These responses are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser.
Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser.
It is not the bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.
Opinions expressed here are the author's alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, airline or hotel chain, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities.
You have a lot to learn. I guarantee you a vast majority of people value their families regardless of expense and wouldn't have life any other way. Obviously not what you want, but to convince anybody that $1k spending is significant or that spending even more to have a family/lifestyle is a foolish decision is even less informed. Unless you are trying to live frugally for spiritual/philosophical reasons, life costs money and it would appear to me that capitalism isn't interested in making pleasant experiences cost less. Play the game or sit on the sidelines is how I would succinctly describe life as an American.
The only way your chosen way of life is smart is if your spouse makes enough to cover both the spouse's expenses plus all other human expenses in the family. Because then you'd come out ahead compared to staying single.
In America having a family is still encouraged. But if you look at the rest of the world less people are getting married or are getting married at a later age. Elon says we need to have more children or else the world economy will start to suffer.
Amex does not typically match bonuses like that, no.
Also usually the "upgrade bonus" offers aren't worth doing at all unless it's on a card you've already had before (since they let you bypass the once per lifetime restrictions)
I had a Platinum many moons ago, but closed it after not seeing the benefit at the time. I got back on board with AMEX last year with a Gold and 100K bonus points, so another 150K would've been nice, but the 100K they offered me isn't nothing to sneeze at.
The entertainment credit, additional Uber credit over Gold as well as additional lounge access over what I already have cover the increased cost of Gold vs. Platinum pretty well. And I'm pretty sure they'll downgrade you if requested when/if the perks aren't worth it anymore.
The only way your chosen way of life is smart is if your spouse makes enough to cover both the spouse's expenses plus all other human expenses in the family. Because then you'd come out ahead compared to staying single.
In America having a family is still encouraged. But if you look at the rest of the world less people are getting married or are getting married at a later age. Elon says we need to have more children or else the world economy will start to suffer.
Would like to hear more testimonials from current Amex Platinum card holders. My current credit card company just nuked my 2.5% rewards card, so I'm on the hunt for what's next. My wife might be traveling more with her career over the next decade and I'm interested in the fringe benefits of the Amex Platinum. I'm just slightly nervous they might raise the annual fee once I'm in their boat.
Generally speaking this isn't a card you keep year over year- you take the bonus and other credits (double dipping most of them) and then move on.
There's rare exceptions (folks who can get near full value from all the credits and/or folks who both fly a LOT and also have a centurion lounge at their home airport) but this won't be most people.
Quote
from johnnyreags
:
I'm not sure we wouldn't benefit more just sticking to a Costco or airline credit card to negate the annoying baggage fees which are my biggest pet peeve.
I think the first problem is you sound like you want to only ever use 1 card.
You can do that of course, but you're leaving a lot of money on the table compared to some combo of:
2-3 cards with category bonuses covering most of the your spend
1 card covering non-category spend
Churning new cards for bonuses (which is where the best value is)
Quote
from johnnyreags
:
$1k/mo spending is NOT substantial. I'm at a point in life where $2.5k/mo is a baseline.
So just to give you an idea of the math here, let's compared a 2% cash back card to churning cards over the course of a year.
2.5k/mo is $30,000 in spend.
At 2% cash back you'll net $600 in rewards.
With 30k in spend you could instead do these signup bonuses:
$500 Boa Premium card for 3k spend
$500 for US Bank AR for $4500 spend
$750 Ink Cash for $7500 spend
That's $1750 n cash--- it's potentially several thousand dollars more if used for travel.... and you've only spent through half your 30k spend so far.
You ought be able to pretty easily top 3k straight cash--- or a LOT more potentially used for travel, with 30k in spend doing new signups.
If you're not willing to churn though- at least strongly consider using more than one card.
There's a few routes for this.
If you can get platinum BoA status for example you can get a few cash cards that'll get you 5.25% cash back on gas, online spending, dining, etc- plus one that'll get you 2.625% cash on everything.
If you want travel rewards....well, again signups really are the way to go here- you can rack up north of half a million amex and chase points pretty easily/quickly....something that'll take you a lot of years of "normal" spending..... but otherwise you'll probably want to pick either the chase or amex ecosystem specifically.
This might be based on what airlines you have available to you and who they partner with... Chase points are the more valuable of the two, but might not be for you specifically. Then get the appropriate 3-4 cards in that ecosystem.
For chase for example it's the Freedom Unlimited (or ink unlimited- better signup there), Freedom Flex, Ink Cash, and then a sapphire card (probably CSR, but YMMV)
Typically airline-specific cards aren't great- again beyond signup bonuses- unless you almost exclusively fly a single airline... (in which case even the premium ones CAN be worthwhile if you fly a lot due to lounge access).
