Slickdeals is community-supported.  We may get paid by brands for deals, including promoted items.
Forum Thread

Looking for your $.02

1,254 1,510 April 19, 2012 at 08:16 AM in Chat
Looking for opinions:

If you have a specific skill or trade do you feel it's okay with charging immediate family members for your labor/time. For example, if you are a mechanic, would you charge your son or daughter, father or mother for your labor? Or do you feel like since they're your family (and let's of course say for arguments sake that everyone likes each other and has a good relationship of course Wink) you should give your help where you're able to and leave it up to the person on the receiving end to give if they should feel inclined?

146 Comments

Your comment cannot be blank.

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Joined Jan 2011
L5: Journeyman
> bubble2 693 Posts
1,159 Reputation
vrmontstr
04-19-2012 at 11:29 PM.
04-19-2012 at 11:29 PM.
Because it is how he makes his living, you should expect to be charged. If he owned a grocery store, would you expect to get your food for free? If he owned a gas station, would you expect free gas? If he was a landscaper, would you expect him to mow your lawn for free any time you asked?

If you were a landscaper, would you want to mow his lawn for free? If you owned a grocery store, should he get his food for free? If you sell Partylite, Tupperware, MaryKay, etc, would you plan on your mother, sister, aunt, cousin, niece, getting their items at cost (therefore making you $0 for your business)? I hope you see where I'm going with this.

My uncle works on vehicles for a living. My mother (his sister) pays him if he works on her car. I asked him to work on a motorcycle for my husband and he gave me a written estimate and I wrote him a check. It is his profession and he should be paid for the work he does.

I asked my mother to pick up some items at Costco for me (since I'm not a member and I was going to visit her). When I got to her house, my items were sitting on the side table in the bedroom with a note with the cost. I wrote her a check.

I realize these are not all items in the same category, but it's really all the same principle. I am an adult with a household and finances of my own. When I was much younger, there was a time I would not have written the same thing. I was surprised to learn that she paid her brother to work on her car. I might have gone back home and not have expected to pay for the things she picked up at Costco. I'm fairly certain at some point many many years ago, my mother informed me I owed her money for something I may have assumed she would just give me. I guess it's a good thing I caught a clue, otherwise she would probably not have been willing to do me any more favors over these past many years.
Reply
Joined Jan 2010
L9: Master
> bubble2 5,725 Posts
11,004 Reputation
stitchshopgirl
04-20-2012 at 12:37 AM.
04-20-2012 at 12:37 AM.
Quote from bette13boop :
I'm sorry too, dear Rodent. Its amazing that anyone wouldn't be willing to help you out in those circumstances. hug

Wow, is it now three locked threads. Did I miss one?
A message to the community #1, then The Raddish started a message to the community #2, and of course the infamous original thread that she started for herself that she believed sparked The Raddish threads #1 & #2. I'd link, but I'm linky challenged. Roll Eyes (Sarcastic)
Reply
Last edited by stitchshopgirl April 20, 2012 at 01:19 AM.
Joined Aug 2006
proud 2b southern
> bubble2 12,358 Posts
3,683 Reputation
jenni.
04-20-2012 at 05:19 AM.
04-20-2012 at 05:19 AM.
My parents raised me, spent countless amounts of money on clothes, shelter, food, gas carrying my butt places I wanted to go, took me on vacations, bought me countless gifts, listened when I needed them to, tried their best to guide me in life, and gave me more precious memories than I can count. I owe them more than they will EVER owe me, and I would never dream of acting like they owe me something now or in the future.

Quote from Maleficent :
Clearly! I seriously couldn't believe that mess. I do WAGS, I don't even do Rite Aid, and I could totally see where you guys and Nipsy and everyone were coming from.
I just wanted to bold that. Carry on.
Reply
Last edited by jenni. April 20, 2012 at 05:20 AM.
Joined Jul 2004
Master Of Scamps
> bubble2 17,139 Posts
3,445 Reputation
Scampsters
04-20-2012 at 05:57 AM.
04-20-2012 at 05:57 AM.
Dear coupon clippers,

Please take your bitchy , snippity attitudes back to Grocery and Drugstore forum we have our own dramas in the Lounge.

