Slickdeals is community-supported.  We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
Heads up, this deal has expired. Want to create a deal alert for this item?
expired Posted by phoinix | Staff • Jan 21, 2025
expired Posted by phoinix | Staff • Jan 21, 2025

30-Oz Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise Jar (Regular)

w/ Subscribe & Save

$3.30

$5.49

39% off
Amazon
47 Comments 12,363 Views
Visit Amazon
Good Deal
Save
Share
Deal Details
Amazon has 30-Oz Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise Jar (Regular) on sale for $3.49 - $0.17 (5% off when you check out via Subscribe & Save) = $3.32. Shipping is free with Prime or on $35+ orders.Thanks to Deal Hunter phoinix for finding this deal.

About this Product:
  • Crafted using only the egg yolks and a few simple ingredients
  • Great for grilling, dips, dressings, sauces and salad
  • Made-like-homemade recipe of oil, vinegar and only the egg yolks is the secret to a rich, creamy, mayonnaise with full, balanced flavor that makes good food taste great

Editor's Notes

Written by Corwin | Staff

Original Post

Written by phoinix | Staff
Product Info
Community Notes
About the Poster
Deal Details
Product Info
Community Notes
About the Poster
Amazon has 30-Oz Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise Jar (Regular) on sale for $3.49 - $0.17 (5% off when you check out via Subscribe & Save) = $3.32. Shipping is free with Prime or on $35+ orders.Thanks to Deal Hunter phoinix for finding this deal.

About this Product:
  • Crafted using only the egg yolks and a few simple ingredients
  • Great for grilling, dips, dressings, sauces and salad
  • Made-like-homemade recipe of oil, vinegar and only the egg yolks is the secret to a rich, creamy, mayonnaise with full, balanced flavor that makes good food taste great

Editor's Notes

Written by Corwin | Staff

Original Post

Written by phoinix | Staff

Community Voting

Deal Score
+28
Good Deal
Visit Amazon

Price Intelligence

Model: Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise, Homestyle Mayo For Chicken Salad to Deviled Eggs, 30 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)

Deal History 

Sale Price
Slickdeal
  • $NaN
  • Today

Current Prices

Sort: Lowest to Highest | Last Updated 7/12/2025, 05:00 PM
Sold By Sale Price
Target$4.69
Amazon$6.43
Sam's Club$6.68

Leave a Comment

Unregistered (You)

Top Comments

Selman
4216 Posts
1723 Reputation
JFG, Blue Plate, and Great Value are all extremely similar mayos. They are creamy with low acidity. Hellmann's is similar, but with a little more acidity. Kewpie is more rich than all of those. Duke's is more acidic than all of those. They are all good depending on what you are trying to achieve, but Great Value is a very comparable mayo to Blue Plate. This is from someone that has no sentimental value of putting one on sandwiches as a kid and has tasted them back to back.
ready4ward
721 Posts
298 Reputation
$3.98 for the 30 oz at Walmart, $3.38 for Great Value 30 oz for comparison. Not bad for delivered but not screaming hot either.
2Slick2Quit
6570 Posts
723 Reputation
Real Mayonnaise? Real soybean oil.

46 Comments

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Jan 23, 2025
903 Posts
Joined Jul 2010
Jan 23, 2025
xlerate
Jan 23, 2025
903 Posts
Quote from Selman :
That seems like a clever comment until you realize all mayonaise recipes contain oil, at which point it starts to seem kind of the opposite.
Not all, the better ones use Avocado or EVOO.
1
Jan 23, 2025
4,216 Posts
Joined Jul 2010
Jan 23, 2025
Selman
Jan 23, 2025
4,216 Posts
Quote from xlerate :
Not all, the better ones use Avocado or EVOO.
I think you read that a little wrong.

ALL mayonnaise uses oil in the recipe. This is the fact. Choosing a different oil is great to try. It doesn't cease to be mayonnaise.

I like the ones with olive oil in them to change things up, but mayonnaise generally tastes better in my opinion, and the opinion of most of the world, when made with a more neutral oil. That lets the egg yolks shine. It's also nice to change the acid up. Vinegar, lemon, and lime are all good. It's easy to make yourself.
Last edited by Selman January 23, 2025 at 10:29 AM.
1
Jan 23, 2025
903 Posts
Joined Jul 2010
Jan 23, 2025
xlerate
Jan 23, 2025
903 Posts
Quote from Selman :
I think you read that a little wrong.
I read it correct. The response I replied to was your response to a post that specifically stated SOYBEAN OIL.

