If you do not, it rolls over into another CD of the same term (I.E. 1 year CD makes a new 1 year CD). That new CD probably won't have your awesome promotional rate, and you get *R$#(ed if you let them do that.
So, if you buy a bank CD, have a calendar reminder to take the money out at the right time!
5% not 5.5% (a 60 days 0.5% bonus is awarded for depositing $1k). However, when rates drop so will the interest in Robinhood, the CD is locked in. Not financial advice.
Savings account rate can dip at any time.
Sure the funds are locked in with a CD, but so is the rate.
Obviously you're not supposed to put emergency funds in a CD. Just funds you're sure you don't need for a while.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
There were two or so negative comments about this bank. I'd like to add a 3rd.
I had (and am still paying off) a credit line with them. It was a pretty good rate, but the way they did things for me, was you had to submit a request in if you wanted to use it.
After submitting 3 requests, and being denied each time, I called them with the fairly logical, "Hey, I have a credit line with this much, but you won't let me use it. Why? And what's the point of having one if you keep denying my requests?"
They were no help. That credit line was then converted to a loan, so I now I definitely could not draw any money out. I'm sure there was some fine print that I did not read somewhere, but this loan took money out of my account twice a month. I've never had a bill that automatically deducted money from my account twice a month. I'm sure they exist, but I've never had one before this one.
I never missed a loan payment (now or then) but I did not know about the dual monthly payment until it happened and pushed my account below the "bank will now charge you to have a checking account" balance. I do take responsibility in that there is some documentation saying that if ever a credit line is turned into a loan, it will automatically take money out of your account every 2 weeks. I will even take responsibility in saying I can understand why the denied my request for drawings funds out of my credit line. I was at 70% of the available credit and wanted to go to 85%. I'm sure they didn't like that.
All that being said, I definitely feel I was treated badly by this bank. Granted there is a grain of salt in there, in that if you just have a savings account, or a CD sitting there for however many months or years; I'm sure they are just fine. They don't seem to have any issue holding or keeping your money. But I can get "just fine" at a lot of different banks. Take my story for what it's worth.
This is the most level-headed, reasoned, non-dramatic, one-star-do-not-recommend review that I've ever read. 😆
You might regret not grabbing this when the fed lowers rates at any minute and your savings account yield drops to 4 and this offer is gone
is there an approximate date when CD percentages like this one will generally go significantly down? I know that no one knows for sure, but would you estimate sometime in September? mid September? late September or beyond?
I know they are FDIC insured up to $250,000. What if you have more than that amount that you want to put into a CD? Are you able to make multiple CD accounts under your name and they will each be insured up to $250,000?
Just to let you guys know. Marcus by Goldman Sachs is getting out of retail banking. Their selling out to a company called BETTERMENT at the end of 2024.
so what would that mean for people that will have 12 month CD accounts? they still have to honor that, right?
I second this. I am surprised they are still able to operate after the whole Gamestock fiasco.
I still have some of their stock which I need to ditch if it ever goes back positive territory above $30 a share.
It was a referall program called relationship money market. I think you may have to call a local branch to see if they can hook it up. I literally was looking around for a while and got a call from the branch where my Mom lives (Naples, FL) with the branch rep and my Mom on the line letting me know about it and within 30 minutes I had an email w/ code to take to my local branch. Had it up and funded in about 72 hours. PNC had the money prior at 1.25% and I am a happy camper now. Moving my 5.0% Ally CD funds in a month once it matures.
Quote
from Lilyly
:
was that fifth third a limited promo? i just checked and they only offer 0.01%
I can find rates as high as 5.35%, but not with big name backing like GS.
Doesn't matter if a big bank or a small bank. What you need to look for if it is FDIC insured. So up to $250,000 you are guranteed to get your money back even if the bank defaults
Doesn't matter if a big bank or a small bank. What you need to look for if it is FDIC insured. So up to $250,000 you are guranteed to get your money back even if the bank defaults
I tend to agree and purchase from any bank with a good rate. I have ones from Discover Bank, VIA Credit Union, Grant County State Bank, First National Bank of America, and a few corporate bonds and munis. Just depends on who has the best deal for the term I want at the time I'm buying.
But, I can see a logic behind wanting to go with stronger banks, or at least avoiding weak banks.
You don't exactly know how that FDIC will handle a bank going bust.
- They may give you the cash owed to date, in which case you would lose the rest of your interest on a long-term CD with a favorable rate.
- They could sell the CD to another bank that will honor the CD. In that case, you have the red tape of setting up new e-banking accounts, getting access to everything.... Pain in the α$$.