Thanks

The Lounge


What i dont get is this. The supposed fact they you automatically owe your parents because they gave birth to you. They made that decision (not you) and therefore are responsible until your can go out and get a job. You dont owe them a eternal debt of gratitude for a choice or decision they made. Should you be eternily grateful if they neglected or abused. If they made you into the wonderful happy person and successful person you are today then be appreciative but you dont automatically 'owe' them.If your success and happiness came from you not wanting to be like them do you owe them caca. In retrospect it isnt a large percentage of your overall lifespan that they clothed and fed you.
Reply
Last edited by Scampsters April 20, 2012 at 06:07 AM.
Joined Jul 2007
Not. Going. Anywhere. LOL
> bubble2 5,232 Posts
9,419 Reputation
Thrifteh
04-20-2012 at 06:46 AM.
04-20-2012 at 06:46 AM.
Gratitude is an attitude. Kudos to OP's father for attempting to teach his children that we are owed nothing in this world. Too many parents (these days) swoop in and 'save the day' or loan money knowing they will forgive the loan. This kind of parenting teaches nothing more than a lack of responsibility, which perpetuates entitlement. Too many parents want to be their child(ren)'s friend rather than than a role model, teacher & disciplinararian.

I live next door to my parents and often ask them to help me with things around my house. The difference between the OP & me is that I say "Can I please hire you to do xyz?" More often than not they refuse cash payment. So I will give them a gift card to a restaurant they enjoy or their favorite beer or something else that I know they would enjoy. I also think about them at times when I don't need a 'favor'. If I'm baking something for my family or cooking a meal that I know they'd enjoy I make extra and deliver it (across the yard Teehee) to them. If I come across something in the store that I know they use and it's a pretty good deal, I pick it yo for them...just because. The point that I'm trying to make is that it is far more important to be mindful of what you bring to the relationship versus what you get from the other person(s).

The statement 'this is how your father makes a living' resonates with me. Perhaps he is taking on side jobs and by taking on your vehicle repair he might be losing out on a non familial paying customer.

OP, if your dad did the work for you pro bono, how would you show your gratitude?
Reply
Joined May 2006
Boating
> bubble2 21,228 Posts
1,397 Reputation
Piccaboo
04-20-2012 at 07:33 AM.
04-20-2012 at 07:33 AM.
Quote from BigRodent :

OK, it's late evening, so I guess it's story time. Sitting comfortably? It's not a happy story, but it's a true one.

I too had a father once. My father passed away in November 2010. I had to make an emergency flight to Poland for his funeral.

At this point, we had a recap team for Rite Aid threads and I was a member of this team. Each member had a day of the week assigned for their recap work. It was about half an hour on average, sometimes more if the week was busy.

Obviously, dealing with grief, but also with an unexpected chance to see my mother and sister, I did not want to have to worry about a Rite Aid thread while away. Not to mention I wasn't even sure about internet connection at my Mom's.

Luckily, or so I thought, we had a person who volunteered to be a back up if any of us regular recap people couldn't handle our assigned day. The person was... yes, Supergirl, the very OP of this thread. As soon as I knew of my emergency trip, and that was a few days in advance of my recap day, I sent a PM to her. Never hear a word back. (and the person in charge of the recap team can confirm I sent this message, since she was CCed on it, as was former Mod Slayers).

Supergirl, I will say it loud and clear: you, of all people, have no right to talk about compassion, kindness, helpfulness or other values like this.

No, I don't hate you. I don't hate anyone. But no, I will not forget this, ever.

So there.
I'm sorry for your loss Rodent Comfort and thank you for coming forth and telling us your story and what took place, and how "someone" whom was to back you up in a time of grief and need, failed to do so; so much for human compassion as one says.


