This collaborative space allows users to contribute additional information, tips, and insights to enhance the original deal post. Feel free to share your knowledge and help fellow shoppers make informed decisions.
There is no "best" stud finder out there, because different stud finders excel at different things. This one is easy to use, its display is intuitive, and (most importantly) it gives more consistent/reliable results than any other stud finder I have used.
But it has two big limitations: it can't detect hot wires, and it can't distinguish between metal pipes and studs.
So I use this as my primary stud finder, but verify its findings with another stud finder to look for hot wires and pipes before doing anything.
Here's a review of some of the differences for this model (m210) vs the lower end models such as AC live wire detection/etc . . . it also demonstrates how Franklin Stud Finders work differently from the usual products from other vendors: https://youtu.be/CFxwJckrzK8?si=qNnYziVLTNCpq2VD
97 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
There is no "best" stud finder out there, because different stud finders excel at different things. This one is easy to use, its display is intuitive, and (most importantly) it gives more consistent/reliable results than any other stud finder I have used.
But it has two big limitations: it can't detect hot wires, and it can't distinguish between metal pipes and studs.
So I use this as my primary stud finder, but verify its findings with another stud finder to look for hot wires and pipes before doing anything.
What is the other "stud finder [you use] to look for hot wires and pipes before doing anything"?
The purpose of the OP is inform the SD community that you can get a $62.97 Franklin m210 for basically half the price (even cheaper if you're lucky enough to find it in the warehouse) but with Costco's great return policy if any problems . . . my understanding was they are clearing these out at the warehouses so I don't know how long it'll be offered online . . . I've been wanting to get one of these but not at $60 so this fits the bill . . .
Last edited by N123 September 7, 2024 at 07:39 PM.
I have the m150 from harborfreight (check sales/coupons) and it's fantastic for everything drywall I've done. Recently used it for 2 sets of 4x8 overhead garage door storage and it was a life saver.
There is no "best" stud finder out there, because different stud finders excel at different things. This one is easy to use, its display is intuitive, and (most importantly) it gives more consistent/reliable results than any other stud finder I have used.
But it has two big limitations: it can't detect hot wires, and it can't distinguish between metal pipes and studs.
So I use this as my primary stud finder, but verify its findings with another stud finder to look for hot wires and pipes before doing anything.
100% agree with you.
I have a similar Franklin Sensor stud finder as the primary, but also use another from Zircon as secondary to confirm. They use different method to find stud.
The Franklin Sensor one fail to find the stud when there is a board behind (ie. head board above a window), but the Zircon one will find it because it "zeros" where you turn it on.
There is no "best" stud finder out there, because different stud finders excel at different things. This one is easy to use, its display is intuitive, and (most importantly) it gives more consistent/reliable results than any other stud finder I have used.
But it has two big limitations: it can't detect hot wires, and it can't distinguish between metal pipes and studs.
So I use this as my primary stud finder, but verify its findings with another stud finder to look for hot wires and pipes before doing anything.
I'm confused. I have this model, bought it from Costco several months ago, and it does have active wire detection. Are you mixing up models or saying the functionality just doesn't work well? So far in my use it seems to be able to detect electricity decently enough.
It does have live wire detection. Says so in the description 👍
You are only reporting what you read in the sales blurb. I am reporting my experience from using it.
The live wire detection is so vague and inconsistent as to be almost worthless. It will tell you that there is a live wire, but you can't know exactly where it is. And you don't necessarily get a repeatable result. The manual even states:
"To best detect the presence of live electrical wires, slowly scan in both directions, passing over the same location multiple times, for a more accurate reading."
Its weak performance with live wires is in sharp contrast to its excellent stud locating ability.
2
Like
Helpful
Funny
Not helpful
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Leave a Comment
Top Comments
But it has two big limitations: it can't detect hot wires, and it can't distinguish between metal pipes and studs.
So I use this as my primary stud finder, but verify its findings with another stud finder to look for hot wires and pipes before doing anything.
https://youtu.be/CFxwJckrzK8?si=
97 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
But it has two big limitations: it can't detect hot wires, and it can't distinguish between metal pipes and studs.
So I use this as my primary stud finder, but verify its findings with another stud finder to look for hot wires and pipes before doing anything.
Does not work at all with double sheetrock walls (new build interior garage door wall for me).
Used this on normal 5/8 walls to hang pegboard, totally fine.
The purpose of the OP is inform the SD community that you can get a $62.97 Franklin m210 for basically half the price (even cheaper if you're lucky enough to find it in the warehouse) but with Costco's great return policy if any problems . . . my understanding was they are clearing these out at the warehouses so I don't know how long it'll be offered online . . . I've been wanting to get one of these but not at $60 so this fits the bill . . .
Use your knuckle and a neodymium magnet
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
But it has two big limitations: it can't detect hot wires, and it can't distinguish between metal pipes and studs.
So I use this as my primary stud finder, but verify its findings with another stud finder to look for hot wires and pipes before doing anything.
I have a similar Franklin Sensor stud finder as the primary, but also use another from Zircon as secondary to confirm. They use different method to find stud.
The Franklin Sensor one fail to find the stud when there is a board behind (ie. head board above a window), but the Zircon one will find it because it "zeros" where you turn it on.
But it has two big limitations: it can't detect hot wires, and it can't distinguish between metal pipes and studs.
So I use this as my primary stud finder, but verify its findings with another stud finder to look for hot wires and pipes before doing anything.
The live wire detection is so vague and inconsistent as to be almost worthless. It will tell you that there is a live wire, but you can't know exactly where it is. And you don't necessarily get a repeatable result. The manual even states:
"To best detect the presence of live electrical wires, slowly scan in both directions, passing over the same location multiple times, for a more accurate reading."
Its weak performance with live wires is in sharp contrast to its excellent stud locating ability.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Leave a Comment