forum threadnoeffort posted Jan 21, 2026 09:08 PM
Item 1 of 2
Item 1 of 2
forum threadnoeffort posted Jan 21, 2026 09:08 PM
Back in stock at Costco. 2025 1 oz American Buffalo Gold Coin $5,099.99
$5,100
Costco Wholesale
Get Deal at RetailerGood Deal
Bad Deal
Save
Share
Leave a Comment
24 Comments
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Bought this yesterday for 5k flat.
Pro tip!
If you are selling silver and trading it to gold, like a lot of people are doing. Sell your silver to a shop for $5 or $6 back. Do not get the gold there. For a buffalo, they are 250+ premium plus maybe more if you use a CC.
Just give your silver to the shop, take the cash, and buy the gold from Costco for the CC savings and 2% reward.
Won't I have to pay tax at Costco?
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Bought this yesterday for 5k flat.
Pro tip!
If you are selling silver and trading it to gold, like a lot of people are doing. Sell your silver to a shop for $5 or $6 back. Do not get the gold there. For a buffalo, they are 250+ premium plus maybe more if you use a CC.
Just give your silver to the shop, take the cash, and buy the gold from Costco for the CC savings and 2% reward.
https://www.usmint.gov/coins/coin...alo-coins/
Won't I have to pay tax at Costco?
https://www.apmex.com/product/299...buffalo-bu
Bought this yesterday for 5k flat.
Pro tip!
If you are selling silver and trading it to gold, like a lot of people are doing. Sell your silver to a shop for $5 or $6 back. Do not get the gold there. For a buffalo, they are 250+ premium plus maybe more if you use a CC.
Just give your silver to the shop, take the cash, and buy the gold from Costco for the CC savings and 2% reward.
If you are a Executive member and use Costco CC to purchase, get 4% rewards.
https://www.monex.com/gold-prices...es7bgo
Buffalo bid is $4788 as I write this.
Buffalo bid is $4788 as I write this.
Not your quote! what the heck
Theyre $5200 to buy one at that very same link, and thats not including shipping and CC upcharge.
And, golds gone down $75 since this post. Its $5200 at your link. When this was posted, I am sure it was $5275.
None of that crap matters. The only thing is, try getting a buffalo for $5100 anywhere else. You cant.
And then factor in, 4% rewards (2% CC and 2% Costco reward) and you're talking 4750-4800 at Costco vs $5200+, probably $5300+ anywhere else.
My local coin shop is charging $5150 for buffalos, and only if you pay cash. Raw, unsealed.
They will adjust this price down soon, but this was and technically still is a great deal.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Leave a Comment