Slickdeals is community-supported.  We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
frontpageitsamazeling | Staff posted May 04, 2026 07:01 PM
  1. Deal Image
Item 1 of 4
  1. Deal Image
  2. Deal Image
  3. Deal Image
  4. Deal Image
Item 1 of 4
frontpageitsamazeling | Staff posted May 04, 2026 07:01 PM

Johnston & Murphy Hodges Cap Toe Leather Oxford Dress Shoe (Tan)

+ Free S&H

$40

$160

75% off
Men's Wearhouse
71 Comments 71,048 Views
Get Deal at Men's Wearhouse
Good Deal
Save
Share
Deal Details
Men's Wearhouse has Johnston & Murphy Hodges Cap Toe Leather Oxford Dress Shoe (Tan) on sale for $39.99. Shipping is free for Perfect Fit Rewards Members (free to join).
  • Note: Sizing and availability may vary.
Thanks to Deal Hunter itsamazeling for sharing this deal.

About this shoe:
  • Classic cap toe Oxford dress shoes
  • Full-grain leather upper for durability
  • Lace-up design for secure fit
  • Memory foam insole for all-day comfort
  • Flexible rubber outsole with TRUFOAM support
  • Suitable for professional and formal wear

Editor's Notes

Written by jimmytx | Staff
  • About this Store:
    • Free returns at any Men's Wearhouse store or by mail within 90 days from the shipped date at no cost. See their Return Policy for more details.
  • Additional Information:
    • Our research indicates that this deal is $89.91 less (69% savings) than the next best available price from a reputable merchant with prices starting from $129.90 at the time of this posting.
    • Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars at Men's Wearhouse based on over 20 customer reviews.
    • Please see the original post for additional details and/or view the Wiki and forum comments for further helpful discussion if available.

Original Post

Written by itsamazeling | Staff
Community Notes
About the Poster
Deal Details
Community Notes
About the Poster
Men's Wearhouse has Johnston & Murphy Hodges Cap Toe Leather Oxford Dress Shoe (Tan) on sale for $39.99. Shipping is free for Perfect Fit Rewards Members (free to join).
  • Note: Sizing and availability may vary.
Thanks to Deal Hunter itsamazeling for sharing this deal.

About this shoe:
  • Classic cap toe Oxford dress shoes
  • Full-grain leather upper for durability
  • Lace-up design for secure fit
  • Memory foam insole for all-day comfort
  • Flexible rubber outsole with TRUFOAM support
  • Suitable for professional and formal wear

Editor's Notes

Written by jimmytx | Staff
  • About this Store:
    • Free returns at any Men's Wearhouse store or by mail within 90 days from the shipped date at no cost. See their Return Policy for more details.
  • Additional Information:
    • Our research indicates that this deal is $89.91 less (69% savings) than the next best available price from a reputable merchant with prices starting from $129.90 at the time of this posting.
    • Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars at Men's Wearhouse based on over 20 customer reviews.
    • Please see the original post for additional details and/or view the Wiki and forum comments for further helpful discussion if available.

Original Post

Written by itsamazeling | Staff

Community Voting

Deal Score
+181
Good Deal
Get Deal at Men's Wearhouse

Leave a Comment

Unregistered (You)

Top Comments

dab2mi
2678 Posts
666 Reputation
Got a similar pair last time (not capped) and they are a bit thin, but comfortable. For $40 I'd say they are worth it.

I added code COLE15 and got another $6 off. So $34 if anyone wants to try it
BeautifulSeagull451
257 Posts
40 Reputation
Yes, they were high quality, but years ago.
ayaniga
2318 Posts
1280 Reputation
I get that products aren't necessarily as good as they once were, but it lists these shoes as full grain leather...what's so bad about that?

I say that, as I wear my J&M shoes every day to work that I bought at the thrift store for $8 a pair.