I second this. I am surprised they are still able to operate after the whole Gamestock fiasco.
I still have some of their stock which I need to ditch if it ever goes back positive territory above $30 a share.
I created 5 accounts each with 9K for the full year term.
If for some reason I need some extra cash on hand, instead of cancelling a single CD and lose tons of interest. I just cancel 1 of them. Haven't needed to use them before but its free insurance basically.
OHHH, interesting, when I googled for CD ladders usual examples were - setup 5, one for 1 yr, 1 for 2 yrs etc. or smaller steps that you need to manage monthly
It all makes sense but hard to get there from the scratch at the beginning with no CDs. Your example makes total sense. If I need money I loose % only on 9K or whatever $$$. Thank you! So simple! I appreciate you taking the time to respond.
I know they are FDIC insured up to $250,000. What if you have more than that amount that you want to put into a CD? Are you able to make multiple CD accounts under your name and they will each be insured up to $250,000?
You'd have to go with different ownership.
You could go with a different bank for the 2nd CD.
Or, you could put the 2nd CD in your spouse's name, and make a 3rd CD joint-owned.
111 Comments
Your comment cannot be blank.
Featured Comments
- Let the interest collect/reinvest in the CD and take all the money at the end of the term. (Note: Brokered CDs don't do this).
- Collect the interest as-you-go, usually monthly or quarterly.
Then, at the end of the term the bank CD has the big *gotcha*.
You have x number of days after the CD matures to take your money out. You have to do in that timeframe. If you do not, it rolls over into another CD of the same term (I.E. 1 year CD makes a new 1 year CD). That new CD probably won't have your awesome promotional rate, and you get *R$#(ed if you let them do that.
So, if you buy a bank CD, have a calendar reminder to take the money out at the right time!
Sure the funds are locked in with a CD, but so is the rate.
Obviously you're not supposed to put emergency funds in a CD. Just funds you're sure you don't need for a while.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Betterment started by being one of the first innovators with retail robo-advisors that automatically maintain an asset allocation.
Being retail, small investor focused (unlike GS), they'll probably do a good job with CDs.
I had (and am still paying off) a credit line with them. It was a pretty good rate, but the way they did things for me, was you had to submit a request in if you wanted to use it.
After submitting 3 requests, and being denied each time, I called them with the fairly logical, "Hey, I have a credit line with this much, but you won't let me use it. Why? And what's the point of having one if you keep denying my requests?"
They were no help. That credit line was then converted to a loan, so I now I definitely could not draw any money out. I'm sure there was some fine print that I did not read somewhere, but this loan took money out of my account twice a month. I've never had a bill that automatically deducted money from my account twice a month. I'm sure they exist, but I've never had one before this one.
I never missed a loan payment (now or then) but I did not know about the dual monthly payment until it happened and pushed my account below the "bank will now charge you to have a checking account" balance. I do take responsibility in that there is some documentation saying that if ever a credit line is turned into a loan, it will automatically take money out of your account every 2 weeks. I will even take responsibility in saying I can understand why the denied my request for drawings funds out of my credit line. I was at 70% of the available credit and wanted to go to 85%. I'm sure they didn't like that.
All that being said, I definitely feel I was treated badly by this bank. Granted there is a grain of salt in there, in that if you just have a savings account, or a CD sitting there for however many months or years; I'm sure they are just fine. They don't seem to have any issue holding or keeping your money. But I can get "just fine" at a lot of different banks. Take my story for what it's worth.
I still have some of their stock which I need to ditch if it ever goes back positive territory above $30 a share.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
I can find rates as high as 5.35%, but not with big name backing like GS.
But, I can see a logic behind wanting to go with stronger banks, or at least avoiding weak banks.
You don't exactly know how that FDIC will handle a bank going bust.
- They may give you the cash owed to date, in which case you would lose the rest of your interest on a long-term CD with a favorable rate.
- They could sell the CD to another bank that will honor the CD. In that case, you have the red tape of setting up new e-banking accounts, getting access to everything.... Pain in the α$$.
I still have some of their stock which I need to ditch if it ever goes back positive territory above $30 a share.
*cough* tax loss harvesting *cough*
If for some reason I need some extra cash on hand, instead of cancelling a single CD and lose tons of interest. I just cancel 1 of them. Haven't needed to use them before but its free insurance basically.
It all makes sense but hard to get there from the scratch at the beginning with no CDs. Your example makes total sense. If I need money I loose % only on 9K or whatever $$$. Thank you! So simple! I appreciate you taking the time to respond.
You could go with a different bank for the 2nd CD.
Or, you could put the 2nd CD in your spouse's name, and make a 3rd CD joint-owned.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.