Slickdeals is community-supported.  We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
Heads up, this deal has expired. Want to create a deal alert for this item?
expiredspyder2799 posted Sep 11, 2024 02:38 AM
expiredspyder2799 posted Sep 11, 2024 02:38 AM

Costco Offer:2024 1 oz American Buffalo Gold Coin - $2599.99

$2,600

Costco Wholesale
3,226 Views
Visit Retailer
Good Deal
Save
Share
Deal Details
Features:
999.9 Fine Gold Coin
Item is Non-Refundable
Limit of 1 Transaction Per Membership, with a Maximum of 5 Units
Item is Not Eligible for Price Adjustments

https://www.costco.com/.product.1...ue&nf=true
Community Notes
About the Poster
Deal Details
Community Notes
About the Poster
Features:
999.9 Fine Gold Coin
Item is Non-Refundable
Limit of 1 Transaction Per Membership, with a Maximum of 5 Units
Item is Not Eligible for Price Adjustments

https://www.costco.com/.product.1...ue&nf=true

Community Voting

Deal Score
+2
Good Deal
Visit Retailer

Leave a Comment

Unregistered (You)

9 Comments

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Sep 11, 2024 02:51 AM
27,178 Posts
Joined Jun 2005
ionizerSep 11, 2024 02:51 AM
27,178 Posts
Only 80 over spot price?
Sep 11, 2024 12:07 PM
2,387 Posts
Joined Jan 2024
WolfTheCatSep 11, 2024 12:07 PM
2,387 Posts
JM bullion will buy it for $2533, less about $40 to ship it to them:
https://www.jmbullion.com/my-acco...r.weight=1
* Note: They pay more for buffalos than eagles, for some reason.

With 4% executive and credit card cash back, it costs $2495.

So, transaction cost is about negative $2.00 including shipping - basically zero. You may be able to find a slightly better sell price if you shop around.

Compare that to an ETF, where holding cost is about 1% of your investment every 4-5 years due to ETF management fees.

Holding cost on physical gold is zero if you already have a safe place to store it.
Sep 11, 2024 10:00 PM
282 Posts
Joined Aug 2019
PurpleNarwhal693Sep 11, 2024 10:00 PM
282 Posts
New to this, I couldnt find why buffaloes are about $50 more than fortuna. Is it the $50 guaranteed by the US gov?
Sep 11, 2024 11:00 PM
2,387 Posts
Joined Jan 2024
WolfTheCatSep 11, 2024 11:00 PM
2,387 Posts
Quote from PurpleNarwhal693 :
New to this, I couldnt find why buffaloes are about $50 more than fortuna. Is it the $50 guaranteed by the US gov?
No. The $50 face value is irrelevant.

Gold items have two value components.

Buffalos have a little more numismatic value, which is basically the extra value collectors give it for it's history, rarity, or design.

Both have the same physical/melt value.

Basically, collectors would rather have a buffalo than a PAMP bar.
1
Sep 12, 2024 01:49 AM
282 Posts
Joined Aug 2019
PurpleNarwhal693Sep 12, 2024 01:49 AM
282 Posts
Quote from WolfTheCat :
No. The $50 face value is irrelevant.

Gold items have two value components.

Buffalos have a little more numismatic value, which is basically the extra value collectors give it for it's history, rarity, or design.

Both have the same physical/melt value.

Basically, collectors would rather have a buffalo than a PAMP bar.
Thank you, that's quite helpful! I was reading a thread on Reddit on which to buy and most comments said "whichever is closer to spot". I originally interpreted as whichever is closer to the 1oz gold price (which would always be fortuna since it's cheaper) but now I'm understanding that the spot values would be different for each.

ETA: I don't think i worded that last sentence right
Last edited by PurpleNarwhal693 September 11, 2024 at 07:04 PM.
Sep 12, 2024 02:26 AM
2,833 Posts
Joined Mar 2009
observer1313Sep 12, 2024 02:26 AM
2,833 Posts
Offer has ended.
Sep 12, 2024 02:31 AM
2,833 Posts
Joined Mar 2009
observer1313Sep 12, 2024 02:31 AM
2,833 Posts
Quote from WolfTheCat :
* Note: They pay more for buffalos than eagles, for some reason.
Maybe the same reason I won't buy Eagles: Eagles are not pure gold (Yes, I know Eagles contain 1 troy ounce of gold).