71 Comments

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

May 05, 2026 01:03 AM
49 Posts
Joined Jan 2015
SixPackDaddyMay 05, 2026 01:03 AM
49 Posts
I have worn Johnson and Murphy shoes for 30 years. They are not quite as good as they use to be granted. However, this is a very good deal if you can get free shipping....
1
May 05, 2026 01:20 AM
156 Posts
Joined Dec 2016
NYCSteelerMay 05, 2026 01:20 AM
156 Posts

Our community has rated this post as helpful. If you agree, why not thank NYCSteeler

It's extremely sad to see how far J&M has fallen. I used to buy their dress shoes along with Allen Edmonds years ago as they were fully made in the US and were well-made shoes. Once J&M stopped making their shoes in the US, I stopped buying them. Their shoes are now cheap garbage - the J&M brand means nothing anymore.
3
2
May 05, 2026 01:32 AM
2,166 Posts
Joined Mar 2009
SlimeBoyMay 05, 2026 01:32 AM
2,166 Posts
Thanks, made my purchase. At this price I can cut my grass with them.
1
May 05, 2026 01:36 AM
359 Posts
Joined Nov 2017
stillen_i30May 05, 2026 01:36 AM
359 Posts
Quote from NYCSteeler :
It's extremely sad to see how far J&M has fallen. I used to buy their dress shoes along with Allen Edmonds years ago as they were fully made in the US and were well-made shoes. Once J&M stopped making their shoes in the US, I stopped buying them. Their shoes are now cheap garbage - the J&M brand means nothing anymore.
Very common for so many brands these days, not just clothing. All the brands have learned to sell to private equity giants whose primary interest is bottom line maximum profits and cheapest materials and labor. The brand name is just a name that is handed down as more of a disguise these days, not what branding used to be (that would suggest a particular level of quality and what you would expect to pay). These brands now keep their prices the same but use "shyte" materials and labor and the extra money just goes into their pockets.
Last edited by stillen_i30 May 4, 2026 at 06:39 PM.
1
May 05, 2026 01:38 AM
439 Posts
Joined May 2013
JNLMay 05, 2026 01:38 AM
439 Posts
Quote from WatchMyScotch :
Johnston and Murphy are high quality shoes. Thus us a very good deal for this quality. Thanks, OP.
Are you referring to the J&M from 30+ yrs ago? Those I agree are quality shoes.

Sad to say even Allen Edmonds' are a far cry now vs 12+ yrs ago. Switched to Septieme Largeur.
Last edited by JNL May 4, 2026 at 06:53 PM.
May 05, 2026 01:43 AM
131 Posts
Joined Oct 2022
nunhgraderMay 05, 2026 01:43 AM
131 Posts
Thanks!
Pro
May 05, 2026 01:47 AM
3,022 Posts
Joined Aug 2005
leecm
Pro
May 05, 2026 01:47 AM
3,022 Posts
The funny thing is JM or ME (not sure who is responsible) lists these Oxfords and they're obviously derbies. That's like dress shoes 101.

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

May 05, 2026 01:51 AM
689 Posts
Joined Dec 2009
slyevoMay 05, 2026 01:51 AM
689 Posts
Quote from dab2mi :
Got a similar pair last time (not capped) and they are a bit thin, but comfortable. For $40 I'd say they are worth it.I added code COLE15 and got another $6 off. So $34 if anyone wants to try it
Thanks for the code! Also 15% at cb site.
May 05, 2026 01:58 AM
794 Posts
Joined Aug 2007
C1787GJMay 05, 2026 01:58 AM
794 Posts
Quote from NYCSteeler :
It's extremely sad to see how far J&M has fallen. I used to buy their dress shoes along with Allen Edmonds years ago as they were fully made in the US and were well-made shoes. Once J&M stopped making their shoes in the US, I stopped buying them. Their shoes are now cheap garbage - the J&M brand means nothing anymore.
Anyone have any suggestions for shoes still made in the USA?
3
May 05, 2026 02:03 AM
55 Posts
Joined Mar 2017
I_AM_KAKAROTMay 05, 2026 02:03 AM
55 Posts
Quote from slyevo :
Thanks for the code! Also 15% at cb site.
Thanks for the code
May 05, 2026 02:05 AM
247 Posts
Joined Sep 2011
bigd212May 05, 2026 02:05 AM
247 Posts
Cole15 promo code gives extra 15% off. Got one for $33.
May 05, 2026 02:23 AM
6,462 Posts
Joined May 2004
lobo411May 05, 2026 02:23 AM
6,462 Posts
$40 for a pair of decent dress shoes and people be whinin' that they aren't made by little old men with mouths full of tacks and hunched over cobbler's benches.
4
3
May 05, 2026 02:36 AM
919 Posts
Joined Dec 2020
CaffeinemanMay 05, 2026 02:36 AM
919 Posts
Quote from NYCSteeler :
It's extremely sad to see how far J&M has fallen. I used to buy their dress shoes along with Allen Edmonds years ago as they were fully made in the US and were well-made shoes. Once J&M stopped making their shoes in the US, I stopped buying them. Their shoes are now cheap garbage - the J&M brand means nothing anymore.
I can't wear Allen Edmonds anymore even the wideist are too narrow. Any recommendations for 2xw or 6 to 7 e high quality? I want to cry once.
1
May 05, 2026 02:44 AM
359 Posts
Joined Nov 2017
stillen_i30May 05, 2026 02:44 AM
359 Posts
Quote from C1787GJ :
Anyone have any suggestions for shoes still made in the USA?
Nordstrom has Allen I believe made in usa. There are also several brands that are made in Italy. Be prepared to pay way more than $40 though
2

