Slickdeals is community-supported.  We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
Heads up, this deal has expired. Want to create a deal alert for this item?
expired Posted by LolaBunny21 | Staff • Jun 5, 2023
expired Posted by LolaBunny21 | Staff • Jun 5, 2023

Alfani Men's Andrew Plain Toe Derby Shoes (Dark Tan or Black) $22.85 + Free Store Pickup at Macy's or FS on $25+

$23

$60

61% off
Macy's
17 Comments 12,412 Views
Visit Macy's
Good Deal
Save
Share
Deal Details
Macy's [macys.com] has Alfani Men's Andrew Plain Toe Derby Shoes (Dark Tan or Black, various sizes) on sale for $22.83. Select free store pickup where available, otherwise shipping is free on orders $25+ for Star Rewards Members (free to join [macys.com]).
Community Notes
About the Poster
Deal Details
Community Notes
About the Poster
Macy's [macys.com] has Alfani Men's Andrew Plain Toe Derby Shoes (Dark Tan or Black, various sizes) on sale for $22.83. Select free store pickup where available, otherwise shipping is free on orders $25+ for Star Rewards Members (free to join [macys.com]).

Community Voting

Deal Score
+11
Good Deal
Visit Macy's

Price Intelligence

Model: Alfani Men's Andrew Plain Toe Derbys, Created for Macy's - Dark Tan

Deal History 

Sort: Most Recent
Post Date Sold By Sale Price Activity
06/18/25Macy's$30
0
07/17/23Macy's$23 popular
6
07/09/23Macy's$23
1

Leave a Comment

Unregistered (You)

17 Comments

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Jun 5, 2023
4,809 Posts
Joined Jan 2005
Jun 5, 2023
SonofZeus
Jun 5, 2023
4,809 Posts
Synthetic upper; man-made sole.
Jun 6, 2023
2,962 Posts
Joined Feb 2011
Jun 6, 2023
ArseneWenger
Jun 6, 2023
2,962 Posts
Quote from SonofZeus :
Synthetic upper; man-made sole.
Yeah, I think that was obvious. It's a great deal for a teenager who needs a pair to wear a few times a year. Or a college student looking to get some interview shoes. They are just starter shoes.
1
Jun 6, 2023
4,809 Posts
Joined Jan 2005
Jun 6, 2023
SonofZeus
Jun 6, 2023
4,809 Posts
Quote from ArseneWenger :
Yeah, I think that was obvious. It's a great deal for a teenager who needs a pair to wear a few times a year. Or a college student looking to get some interview shoes. They are just starter shoes.
Obvious?
Not to me.
4
Jun 6, 2023
61 Posts
Joined Nov 2021
Jun 6, 2023
Legacy6452
Jun 6, 2023
61 Posts
Quote from SonofZeus :
Obvious?
Not to me.
$60 shoe at Macy's discounted to <$25, what did you honestly expect? At this price point, you're probably better off with the man-made materials than trying to force the worst "genuine leather" on it.
1
Jun 6, 2023
4,809 Posts
Joined Jan 2005

This comment has been rated as unhelpful by Slickdeals users.

Jun 6, 2023
2,962 Posts
Joined Feb 2011
Jun 6, 2023
ArseneWenger
Jun 6, 2023
2,962 Posts
Quote from SonofZeus :
It's obvious you don't know the markup on excellent shoes.
No "excellent" shoe is MSRP $60 like the one in OP. Macy's doesn't really sell high quality men's shoes and Alfani is their house brand, so that's what I meant by saying it's obvious this is a low quality shoe.

I browse this site every day and have for like 15 years. The lowest I have ever seen brand new real leather upper men's dress shoes with a Goodyear welt was probably around $99 like ten years ago. Wish i bought 5 pairs then. Nowadays I'd pull the trigger at $150 but even that's very rare.

And to be clear when I say real leather upper I mean something like full grain, not low quality "genuine" leather.
Pro
Jun 7, 2023
4,261 Posts
Joined Jun 2013
Jun 7, 2023
Walstar2
Pro
Jun 7, 2023
4,261 Posts
Quote from ArseneWenger :
No "excellent" shoe is MSRP $60 like the one in OP. Macy's doesn't really sell high quality men's shoes and Alfani is their house brand, so that's what I meant by saying it's obvious this is a low quality shoe.