Quote from Scampsters :
Dear coupon clippers,

Please take your bitchy , snippity attitudes back to Grocery and Drugstore forum we have our own dramas in the Lounge.

Thanks

The Lounge


What i dont get is this. The supposed fact they you automatically owe your parents because they gave birth to you. They made that decision (not you) and therefore are responsible until your can go out and get a job. You dont owe them a eternal debt of gratitude for a choice or decision they made. Should you be eternily grateful if they neglected or abused. If they made you into the wonderful happy person and successful person you are today then be appreciative but you dont automatically 'owe' them.If your success and happiness came from you not wanting to be like them do you owe them caca. In retrospect it isnt a large percentage of your overall lifespan that they clothed and fed you.
Scampster's - I invited these folks to come here and tell us about OP and their experiences with OP from the Drugstore Forum; as I was perusing that Forum, using a search and found some interesting threads and comments. I figured they, themselves would be better to speak on this, than I would. Although I did find interesting information; coming straight from people involved with OP, was much more enlightening. So don't shoe them away when another Lounger invited them into this thread. Thank you Hug2
Reply
Joined Apr 2010
L99: Potato
> bubble2 3,582 Posts
388 Reputation
Majide
04-20-2012 at 08:13 AM.
04-20-2012 at 08:13 AM.
Quote from jenni. :
My parents raised me, spent countless amounts of money on clothes, shelter, food, gas carrying my butt places I wanted to go, took me on vacations, bought me countless gifts, listened when I needed them to, tried their best to guide me in life, and gave me more precious memories than I can count. I owe them more than they will EVER owe me, and I would never dream of acting like they owe me something now or in the future.



I just wanted to bold that. Carry on.
Iagree
My sister has this whole entitlement issue, and I don't know where she gets it from. But once I started working, I started "paying them back" the best I could. It isn't much compared to what they've done for me, but I don't complain (well, frequent fast food got irritating, and I did start complaining about that, though...)

So I would often pick up dinner or groceries for all of us. I threw in a little extra cash when I would pay them for my share of some bills and my rent. Run some errands and such for them. It's always surprising when my sister or other people seem to think they shouldn't be expected to ever do things like that...

I'll never be able to repay them for all the things they have done for me, but I do what I can to try and show them I appreciate it. And yeah, my father wasn't the best in the world either. Doesn't mean I shouldn't do things for him, though.
Reply

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Joined Aug 2009
Permanent Ban
> bubble2 1,254 Posts
1,510 Reputation
Original Poster
Supergirl9801
04-20-2012 at 08:19 AM.
04-20-2012 at 08:19 AM.
Quote from Piccaboo :
...
I was being sarcastic dear...since that is what several have implied in this thread...that my logic of thinking a family member should offer THEIR LABOR as a gift of love is so far fetched. I never said I expected my father to cover the costs of my repairs.
Quote from Maleficent :
Yeah, if they were doing things for OTHER family members. Nobody said they expected to get free work/labor/favors from their family. Obviously people are going to agree that they normally wouldn't charge a family member when you leave that little gem out. Roll Eyes (Sarcastic)

You didn't have to actually say anything. Your tone and your attitude says it all.
What little gem did I leave out???
Quote from BigRodent :

OK, it's late evening, so I guess it's story time. Sitting comfortably? It's not a happy story, but it's a true one.

I too had a father once. My father passed away in November 2010. I had to make an emergency flight to Poland for his funeral.

At this point, we had a recap team for Rite Aid threads and I was a member of this team. Each member had a day of the week assigned for their recap work. It was about half an hour on average, sometimes more if the week was busy.

Obviously, dealing with grief, but also with an unexpected chance to see my mother and sister, I did not want to have to worry about a Rite Aid thread while away. Not to mention I wasn't even sure about internet connection at my Mom's.

