This collaborative space allows users to contribute additional information, tips, and insights to enhance the original deal post. Feel free to share your knowledge and help fellow shoppers make informed decisions.
This is a really nice deal. I think I'm going to end up going with the 840 for the touch screen, so hopefully one day soon they'll have the solar version for $100 off as well.
The price may seem attractive here, but a few things to keep in mind: According to the DCR review, the solar adds very little time, the screen is slightly dimmer than the non-solar, and having button-only is a bit clunky on the new menu.
Good price, site seems to be legit. I Question the benefit of "solar" gps. Seems to be an expensive gimmick, unless you really need to squeeze a few extra minutes out of your gps.
The battery life of the Garmin Edge 540 is already impressive. I agree that solar at this stage of the innovation for watches/cycling computers is not worth the upcharge or added hardware to drive it.
I opted for an Edge 1040 non-solar for that reason.
edit: The Edge 540 has somewhere around a 26-hour battery life non-solar, according to Garmin. Hence the thought that the solar addition does not really contribute as much as the upcharge requires (assuming not on sale).
But since this unit is on sale already, it is not a bad way to get a very reliable unit with 2023 technology and software.
Last edited by EastCoastMTBer April 23, 2023 at 10:43 AM.
A lot of people question the solar aspect of the units.
You either ride enough that getting 40 minutes out of 3 hours means something or you don't ride that much and you probably don't need this high end of a unit with or without solar.
The solar is superfluous, course guidance isn't. I have an Edge 830 and use it for races that exceed 75 miles in distance and at times train in excess of 90 miles with the display at full brightness, heart rate monitor, power meter, speed, cadence sensors, rear radar and my wireless shifters paired and haven't ever run out of battery.
The solar is superfluous, course guidance isn't. I have an Edge 830 and use it for races that exceed 75 miles in distance and at times train in excess of 90 miles with the display at full brightness, heart rate monitor, power meter, speed, cadence sensors, rear radar and my wireless shifters paired and haven't ever run out of battery.
I think you proved my point though.
I also think I wasn't articulate in how I made my point and it came off wrong.
Course guidance is the important part, and you can get a good bike computer that handles that very well for much cheaper than even $350 let alone retail of $450 on the new Garmin.
You ride enough that the solar is going to have a measurable difference in making sure you don't run out of battery. You probably do really well at recharging, cleaning and maintained on your bike but that doesn't mean everyone is always so diligent in charging. 90 mile training rides multiple days a week IS going to help the new Garmin stay charged.
Not sure if that helps clarify my point or not. But basically, if someone only needs basic bike computer stuff, this machines already more than they need regardless of the solar.
Leave a Comment
22 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
I opted for an Edge 1040 non-solar for that reason.
edit: The Edge 540 has somewhere around a 26-hour battery life non-solar, according to Garmin. Hence the thought that the solar addition does not really contribute as much as the upcharge requires (assuming not on sale).
But since this unit is on sale already, it is not a bad way to get a very reliable unit with 2023 technology and software.
You either ride enough that getting 40 minutes out of 3 hours means something or you don't ride that much and you probably don't need this high end of a unit with or without solar.
I also think I wasn't articulate in how I made my point and it came off wrong.
Course guidance is the important part, and you can get a good bike computer that handles that very well for much cheaper than even $350 let alone retail of $450 on the new Garmin.
You ride enough that the solar is going to have a measurable difference in making sure you don't run out of battery. You probably do really well at recharging, cleaning and maintained on your bike but that doesn't mean everyone is always so diligent in charging. 90 mile training rides multiple days a week IS going to help the new Garmin stay charged.
Not sure if that helps clarify my point or not. But basically, if someone only needs basic bike computer stuff, this machines already more than they need regardless of the solar.
Leave a Comment