Select Costco Wholesale Stores (link for reference only) have for its
Members: Kirkland Signature USDA Prime Beef Bone-In Ribeye Steak on sale for
$16.99 per pound. Valid for
in-warehouse purchase only. You may check the warehouse section of the
Costco App and search for local inventory using item number
12233.
Thanks to community member
c2nah777 for sharing this deal.
Note: Availability may vary by location.
Top Comments
Here is a guy that cooked both and said there was really no difference other than presentation
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZm4axg
If i were to buy these i would probably cut off the frenched part of the Ribeye to make it easier to manage.
Community Reviews
Costco's USDA Prime tomahawk-style bone-in ribeye is being treated as a big, showy steak that grills well and can deliver rich flavor, tenderness, and strong presentation. The thick cuts are good for sharing, reverse searing, or smoker workflows, and the bone can help with handling and keep the meat from overcooking near the edge. The main knock is value, since the bone adds weight and the effective meat price can feel closer to a much higher boneless ribeye. It is a better fit for special occasions than for everyday steak buying.
Common Questions (5)
AI-generated summary based on comments from the community. Updated ago
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
209 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
I'll go one step further and that not only is this the worst possible value in steaks, from one of the worst possible retailers for steaks, but in order for it to achieve the desired "look" of a tomahawk/cowboy ribeye, you need it from the least good portion of the rib primal.
Colloquially, you want beef that's "furthest from the horn and the hoof" for it to be the most tender. That generally means you want it from the "short" side of the rib primal. Which wouldn't look too "fancy* when you french the bone for presentation.
Maybe I'm just pissing into the wind here, though...
I'll go one step further and that not only is this the worst possible value in steaks, from one of the worst possible retailers for steaks, but in order for it to achieve the desired "look" of a tomahawk/cowboy ribeye, you need it from the least good portion of the rib primal.
Colloquially, you want beef that's "furthest from the horn and the hoof" for it to be the most tender. That generally means you want it from the "short" side of the rib primal. Which wouldn't look too "fancy* when you french the bone for presentation.
Maybe I'm just pissing into the wind here, though...
I'll go one step further and that not only is this the worst possible value in steaks, from one of the worst possible retailers for steaks, but in order for it to achieve the desired "look" of a tomahawk/cowboy ribeye, you need it from the least good portion of the rib primal.
Colloquially, you want beef that's "furthest from the horn and the hoof" for it to be the most tender. That generally means you want it from the "short" side of the rib primal. Which wouldn't look too "fancy* when you french the bone for presentation.
Maybe I'm just pissing into the wind here, though...
I got an up close look today at the Choice Tomahawks at Sam's. Way better marbling at Costco for the Prime, and less of a fat cap, just as one would expect!
And Costco looked not just "very low" Prime as you say. There are always individual differences within classification ranges. Maybe your point is why I tend to like Sam's beef overall better than Costco's.
Ribeye's just don't excite me when only Choice at the supermarkets. Huge fat caps, and poor marbling.
I think I'd go more for the whole Prime Ribeye (just mentioned) for $14.99, instead of the Prime Tomahawk Ribeyes. I agree that is a much better value. I'd need to vacuum seal most, if I cut it all into steaks. Or have a party with all of it, or make a Prime Rib. At least I could custom-cut for thickness.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but when you get a whole Ribeye there will be more fat trimming needed than with the already-cut steaks. But either way, $14.99 for Prime Ribeye sounds very good in today's market.
I can tell you know much more than I do about beef cuts, and I bow to your wisdom as far as that goes. I just am not going to make a generalization that all Costco beef sucks and their Prime is bottom of the barrel for Prime. You sound like you have much more research into it, but all I can speak to is my anecdotal experiences.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
I got an up close look today at the Choice Tomahawks at Sam's. Way better marbling at Costco for the Prime, and less of a fat cap, just as one would expect!
And Costco looked not just "very low" Prime as you say. There are always individual differences within classification ranges. Maybe your point is why I tend to like Sam's beef overall better than Costco's.
Ribeye's just don't excite me when only Choice at the supermarkets. Huge fat caps, and poor marbling.
I think I'd go more for the whole Prime Ribeye (just mentioned) for $14.99, instead of the Prime Tomahawk Ribeyes. I agree that is a much better value. I'd need to vacuum seal most, if I cut it all into steaks. Or have a party with all of it, or make a Prime Rib. At least I could custom-cut for thickness.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but when you get a whole Ribeye there will be more fat trimming needed than with the already-cut steaks. But either way, $14.99 for Prime Ribeye sounds very good in today's market.
I can tell you know much more than I do about beef cuts, and I bow to your wisdom as far as that goes. I just am not going to make a generalization that all Costco beef sucks and their Prime is bottom of the barrel for Prime. You sound like you have much more research into it, but all I can speak to is my anecdotal experiences.
I used to work at Costco, did a tour in the meat department as well. I also regularly visit 7 or 8 different Costco warehouses, and about 3 Sam's. There are USDA grades, and also sub-grades within the strata, that can be applied to beef, but the casual shopper seems to only know (or care) about "prime", "choice" and "select". And also seem more than willing to buy into a narrative that is demonstrably not true. I'll say this without any fear of exaggeration or hyperbole: no one is selling high prime beef to Costco. No one. Hell, I'd have been happy with mid-prime the 3 times I drank the kool-aid. But each time I "splurged" and bought Costco "prime"... Mouthfuls of regret. Because when you've had real, true, according-to-Hoyle prime beef, you'll never mistake what Costco is selling for the same thing.
I made a conscious decision early on in life to be as informed as I possibly could about certain things. Dollar for dollar, I'll take Sam's choice untenderized beef over Costco tenderized prime any day of the week and twice on Sundays. Because the label means exactly bupkis when it doesn't cook, feel, or taste like the label says it should.
I used to work at Costco, did a tour in the meat department as well. I also regularly visit 7 or 8 different Costco warehouses, and about 3 Sam's. There are USDA grades, and also sub-grades within the strata, that can be applied to beef, but the casual shopper seems to only know (or care) about "prime", "choice" and "select". And also seem more than willing to buy into a narrative that is demonstrably not true. I'll say this without any fear of exaggeration or hyperbole: no one is selling high prime beef to Costco. No one. Hell, I'd have been happy with mid-prime the 3 times I drank the kool-aid. But each time I "splurged" and bought Costco "prime"... Mouthfuls of regret. Because when you've had real, true, according to Hoyle prime beef, you'll never mistake what Costco is selling for the same thing.
I made a conscious decision early on in life to be as informed as I possibly could about certain things. Dollar for dollar, I'll take Sam's choice untenderized beef over Costco tenderized prime any day of the week and twice on Sundays. Because the label means exactly bupkis when it doesn't cook, feel, or taste like the label says it should.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
My local Costco carries ribeye primal for 15.99 last time I visited. Cheaper than choice cut ribeye steaks per lbs. Though I had to trim off a lot of fat.
Join The Conversation
Share your experience with the Slickdeals community
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!