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Sep 12, 2024 10:10 AM
2,387 Posts
Joined Jan 2024
WolfTheCatSep 12, 2024 10:10 AM
2,387 Posts
[quote="PurpleNarwhal693;172816899"]Thank you, that's quite helpful! I was reading a thread on Reddit on which to buy and most comments said "whichever is closer to spot". I originally interpreted as whichever is closer to the 1oz gold price (which would always be fortuna since it's cheaper) but now I'm understanding that the spot values would be different for each.

That is a logic - to try to buy gold for the lowest price, to have maximum intrinsic value of the gold and minimum numismatic value. Spot price really doesn't have anything to do with that - cheapest you can find. The logic behind that is that gold is "real" value, while numismatic is not. If you ascribe to that, buy the PAMP - it costs less.

However, that isn't really true. Both are real value. Most of gold's value is due to the fact it's collected - it doesn't have much industrial/practical use that drives it's cost. Intrinsic gold value is more stable, while numismatic value fluctuates more on the whims of collectors.

If you go to Kitco, JM Buillion, or your local coin shop, they'll all pay more for a buffalo than a PAMP bar (unless for some reason the design caught on).

For us (the small investor), we kinda have to buy some of both values. Even PAMP spends money to stamp fancy designs on their gold to add a little value and try to make more money, in the hopes a design will catch on and gain value. It's hard for the small investor to buy boring, unadorned blocks for any less money, so you might as well take the design.

Personally, I just look at the current price at Costco vs. the price I can sell it for today at JM Bullion. If that's looks good, I may buy. I don't sweat what "kind" of value it is.

I don't see gold spot price as very relevant to me. I can't buy for spot, and I can't sell for spot - it's just a general reference number to know whether gold is generally going up/down.
Last edited by WolfTheCat September 12, 2024 at 04:52 AM.
1
Sep 16, 2024 02:07 AM
282 Posts
Joined Aug 2019
PurpleNarwhal693Sep 16, 2024 02:07 AM
282 Posts
[quote="WolfTheCat;172820295"]
Quote from PurpleNarwhal693 :
Thank you, that's quite helpful! I was reading a thread on Reddit on which to buy and most comments said "whichever is closer to spot". I originally interpreted as whichever is closer to the 1oz gold price (which would always be fortuna since it's cheaper) but now I'm understanding that the spot values would be different for each.

That is a logic - to try to buy gold for the lowest price, to have maximum intrinsic value of the gold and minimum numismatic value. Spot price really doesn't have anything to do with that - cheapest you can find. The logic behind that is that gold is "real" value, while numismatic is not. If you ascribe to that, buy the PAMP - it costs less.

However, that isn't really true. Both are real value. Most of gold's value is due to the fact it's collected - it doesn't have much industrial/practical use that drives it's cost. Intrinsic gold value is more stable, while numismatic value fluctuates more on the whims of collectors.

If you go to Kitco, JM Buillion, or your local coin shop, they'll all pay more for a buffalo than a PAMP bar (unless for some reason the design caught on).

For us (the small investor), we kinda have to buy some of both values. Even PAMP spends money to stamp fancy designs on their gold to add a little value and try to make more money, in the hopes a design will catch on and gain value. It's hard for the small investor to buy boring, unadorned blocks for any less money, so you might as well take the design.

Personally, I just look at the current price at Costco vs. the price I can sell it for today at JM Bullion. If that's looks good, I may buy. I don't sweat what "kind" of value it is.

I don't see gold spot price as very relevant to me. I can't buy for spot, and I can't sell for spot - it's just a general reference number to know whether gold is generally going up/down.
Hey these are great insights, thanks so much for sharing. I have a better understanding now and I think your approach of comparing against the websites would be better than preferring one over the other. Really appreciate you taking the time to comment!

Leave a Comment

Unregistered (You)

Popular Deals

Trending Deals