HERE:
Quote from 2Slick2Quit :
Real Mayonnaise? Real soybean oil.

Quote from Selman :
mayonnaise generally tastes better in my opinion, and the opinion of most of the world, when made with a more neutral oil.
A subjective response that groups your taste preference with that of 'most of the world' without providing any supporting source.
1
Jan 23, 2025
8,800 Posts
Joined Feb 2007
Jan 23, 2025
trza
Jan 23, 2025
8,800 Posts
Quote from JMBauer74 :
This or Dukes?
Dukes > Hellmans > Blue Plate > Kraft > Vomit > Cat Pee > Miracle Whip
2
Jan 23, 2025
313 Posts
Joined Jun 2017
Jan 23, 2025
JstSyn
Jan 23, 2025
313 Posts
For real mayonnaise, buy chosen foods avocado oil mayonnaise. Not this soybean poison
1
1
Jan 23, 2025
563 Posts
Joined Oct 2019
Jan 23, 2025
OliveFog741
Jan 23, 2025
563 Posts
Quote from ibuythingshere :
nope. once you craft the Mayo Machine, you just put egg in it and out comes Mayo. sells for 190g
How did you know my nickname?
- M. M.
Jan 23, 2025
1,199 Posts
Joined Jun 2011
Jan 23, 2025
LJCRST
Jan 23, 2025
1,199 Posts
Quote from Selman :
JFG, Blue Plate, and Great Value are all extremely similar mayos. They are creamy with low acidity. Hellmann's is similar, but with a little more acidity. Kewpie is more rich than all of those. Duke's is more acidic than all of those. They are all good depending on what you are trying to achieve, but Great Value is a very comparable mayo to Blue Plate. This is from someone that has no sentimental value of putting one on sandwiches as a kid and has tasted them back to back.
I'm still stuck in the "mayo is mayo" level.

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Pro
Jan 24, 2025
13,102 Posts
Joined Apr 2005
Jan 24, 2025
TidalWaveOne
Pro
Jan 24, 2025
13,102 Posts
Quote from Follywood :
Hellmans the best
I did a fact check on that statement and it came up true.
Jan 24, 2025
464 Posts
Joined Mar 2009
Jan 24, 2025
locomo
Jan 24, 2025
464 Posts
Quote from Selman :
That second paragraph directly applies.
Scientific Method, like "safe and effective" ?
1
Jan 24, 2025
4,216 Posts
Joined Jul 2010
Jan 24, 2025
Selman
Jan 24, 2025
4,216 Posts
Quote from xlerate :
I read it correct. The response I replied to was your response to a post that specifically stated SOYBEAN OIL.

HERE:





A subjective response that groups your taste preference with that of 'most of the world' without providing any supporting source.
No, you don't get it at all. The post I replied to was questioning if it is real mayonnaise. Most mayo in the world is not made with olive oil. It's still mayonnaise.

Most of what people choose is made with more neutral oil, but that's beside the point that you read wrong. Go look. Also see what mayo in other countries is predominantly made of. You want a peer reviewed source for that? So asinine.
2
Jan 24, 2025
903 Posts
Joined Jul 2010
Jan 24, 2025
xlerate
Jan 24, 2025
903 Posts
Quote from Selman :
No, you don't get it at all. The post I replied to was questioning if it is real mayonnaise. Most mayo in the world is not made with olive oil. It's still mayonnaise.

Most of what people choose is made with more neutral oil, but that's beside the point that you read wrong. Go look. Also see what mayo in other countries is predominantly made of. You want a peer reviewed source for that? So asinine.
I wonder if there's a corelation between what most what people choose is what mostly available? 🤔

Same could be said that most people (USA) choose High Fructose Corn Syrup over Cane Sugar.

And the comment you replied to distinctly said 'Real Mayonnaise, Real Soybean Oil'.

That comment clearly is highlighting Soybean Oil as the subject of contention. 'Real Mayonnaise' is a marketing term.
1
Jan 24, 2025
4,216 Posts
Joined Jul 2010
Jan 24, 2025
Selman
Jan 24, 2025
4,216 Posts
Quote from xlerate :
I wonder if there's a corelation between what most what people choose is what mostly available? 🤔

Same could be said that most people (USA) choose High Fructose Corn Syrup over Cane Sugar.

