Various Utility Companies are offering current Account Holders in Select States: Google Nest Thermostat or Nest Learning Thermostat on sale for prices listed below. Shipping may vary by location and provider.
Thanks to Staff Member DLS4U for sharing this deal.
Offer Notes:
Rebate amounts and requirements vary depending on the utility provider; requirements may include enrollment in rewards/savings programs. Other limitations & eligibility requirements may apply, e.g., connection to central AC.
Example Participating Locations/Services (prices below after all rebates & discounts, which may require enrollment in a savings/rewards program):
Various Utility Companies in 32 states areoffering eligible customers Google Nest thermostats for as little as $0 outside ofshipping and taxes (no rebate or coupon required). Get up to $129 off of aGoogle Nest Thermostat valued at $129.99 or up to $170 off of a Nest Learning Thermostatvalued at $249 through August 21st.
I came here expecting some of these replies and wanted to give a reasonable answer.
First - no, the utilities are generally not "controlling" your thermostat. The situation these commenters are referring to is called demand response (DR). Where the utilities will pay their consumers to shift or reduce their demand during times of grid strain to reduce the likelihood of brown or blackouts. For this to happen you need to enroll in the DR program itself, you'll know if you're doing this. Utilities can't just enroll you without your notice.
Second - even if you are in one of these DR programs, you absolutely always have final control over your thermostat and temperature setting. You ALWAYS have the option to opt-out of DR events and keep your thermostat or AC humming along at whatever temperature you want. Yes, if you're enrolled in one of these DR programs and you opt-out, your electric bill may be higher. But that's the whole point. If the utility is offering free stuff (like a thermostat) and ongoing revenue to participate in a DR program, but you opt-out of actually participating? It hurts the utility (and the rest of the grid for that matter), who was expecting you to provide relief so there is some financial incentives there.
I'm just tried of people sensationalizing this stuff. Geeze.
My experience here is as someone who helps implement some of these types of programs for a few utilities around the country. I predominately work with commercial and industrial customers but interact with the residential side of things as well.
F*** Tennessee
You're energy usage is the product. Utilities offer rebates for these types of products (just like LED lights or insulation) because they can save energy. Most utilities in the United States are decoupled from their revenue. Meaning that the utility receives the same revenue regardless of the energy they delivery. So it's in their best interest to help you save energy. You as their utility consumer using less energy = the utility having to delivery less energy or build more energy infrastructure. That's the entire point here.
It's not about data mining for the utility. They don't get that visibility with any demand response programs. Does google for their nest product? Sure, but that's different than what other folks have being talking about here as google isn't offering the rebate. It's about the utility having an incentive to encourage you to use less energy, that's why they offer rebates and discounts on these things.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
I don't see it listed, but it seems the ecobee is $49 in CA, I was thinking of that over a Nest. Can anyone with more experience with these comment on the two?
TIA, repp for assistance!
I had a hell of a time keeping the nests online without a C wire. There is an adapter Google will sell you. It worked for one of my nests. And the other one, they just ran a C wire from the relays in the attic. They work fine now
Did you have the fancier version I wonder? (more power draw maybe??) I installed the newer (regular) nest last summer. I had a C wire behind the old thermostat unused so I hooked it up. Worked fine for a couple months and then after a long power outage I was getting all sorts of battery low messages, etc. Turned out the C wire wasn't hooked up at the furnace. I've been running powered now ever since.
In short I (and I know others) have had success with no C wire on the regular nest thermostat. BUT personally would never have purchased without access to a C wire and running fully powered.
What you said was "utility companies will control your thermostat even during non-peak periods." - in my reading at least that meant all utility companies as you did not add a qualifier. You also didn't mention that it will be clear when you want to purchase a device if your utility is one of those "some." So this isn't something that will happen without a persons knowledge or consent and that you as the consumer, ALWAYS have final control. And that the demand response offered by the utilities is part of the trade off, they give you discounted stuff and ongoing revenue from participation, and you shift your load (e.g., increase your thermostat cooling setting) in return. Seems pretty fair to me. You're two sentence quip omits all of that nuance and real-world details in place of something catchy that makes the utilities look bad for offering this discount.
I could have said "misleading" instead of "sensationalizing." I wanted to add some real context to the situation as nothing is ever so black and white and writing a comment implying that it is (by omitting the nuance) is misleading to anyone who isn't already familiar with the details.
I've seen the option on my Nest asking if I want to join. I selected no. And I still have the thermostat frequently set to a temperature I've never set it to (so it's not learning that temperature from my past settings)—even in non-peak periods—and Nest also has told me that the temp I'm trying to set will happen in x number of minutes in the future (amount of time has varied) and the system will not turn on until that time has elapsed.
So you saying "this isn't something that will happen without a persons knowledge or consent and that you as the consumer, ALWAYS have final control" is what they want you to believe, but in my personal experience, that is not true. I used to believe what you believed and made the same arguments until I saw what was happening to me.
I've seen the option on my Nest asking if I want to join. I selected no. And I still have the thermostat frequently set to a temperature I've never set it to (so it's not learning that temperature from my past settings)—even in non-peak periods—and Nest also has told me that the temp I'm trying to set will happen in x number of minutes in the future (amount of time has varied) and the system will not turn on until that time has elapsed.