I browse this site every day and have for like 15 years. The lowest I have ever seen brand new real leather upper men's dress shoes with a Goodyear welt was probably around $99 like ten years ago. Wish i bought 5 pairs then. Nowadays I'd pull the trigger at $150 but even that's very rare.

And to be clear when I say real leather upper I mean something like full grain, not low quality "genuine" leather.
Pro-tip: Use Amazon Warehouse. You buy shoes that are "used" but it just means the box was banged up or someone bought them and returned them right away. I've gotten Allen Edmonds at like 80% off MSRP that way and they arrive looking flawless.
1

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Jun 7, 2023
27 Posts
Joined Jan 2010
Jun 7, 2023
JJ0915
Jun 7, 2023
27 Posts
People, we all need to be wearing suits and shoes made from recycled plastic. Much cheaper, more environmental friendly, always wrinkle free, and the benefits go on and on. We should see 99c stores carry plastic clothing items soon Smilie
2
Jun 7, 2023
2,962 Posts
Joined Feb 2011
Jun 7, 2023
ArseneWenger
Jun 7, 2023
2,962 Posts
Quote from JJ0915 :
People, we all need to be wearing suits and shoes made from recycled plastic. Much cheaper, more environmental friendly, always wrinkle free, and the benefits go on and on. We should see 99c stores carry plastic clothing items soon
Leather is way more sustainable than a shoe made of recycled plastic. I have full grain leather upper shoes than are over 10 years and just needed a new sole once. I dont think they make plastic shoes with goodyear welts and even if they did the upper would mangle very quickly anyway. You would have to replace a plastic shoe wayyyy more often than leather.

For suits... I mean you would burn alive in a plastic suit. Polyester is hot enough and probably gives you a good idea of what "recycled plastic" would feel like.
Jun 7, 2023
767 Posts
Joined Dec 2010
Jun 7, 2023
gizmo17
Jun 7, 2023
767 Posts
I looked at those last week with my son, he needs something for his prom. I figured for 1 night, I'm sure his friends aren't into fashion to know $30 shows from $130 shoes. He laughed at it, the front is really long and kind of pointy. it did look kind of funny. 😊
Jun 7, 2023
30 Posts
Joined Nov 2007
Jun 7, 2023
jpham
Jun 7, 2023
30 Posts
Quote from SonofZeus :
It's obvious you don't know the markup on excellent shoes.
You ok?
Jun 8, 2023
2 Posts
Joined Nov 2015
Jun 8, 2023
diveshg
Jun 8, 2023
2 Posts
Quote from Walstar2 :
Pro-tip: Use Amazon Warehouse. You buy shoes that are "used" but it just means the box was banged up or someone bought them and returned them right away. I've gotten Allen Edmonds at like 80% off MSRP that way and they arrive looking flawless.
How to use amazon warehouse? Is it online or physical location?
Jun 9, 2023
9 Posts
Joined Oct 2021
Jun 9, 2023
CoolSparrow9902
Jun 9, 2023
9 Posts
Quote from ArseneWenger :
Yeah, I think that was obvious. It's a great deal for a teenager who needs a pair to wear a few times a year. Or a college student looking to get some interview shoes. They are just starter shoes.
Let teenagers use the best available. Youths need to develop good habits, feel best comfortable outfit, use best gadgets and grow up.
Synthetic leather and other junk should cost low, coz they don't replace/compete good goods, but only a temporary patch in emergency cases.
5
Jun 9, 2023
767 Posts
Joined Dec 2010
Jun 9, 2023
gizmo17
Jun 9, 2023
767 Posts
Quote from CoolSparrow9902 :
Let teenagers use the best available. Youths need to develop good habits, feel best comfortable outfit, use best gadgets and grow up.
Synthetic leather and other junk should cost low, coz they don't replace/compete good goods, but only a temporary patch in emergency cases.
Not sure if you're trolling or not.
I think youth (my youth anyway) needs to understand that $ doesn't grow in trees and that if you want nicer things, it requires hard work and maybe a sacrifice on some other purchase.

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Jun 10, 2023
9 Posts
Joined Nov 2022
Jun 10, 2023
99gabbarsingh
Jun 10, 2023
9 Posts
Dont buy if you are not sure, as Last Act items can not be returned. You will lose money for shoes you dont like.

Leave a Comment

Unregistered (You)

Popular Deals

View All

Trending Deals

View All