And the comment you replied to distinctly said 'Real Mayonnaise, Real Soybean Oil'.

That comment clearly is highlighting Soybean Oil as the subject of contention. 'Real Mayonnaise' is a marketing term.
Let me change it to, "When given the choice, most people choose mayonnaise made with more neutral oils". They've got Great Value Olive Oil mayo for about the same cost, and Walmart stocks and sells way less of it. But, that's all unrelated to your error.

Again, buy whatever mayo you like. It is nonsense to suggest mayo isn't real unless made with olive oil, and that's what you wrongly replied to. You are also wrong about "real mayonnaise" being a marketing term. Those words are regulated by several countries, including the USA. Oil quantities and ingredients are legislated for that term. You also misquoted the original post by failing again to see the question mark. You've kind of proven that you read it incorrectly multiple times even after someone told you to check again. That's pretty hard headed.
Last edited by Selman January 24, 2025 at 09:48 AM.
2
Jan 24, 2025
1,535 Posts
Joined Nov 2011
Jan 24, 2025
Turbotalon
Jan 24, 2025
1,535 Posts
So this just got delivered today and I got "JFG Salad Dressing" but the top stick from Amazon on the jar says Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise. The nutrition label doesn't match. Wtf Amazon.

Update - A separate shipment had my other one which indeed was Blue Plate....
Last edited by Turbotalon January 24, 2025 at 03:37 PM.
Jan 27, 2025
903 Posts
Joined Jul 2010
Jan 27, 2025
xlerate
Jan 27, 2025
903 Posts
Quote from Selman :
Let me change it to, "When given the choice, most people choose mayonnaise made with more neutral oils".
I see you have changed your tune, again, and still have not provided anything that supports your claim of what most people prefer.


Quote from Selman :
They've got Great Value Olive Oil mayo for about the same cost, and Walmart stocks and sells way less of it.
Two things: (and we have discussed this already, but you seem to not be able to retain the idea that having less of a product is directly related to selling less. (Cant sell what you don't have). But please share any resource you have to show Walmart "sells way less".


Quote from Selman :
But, that's all unrelated to your error.
Which error is that?


Quote from Selman :
You are also wrong about "real mayonnaise" being a marketing term. Those words are regulated by several countries, including the USA. Oil quantities and ingredients are legislated for that term.
The label mayonnaise is protected in use on food, the "real" before it is marketing because mayonnaise already must contain certain ingredients. "Mayo" is not mayonnaise so there is no need to put "real" before it.


Quote from Selman :
You also misquoted the original post by failing again to see the question mark. You've kind of proven that you read it incorrectly multiple times even after someone told you to check again. That's pretty hard headed.
Do you own any type of mirror? Wink

You are avoiding the context of the quoted comment you responded to. "Soybean Oil". That comment intended to highlight the poor quality of oil choice in the product. You showed up with zero evidence claiming people prefer neutral oils having a full on discussion about a subject no one but you brought up.

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Jan 27, 2025
4,216 Posts
Joined Jul 2010
Jan 27, 2025
Selman
Jan 27, 2025
4,216 Posts
Quote from xlerate :
I see you have changed your tune, again, and still have not provided anything that supports your claim of what most people prefer.




Two things: (and we have discussed this already, but you seem to not be able to retain the idea that having less of a product is directly related to selling less. (Cant sell what you don't have). But please share any resource you have to show Walmart "sells way less".




Which error is that?




The label mayonnaise is protected in use on food, the "real" before it is marketing because mayonnaise already must contain certain ingredients. "Mayo" is not mayonnaise so there is no need to put "real" before it.




Do you own any type of mirror? Wink

You are avoiding the context of the quoted comment you responded to. "Soybean Oil". That comment intended to highlight the poor quality of oil choice in the product. You showed up with zero evidence claiming people prefer neutral oils having a full on discussion about a subject no one but you brought up.
Lol. It's a days-old, expired mayo post. Stay mad. I love that you still can't figure out your mistake and upvoted yourself for it.
Last edited by Selman January 27, 2025 at 10:03 AM.

Leave a Comment

Unregistered (You)

Popular Deals

View All

Trending Deals

View All