Luckily, or so I thought, we had a person who volunteered to be a back up if any of us regular recap people couldn't handle our assigned day. The person was... yes, Supergirl, the very OP of this thread. As soon as I knew of my emergency trip, and that was a few days in advance of my recap day, I sent a PM to her. Never hear a word back. (and the person in charge of the recap team can confirm I sent this message, since she was CCed on it, as was former Mod Slayers).

Supergirl, I will say it loud and clear: you, of all people, have no right to talk about compassion, kindness, helpfulness or other values like this.

No, I don't hate you. I don't hate anyone. But no, I will not forget this, ever.

So there.
Big Rodent I am truly sorry for your loss. As for the Recap team, that was quite some time ago and honestly, I don't know what happened. There were a couple times when I filled in for people or just took over a day. As for this PM you sent me, I just don't know. Maybe I was out of town and never got it?? I would've never just ignored it though. Of course, I doubt you believe me...but I can't control that.
Quote from reg036 :
Facepalm


Popcorn
Seriously right! The slammers have followed me here..this is getting old.

Quote from Scampsters :
Dear coupon clippers,

Please take your bitchy , snippity attitudes back to Grocery and Drugstore forum we have our own dramas in the Lounge.

Thanks

The Lounge

Couldn't agree more....if I wanted slammed by haters I would've posted this question in the chat threads over there...sheesh. I wanted unbiased opinions.
Quote from Thrifteh :
Gratitude is an attitude. Kudos to OP's father for attempting to teach his children that we are owed nothing in this world. Too many parents (these days) swoop in and 'save the day' or loan money knowing they will forgive the loan. This kind of parenting teaches nothing more than a lack of responsibility, which perpetuates entitlement. Too many parents want to be their child(ren)'s friend rather than than a role model, teacher & disciplinararian.

I live next door to my parents and often ask them to help me with things around my house. The difference between the OP & me is that I say "Can I please hire you to do xyz?" More often than not they refuse cash payment. So I will give them a gift card to a restaurant they enjoy or their favorite beer or something else that I know they would enjoy. I also think about them at times when I don't need a 'favor'. If I'm baking something for my family or cooking a meal that I know they'd enjoy I make extra and deliver it (across the yard Teehee) to them. If I come across something in the store that I know they use and it's a pretty good deal, I pick it yo for them...just because. The point that I'm trying to make is that it is far more important to be mindful of what you bring to the relationship versus what you get from the other person(s).

The statement 'this is how your father makes a living' resonates with me. Perhaps he is taking on side jobs and by taking on your vehicle repair he might be losing out on a non familial paying customer.

OP, if your dad did the work for you pro bono, how would you show your gratitude?
If he didn't ask for money for his time I would MOST CERTAINLY offer something...helping him around the house, in his garden, with his business' website. There's numerous things I would do to "repay" him for his labor...because THAT'S the kind of daughter I am. I am NOT ungrateful as you all seem to think I am. This is simply a moral question that creeped into my head and I posted a simple question on here to get everyone else's opinion on it. And now a select few want to keep posting and bashing and trying to make me feel like a horrible human being.
Quote from Piccaboo :

Scampster's - I invited these folks to come here and tell us about OP and their experiences with OP from the Drugstore Forum; as I was perusing that Forum, using a search and found some interesting threads and comments. I figured they, themselves would be better to speak on this, than I would. Although I did find interesting information; coming straight from people involved with OP, was much more enlightening. So don't shoe them away when another Lounger invited them into this thread. Thank you Hug2
They were here posting before your "invite" Cool

So, flame on and continue bashing....because that's obviously what SD has turned into. How pathetically sad Frown
Reply
Joined Jan 2007
The Mistress of All Evil!
> bubble2 22,510 Posts
8,433 Reputation
Maleficent
04-20-2012 at 08:26 AM.
04-20-2012 at 08:26 AM.
Quote from Supergirl9801 :
What little gem did I leave out???
That you weren't the one offering your time/services to anyone and you want/expect your father to offer his services for free.

