This collaborative space allows users to contribute additional information, tips, and insights to enhance the original deal post. Feel free to share your knowledge and help fellow shoppers make informed decisions.
Model: Definitive Technology Demand D17 Floorstanding Speaker, Right and Left, Black
Deal History
Deal History includes data from multiple reputable stores, such as Best Buy, Target, and Walmart. The lowest price among stores for a given day is selected as the "Sale Price".
Sale Price does not include sale prices at Amazon unless a deal was posted by a community member.
If you're not part of the expired D15 thread, some of us have internal crossover damage. You might wanna pull off the binding post cover (4 Allen screws) and see if anything was broken loose in shipping. Something about Def Tech's packaging and UPS gorillas results in damaged crossovers. I ordered several of the older BP series Def tech speakers years ago and several had damaged crossovers from being dropped.
It looks like an inductor near the back is subject to snapping loose.
Decisions decisions. Maybe an AV expert can chime in.
Should I sell my Klipsch nines, add a bit more to my budget, and buy the D17 + D5C + D9 + AV receiver + sub (maybe I'll get the sub later) to get a full 5.1 setup?
My use case is probably 70% music and 30% movies.
Why on earth would you sell your Nines. Those are the top rated powered speakers in so many publications. Especially with 70% music.
It depends on how to look at it. D17 is about 1.6 times more expensive than D15 for each speaker($250 vs $400). This is my bedroom system and I'd rather stick with D15. I'm excited to try them out when they arrive later this week. I believe this would be sufficient to use it with my NAD C328.
For your use case I would do the D15 all day long. More slender and slightly smaller profile with arguable almost all the same performance. I think you made the right choice with staying with the D15. These will be I my office as a music listening stereo pair so going larger worked for me.
I don't get it why do these have two sets of speaker posts? Is that a sub on the side?
The can be Bi amped. Separate amp for the highs and mids. More power to each driver gives greater conrtol and arguably cleaner reproduction of music. Other reason as well but that's more nuanced.
I don't get it why do these have two sets of speaker posts? Is that a sub on the side?
They are passive radiators. They're basically woofers without motors that aren't connected to any signal. They vibrate in conjunction with the actual woofers to make more low end bass. They're an alternative to a port tube.
Decisions decisions. Maybe an AV expert can chime in.
Should I sell my Klipsch nines, add a bit more to my budget, and buy the D17 + D5C + D9 + AV receiver + sub (maybe I'll get the sub later) to get a full 5.1 setup?
I have not heard those klipsch but erin does a fantastic job in his reviews. They look good but a bit hot for my tastes. I dislike powered speakers because receivers offer alot of adjustability today. I personally don't like horn loaded tweeters.
On a side note, I would not waste money on the D9. Good fronts and a good center are what matters. Most of the effects channels are going to get limited love from your sound mixes. So save your money and get cheaper surrounds/effects speakers.
Decisions decisions. Maybe an AV expert can chime in.
Should I sell my Klipsch nines, add a bit more to my budget, and buy the D17 + D5C + D9 + AV receiver + sub (maybe I'll get the sub later) to get a full 5.1 setup?
My use case is probably 70% music and 30% movies.
I disagree with the other commenters if:
you really don't care about the extra space these speakers + subwoofer + receiver + speaker wires etc. etc. take vs just the Nines, e.g. you have at least a mid-size room
you can really get these plus a sub, plus a good receiver+amp for a similar price (resale of Nines)
The Nines are incredible for sure. Their bass extension is down to 33hz which is amazing. The input options (HDMI etc.) are very convenient. They are a nice tight bookshelf speaker form factor. But they simply can't beat having the huge displacement (speaker size) of these towers AND a subwoofer. e.g. RSL Speedwoofer 10s goes down to ~22Hz. Thats a must for movies and a big plus for SOME types of music. I had the Fives and the Nines, and adding a subwoofer just wiped the floor either way. Then of course for movies theres the surround effect if you add even more speakers (now or down the line)
OF COURSE this is just my preference. Maybe you hate bass, you do you. my 2 cents!
Last edited by racker15 December 18, 2023 at 05:24 PM.
keep the nines. What you're describing is a bad idea and a significant downgrade.
Those nines compared to the d15 or d17 here on a decent amp will not compare in the 50hz-90hz range and will not have the overall volume capability as the def techs.
Top Comments
It looks like an inductor near the back is subject to snapping loose.
Join The Conversation
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!
72 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Should I sell my Klipsch nines, add a bit more to my budget, and buy the D17 + D5C + D9 + AV receiver + sub (maybe I'll get the sub later) to get a full 5.1 setup?
My use case is probably 70% music and 30% movies.
I wasn't sure if the D17 + a good AV receiver would provide better sound quality for music listening when compared to the Nines.
But it seems like the Nines would offer comparable sound quality (for music) vs the D17s, and I probably won't notice much difference in sound quality
I wasn't sure if the D17 + a good AV receiver would provide better sound quality for music listening when compared to the Nines.
But it seems like the Nines would offer comparable sound quality (for music) vs the D17s, and I probably won't notice much difference in sound quality
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Should I sell my Klipsch nines, add a bit more to my budget, and buy the D17 + D5C + D9 + AV receiver + sub (maybe I'll get the sub later) to get a full 5.1 setup?
My use case is probably 70% music and 30% movies.
I have not heard those klipsch but erin does a fantastic job in his reviews. They look good but a bit hot for my tastes. I dislike powered speakers because receivers offer alot of adjustability today. I personally don't like horn loaded tweeters.
On a side note, I would not waste money on the D9. Good fronts and a good center are what matters. Most of the effects channels are going to get limited love from your sound mixes. So save your money and get cheaper surrounds/effects speakers.
Should I sell my Klipsch nines, add a bit more to my budget, and buy the D17 + D5C + D9 + AV receiver + sub (maybe I'll get the sub later) to get a full 5.1 setup?
My use case is probably 70% music and 30% movies.
- you really don't care about the extra space these speakers + subwoofer + receiver + speaker wires etc. etc. take vs just the Nines, e.g. you have at least a mid-size room
- you can really get these plus a sub, plus a good receiver+amp for a similar price (resale of Nines)
The Nines are incredible for sure. Their bass extension is down to 33hz which is amazing. The input options (HDMI etc.) are very convenient. They are a nice tight bookshelf speaker form factor. But they simply can't beat having the huge displacement (speaker size) of these towers AND a subwoofer. e.g. RSL Speedwoofer 10s goes down to ~22Hz. Thats a must for movies and a big plus for SOME types of music. I had the Fives and the Nines, and adding a subwoofer just wiped the floor either way. Then of course for movies theres the surround effect if you add even more speakers (now or down the line)OF COURSE this is just my preference. Maybe you hate bass, you do you. my 2 cents!
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Join The Conversation
Share information with the community. Please follow our Community Guidelines and be kind!