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

May 05, 2026 02:57 AM
43 Posts
Joined Mar 2018
BlueKnob5870May 05, 2026 02:57 AM
43 Posts
Quote from dab2mi :
Got a similar pair last time (not capped) and they are a bit thin, but comfortable. For $40 I'd say they are worth it.I added code COLE15 and got another $6 off. So $34 if anyone wants to try it
Seconded, got a similar last time and was worth it at this price point

Leave a Comment

Unregistered (You)

Related Searches

Clothing & AccessoriesMen's Clothing & AccessoriesMen's AccessoriesShoesMen's ShoesFree ShippingOccasions

Popular Deals

See All
Found by lazysaver
Today 03:12 AM
Forum Thread
TP-Link AX1800 X25 3 pack Mesh Router cheaper in store clearance $72$72
0
Found by pennysave
Yesterday 01:31 PM
Forum Thread
$279: DEWALT FLEXVOLT 60V MAX Lithium-Ion Cordless Brushless 4.5 in. to 6 in. Small Angle Grinder with 6Ah Battery and Charger at HomeDepot$279$548
49% off
1
Found by buylow
Yesterday 08:53 PM
Forum Thread
Wüsthof Classic 6-Inch Chef's Knife Sam's Club $69.98$70
0
Found by Rokket
Today 01:41 AM
Forum Thread
BalanceFrom 10-Lb Olympic Bumper Plate Weight Plate (Pair) $14.02 + Free Shipping w/ Walmart+ or on $35+$14$35
60% off
1
Found by LolaBunny21
Yesterday 10:53 PM
Forum Thread
Prime Members: NIIMBOT D110 Upgraded Mini Label Maker w/ Tape $9.99 + Free Shipping$9.99$30
66% off
4

Trending Deals

See All
Found by iconian
Yesterday 10:19 PM
Forum Thread
34” Deco Gear 3440x1440 180Hz Curved Ultrawide Monitor $190 + Free S/H $189.99$190$300
36% off
1
Found by pennysave
Yesterday 03:48 PM
Forum Thread
$1849 | Apple 2026 MacBook Pro Laptop with Apple M5 chip: 14.2-inch, 32GB Memory, 1TB SSD, Space Black/Silver at Amazon$1,849$2,099
11% off
9
Found by babgaly
Today 04:08 AM
Forum Thread
Sunveza 118W 1-Port USB-C Charger (MacBook Pro Compatible) w/ 6.6' USB-C to USB-C Cable $8.08 + Free Shipping w/ Prime or on $35+$8.08$27
70% off
0
Found by LolaBunny21
Yesterday 11:56 PM
Forum Thread
160-Piece Beetles Flat-X Almond Medium Pre-Etched Press-On Nail Tips (16 Sizes) $2.84 w/ S&S + Free Shipping w/ Prime or on $35+$2.84$6.99
59% off
0
Found by ItsSoCheap
Today 03:40 AM
Forum Thread
Open Box: RK Royal Kludge N80 Low-Profile 75% Wireless Mechanical Keyboard w/ Knob & Display (Red Switches) $48.49 + Free Shipping w/ Prime$48
1