Quote :
If he didn't ask for money for his time I would MOST CERTAINLY offer something...helping him around the house, in his garden, with his business' website. There's numerous things I would do to "repay" him for his labor...because THAT'S the kind of daughter I am. I am NOT ungrateful as you all seem to think I am. This is simply a moral question that creeped into my head and I posted a simple question on here to get everyone else's opinion on it. And now a select few want to keep posting and bashing and trying to make me feel like a horrible human being.
Yeah, see, that's hard to believe, because you got so frustrated at him charging you a DISCOUNTED price for his services. If you were really that grateful and appreciative, you wouldn't be complaining that he's not offering his mechanic services for free.
Reply
Joined Jul 2004
Master Of Scamps
> bubble2 17,139 Posts
3,445 Reputation
Scampsters
04-20-2012 at 08:28 AM.
04-20-2012 at 08:28 AM.
Quote from Supergirl9801 :
Seriously right! The slammers have followed me here..this is getting old.

Couldn't agree more....if I wanted slammed by haters I would've posted this question in the chat threads over there...sheesh. I wanted unbiased opinions.
If he didn't ask for money for his time I would MOST CERTAINLY offer something...helping him around the house, in his garden, with his business' website. There's numerous things I would do to "repay" him for his labor...because THAT'S the kind of daughter I am. I am NOT ungrateful as you all seem to think I am. This is simply a moral question that creeped into my head and I posted a simple question on here to get everyone else's opinion on it. And now a select few want to keep posting and bashing and trying to make me feel like a horrible human being.
Frown
I wasnt defending you in all honesty but noone else but you knows what you endured growing up beside you. Maybe you were a latch key kid and had to make all your own meals . I guess everyone on SD had a Network TV familly from the 1950's and lived in towns similar to Mayberry with the white picket fences.
Isnt it a kind of entitlement for parents to assume you owe them for simplying bringing you into the world and some form of social conditioning to think that all children 'owe' a life time of endenture and servitude to their parents. When you in all honesty you know nothing of what the OP had for a life as a child.

Quote from Piccaboo :

Scampster's - I invited these folks to come here and tell us about OP and their experiences with OP from the Drugstore Forum; as I was perusing that Forum, using a search and found some interesting threads and comments. I figured they, themselves would be better to speak on this, than I would. Although I did find interesting information; coming straight from people involved with OP, was much more enlightening. So don't shoe them away when another Lounger invited them into this thread. Thank you Hug2
but really who cares you dont know the OP and if they never post in the Lounge know one here knows the OP. How do you know any of the bitchy comments made by others on that other part of SD are even valid. How do you know its not a clique like the ones in the lounge have formed that she simply isnt part of.
Reply
Last edited by Scampsters April 20, 2012 at 08:32 AM.
Joined Feb 2010
L6: Expert
> bubble2 1,002 Posts
80 Reputation
beanqueen
04-20-2012 at 08:59 AM.
04-20-2012 at 08:59 AM.
Quote from Supergirl9801 :
Thanks for the input. Unfortunately I'm going through this with my father. He is a master mechanic and I believe has always treated his kids unfairly IMO. I am certainly not trying to be greedy or ungrateful and truly appreciate his talents and would certainly offer him something for his labor. I just told like being charged for his labor. It just rubs me the wrong way and I was wondering if I was off my rocker for feeling that way. I've never asked for him to put working on my car in front of any paying customers car, and I have always operated on his schedule, yet he still insists on charging me for his time. Granted it's not the full shop rate, but I still can't help but feel it's just wrong. My mom totally disagrees with me and says this is how he makes his living and he's doing it at a discount and I'm a grown woman with a steady regular income, blah blah blah. I get all that, and that's why I think it should be at my discretion to pay him. Maybe it is being selfish. But I have kids of my own and would never charge them for something I could help with...regardless how much time it involved. Agh!
My father's a mechanic, too and he doesn't make me pay for his services but that's because I usually do most of the work. See I don't just drop the car off at his house and come back later when it's fixed. I invest time to learn what he is so knowledgeable about, so that when he's gone I'm not stuck if something goes wrong. It also means I get to bond with my father. He's teaching me something new, and I'm learning by doing it. I buy the parts and he shows me what to do and if I'm having trouble, he steps in. But it's fun for us and I would never just drop off a car and expect it to be done. If there's something that needs to be done and we can't fit it into our schedule to get it fixed then I go to a mechanic that has the time and PAY him what it costs.