So you saying "this isn't something that will happen without a persons knowledge or consent and that you as the consumer, ALWAYS have final control" is what they want you to believe, but in my personal experience, that is not true. I used to believe what you believed and made the same arguments until I saw what was happening to me.
Ooooooo conspiracies! Who is the "they" (of "they want you to believe") that you're referring to?
Does this nest require C wire to install now?
In the past, the nest broke my furnace because I don't have C wire.
Unless you want to keep putting batteries into it, yes. I need to run a C wire to mine. I've heard in some cases Google pays for the service call to do it. Haven't gotten around to it yet.
I've seen the option on my Nest asking if I want to join. I selected no. And I still have the thermostat frequently set to a temperature I've never set it to (so it's not learning that temperature from my past settings)—even in non-peak periods—and Nest also has told me that the temp I'm trying to set will happen in x number of minutes in the future (amount of time has varied) and the system will not turn on until that time has elapsed.
So you saying "this isn't something that will happen without a persons knowledge or consent and that you as the consumer, ALWAYS have final control" is what they want you to believe, but in my personal experience, that is not true. I used to believe what you believed and made the same arguments until I saw what was happening to me.
He is right, you have absolute control.
The nest thermostat is trying to learn your habits. A product is not inferior simply because the consumer is the ignorant component. Learn how the damn thing works
that thermostat sucks, the home app is shockingly crappy too. get the ecobee if you want one of these data miners, reliable, good app, easy to program and setup.
With all due respect, Google Nest Learning Thermostat was a huge favorite by Consumer reports scoring 83/100. ecobee Smart with Voice Control EB-STATe5-01 was the closest in 5th place with a score of 73
144 Comments
Your comment cannot be blank.
Featured Comments
First - no, the utilities are generally not "controlling" your thermostat. The situation these commenters are referring to is called demand response (DR). Where the utilities will pay their consumers to shift or reduce their demand during times of grid strain to reduce the likelihood of brown or blackouts. For this to happen you need to enroll in the DR program itself, you'll know if you're doing this. Utilities can't just enroll you without your notice.
Second - even if you are in one of these DR programs, you absolutely always have final control over your thermostat and temperature setting. You ALWAYS have the option to opt-out of DR events and keep your thermostat or AC humming along at whatever temperature you want. Yes, if you're enrolled in one of these DR programs and you opt-out, your electric bill may be higher. But that's the whole point. If the utility is offering free stuff (like a thermostat) and ongoing revenue to participate in a DR program, but you opt-out of actually participating? It hurts the utility (and the rest of the grid for that matter), who was expecting you to provide relief so there is some financial incentives there.
I'm just tried of people sensationalizing this stuff. Geeze.
My experience here is as someone who helps implement some of these types of programs for a few utilities around the country. I predominately work with commercial and industrial customers but interact with the residential side of things as well.
It's not about data mining for the utility. They don't get that visibility with any demand response programs. Does google for their nest product? Sure, but that's different than what other folks have being talking about here as google isn't offering the rebate. It's about the utility having an incentive to encourage you to use less energy, that's why they offer rebates and discounts on these things.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
TIA, repp for assistance!
In short I (and I know others) have had success with no C wire on the regular nest thermostat. BUT personally would never have purchased without access to a C wire and running fully powered.
I could have said "misleading" instead of "sensationalizing." I wanted to add some real context to the situation as nothing is ever so black and white and writing a comment implying that it is (by omitting the nuance) is misleading to anyone who isn't already familiar with the details.
So you saying "this isn't something that will happen without a persons knowledge or consent and that you as the consumer, ALWAYS have final control" is what they want you to believe, but in my personal experience, that is not true. I used to believe what you believed and made the same arguments until I saw what was happening to me.
Anyone has ecobee lite free with their provider ?
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
So you saying "this isn't something that will happen without a persons knowledge or consent and that you as the consumer, ALWAYS have final control" is what they want you to believe, but in my personal experience, that is not true. I used to believe what you believed and made the same arguments until I saw what was happening to me.
In the past, the nest broke my furnace because I don't have C wire.
Unless you want to keep putting batteries into it, yes. I need to run a C wire to mine. I've heard in some cases Google pays for the service call to do it. Haven't gotten around to it yet.
If you have privacy concerns or can't stand to have your house above 60 degrees during a heatwave, this may not be for you.
That's a flat out lie.
So you saying "this isn't something that will happen without a persons knowledge or consent and that you as the consumer, ALWAYS have final control" is what they want you to believe, but in my personal experience, that is not true. I used to believe what you believed and made the same arguments until I saw what was happening to me.
He is right, you have absolute control.
The nest thermostat is trying to learn your habits. A product is not inferior simply because the consumer is the ignorant component. Learn how the damn thing works
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
With all due respect, Google Nest Learning Thermostat was a huge favorite by Consumer reports scoring 83/100. ecobee Smart with Voice Control EB-STATe5-01 was the closest in 5th place with a score of 73