But my father doesn't own a business anymore, because he didn't charge people for the labor because he was friends with them or felt sorry for them. So I think your father is perfectly justified in charging you if you're treating everything like a shop and not as bonding time where you're helping out and learning from him. That's why parents have kids, to teach them about who they are and all the things they know and incourage the kids to find themselves.

If you were doing the majority of the work, then yes I think it would be unfair for him to charge you for labor. But if he is doing it all, then you should be charged. But your argument that you'll take care of him when he's old only works if he gets to that stage, he may die of a heart attack tomorrow and you would have nothing to show for your argument of repaying him later. Invest the time now and learn his trade if you think you shouldn't have to pay...otherwise pay the man for his services, because if you didn't live close by, you'd be paying someone else.
Reply
Joined May 2006
Boating
> bubble2 21,228 Posts
1,397 Reputation
Piccaboo
04-20-2012 at 09:57 AM.
04-20-2012 at 09:57 AM.
Quote from beanqueen :
My father's a mechanic, too and he doesn't make me pay for his services but that's because I usually do most of the work. See I don't just drop the car off at his house and come back later when it's fixed. I invest time to learn what he is so knowledgeable about, so that when he's gone I'm not stuck if something goes wrong. It also means I get to bond with my father. He's teaching me something new, and I'm learning by doing it. I buy the parts and he shows me what to do and if I'm having trouble, he steps in. But it's fun for us and I would never just drop off a car and expect it to be done. If there's something that needs to be done and we can't fit it into our schedule to get it fixed then I go to a mechanic that has the time and PAY him what it costs.

But my father doesn't own a business anymore, because he didn't charge people for the labor because he was friends with them or felt sorry for them. So I think your father is perfectly justified in charging you if you're treating everything like a shop and not as bonding time where you're helping out and learning from him. That's why parents have kids, to teach them about who they are and all the things they know and incourage the kids to find themselves.

If you were doing the majority of the work, then yes I think it would be unfair for him to charge you for labor. But if he is doing it all, then you should be charged. But your argument that you'll take care of him when he's old only works if he gets to that stage, he may die of a heart attack tomorrow and you would have nothing to show for your argument of repaying him later. Invest the time now and learn his trade if you think you shouldn't have to pay...otherwise pay the man for his services, because if you didn't live close by, you'd be paying someone else.
Amen Sistah.....this is something my son learned as a life lesson...not taking the time to learn the trade of his father...now that he has moved many states away...he is "stuck" literally when it comes to car repairs. So be it...he had the opportunity given to him...but tossed it aside...his loss...not ours...you can lead a horse to water...but not make it drink. On the other hand we will also not bail him out if and when he gets in too deep as well, he has been told this. The gravy train has run dry; time to fly on your own "wings" now dear son. This is something OP needs to learn as well. The gravy train does stop at a certain point in life for "grown children". We raise you, we give you values, but do not expect parents to "keep giving"; yes they may if they wish; but it's not "entitlement".
Reply
Joined May 2006
Boating
> bubble2 21,228 Posts
1,397 Reputation
Piccaboo
04-20-2012 at 10:01 AM.
04-20-2012 at 10:01 AM.
Quote from Scampsters :
I wasnt defending you in all honesty but noone else but you knows what you endured growing up beside you. Maybe you were a latch key kid and had to make all your own meals . I guess everyone on SD had a Network TV familly from the 1950's and lived in towns similar to Mayberry with the white picket fences.
Isnt it a kind of entitlement for parents to assume you owe them for simplying bringing you into the world and some form of social conditioning to think that all children 'owe' a life time of endenture and servitude to their parents. When you in all honesty you know nothing of what the OP had for a life as a child.


but really who cares you dont know the OP and if they never post in the Lounge know one here knows the OP. How do you know any of the bitchy comments made by others on that other part of SD are even valid. How do you know its not a clique like the ones in the lounge have formed that she simply isnt part of.
I think many of the regulars here in the Lounge, are also regulars over there ----------> in the Drugstore Forum as well, and knew a lot about her as well laugh out loud Having their input, verified her A-T-T-I-T-U-D-E and I do not necessarily believe it's a clique mentality that came here and voiced their opinions. I've posted in the Drugstore Forum, with no issues; I know how to ignore those who are "rude"; same with this Forum here Coverlaugh Don't we all by now; after being here for years Woot

How are your neighbor's doing Scampster's - mine are still biaotchy Teehee Are your's Big Grin
Reply
Joined Jan 2007
The Mistress of All Evil!
> bubble2 22,510 Posts
8,433 Reputation
Maleficent
04-20-2012 at 10:06 AM.
04-20-2012 at 10:06 AM.
Quote from Piccaboo :
I think many of the regulars here in the Lounge, are also regulars over there ----------> in the Drugstore Forum as well, and knew a lot about her as well laugh out loud Having their input, verified her A-T-T-I-T-U-D-E and I do not necessarily believe it's a clique mentality that came here and voiced their opinions. I've posted in the Drugstore Forum, with no issues; I know how to ignore those who are "rude"; same with this Forum here Coverlaugh Don't we all by now; after being here for years Woot

How are your neighbor's doing Scampster's - mine are still biaotchy Teehee Are your's Big Grin
Iagree

It's her posts DIRECTLY that many have formed an opinion about, not based on what other people are saying.

From what I've seen over there, though, a lot of what they said was pretty dead on. If you don't believe it scampsters, feel free to look up OP's other posts everywhere and see for yourself.
Reply

Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.

Joined Jan 2006
L8: Grand Teacher
> bubble2 3,711 Posts
341 Reputation
FeedMeAlmonds
04-20-2012 at 10:11 AM.
04-20-2012 at 10:11 AM.
Quote from beanqueen :
My father's a mechanic, too and he doesn't make me pay for his services but that's because I usually do most of the work. See I don't just drop the car off at his house and come back later when it's fixed. I invest time to learn what he is so knowledgeable about, so that when he's gone I'm not stuck if something goes wrong. It also means I get to bond with my father. He's teaching me something new, and I'm learning by doing it. I buy the parts and he shows me what to do and if I'm having trouble, he steps in. But it's fun for us and I would never just drop off a car and expect it to be done. If there's something that needs to be done and we can't fit it into our schedule to get it fixed then I go to a mechanic that has the time and PAY him what it costs.

But my father doesn't own a business anymore, because he didn't charge people for the labor because he was friends with them or felt sorry for them. So I think your father is perfectly justified in charging you if you're treating everything like a shop and not as bonding time where you're helping out and learning from him. That's why parents have kids, to teach them about who they are and all the things they know and incourage the kids to find themselves.

If you were doing the majority of the work, then yes I think it would be unfair for him to charge you for labor. But if he is doing it all, then you should be charged. But your argument that you'll take care of him when he's old only works if he gets to that stage, he may die of a heart attack tomorrow and you would have nothing to show for your argument of repaying him later. Invest the time now and learn his trade if you think you shouldn't have to pay...otherwise pay the man for his services, because if you didn't live close by, you'd be paying someone else.
Exactly, that's why in my earlier post I stated if someone is taking their time to fix something of yours, you should be part of the process. That might mean just holding the light for the person, grabbing them parts, or even getting them water.
Reply
Page 8 of 10
Start the Conversation
 
Link Copied

The link has been copied to the clipboard.