Hotel cards CAN be worth it beyond the signup bonus- as they'll often give you free nights worth more than the annual fee, or some hotel status of value... but worth it to keep, not to actually put normal spend on.
I have the 150K offer from Amex. Can someone please help me understand the benefits of applying through Schwab? I see only 100K offer there. Do they waive the annual fee etc?
You are discussing two entirely different cards, though they're both issued by Amex.
You are discussing two entirely different cards, though they're both issued by Amex.
You can get both. And the signup bonus on both.
The fees and benefits of each are also different.
Thanks so much. My wife already has the Amex Platinum Card and I am debating whether we should add another Platinum Card because of this 150K signup bonus. I don't want want to $695 fee for two cards every year.
Can we apply for both Amex Platinum and Schwab Amex Platinum cards ?
Any idea about the Morgan Stanley one which seems to offer waiving the fee?
Generally speaking this isn't a card you keep year over year- you take the bonus and other credits (double dipping most of them) and then move on.
There's rare exceptions (folks who can get near full value from all the credits and/or folks who both fly a LOT and also have a centurion lounge at their home airport) but this won't be most people.
I think the first problem is you sound like you want to only ever use 1 card.
You can do that of course, but you're leaving a lot of money on the table compared to some combo of:
2-3 cards with category bonuses covering most of the your spend
1 card covering non-category spend
Churning new cards for bonuses (which is where the best value is)
My wife is the one who won't play credit card games and thus would need 1 and ideally 1 credit card only. I can see her using a Costco credit card when shopping there, but I'm the only one of the two of us who will keep track of and play spending category games. I understand there is money to be had out there, but the amount of time it takes to churn like what you've described is just not compatible with my phase in life. We are lucky to not have to squeeze every cent out of our financial instruments. Frankly, I'm concerned what that amount of opening and closing of credit accounts does to one's report. But yes, the biggest rewards are in the signup not the usage. Everything is adopting a cellphone business model it seems.
I was just recently disappointed when our current 2.5% card benefit went away because that was "good enough" in my opinion. Now I'm looking at cards that offer nil spending rewards, or travel cards that aren't really compatible with my non-travel lifestyle. Not much time to travel while raising kids and building careers. I think I'll hold off on Amex Platinum until closer to retirement. Who knows what the annual fee will be then.
How is Schwab better? You are giving up 50k points (or $500) to pay an annual fee of $495 ($695-$200) versus $695. You'd have to hold for 3 years before coming out ahead with the Schwab card (minus the extra 10% bonus redemption you get with schwab). Not worth it for most unless you are spending heavily to get the extra 10%.
I was shown 150k back in January. Came back and checked the next day and it offered me another 25k on top of that. Plus I got a referral bonus of 30k for a friend.
My wife is the one who won't play credit card games and thus would need 1 and ideally 1 credit card only. I can see her using a Costco credit card when shopping there, but I'm the only one of the two of us who will keep track of and play spending category games. I understand there is money to be had out there, but the amount of time it takes to churn like what you've described is just not compatible with my phase in life. We are lucky to not have to squeeze every cent out of our financial instruments. Frankly, I'm concerned what that amount of opening and closing of credit accounts does to one's report.
Mostly it improves your score.
Because you tend to have so much available credit that your utilization stays very low... likewise utilization on each individual card tends to be low.
And even closed cards stay on your report for years, so as long as you keep whatever your oldest card is alive your avg. age of credit will be fine too.
The only "bad" thing churning can do to your score is on # of hard pulls--- but those are typically VERY tiny hits that go away quickly.
I've churned through dozens of cards in recent years with a score comfortably north of 800
Quote
from johnnyreags
:
But yes, the biggest rewards are in the signup not the usage. Everything is adopting a cellphone business model it seems.
I was just recently disappointed when our current 2.5% card benefit went away because that was "good enough" in my opinion. Now I'm looking at cards that offer nil spending rewards, or travel cards that aren't really compatible with my non-travel lifestyle. Not much time to travel while raising kids and building careers. I think I'll hold off on Amex Platinum until closer to retirement. Who knows what the annual fee will be then.
Though the 2.5% caps at 10k spend... if HER spend isn't higher than that (ie YOU do the other 20k a year you mention) this might work for her.
Alternatively, if you can get plat status with BoA (most easily done with 100k in an ML IRA) you can get 2.625% cash back, no annual fee, on the Unlimited Cash Rewards card.
Bonus- if you can ever talk her into holding a 2nd card, you also get 5.25% back on the 3-2-1 Cash Rewards in a category of your choice, PLUS 3.5% back on grocery and warehouse club spend ($2500/quarter cap on that)
Thanks so much. My wife already has the Amex Platinum Card and I am debating whether we should add another Platinum Card because of this 150K signup bonus. I don't want want to $695 fee for two cards every year.
Can we apply for both Amex Platinum and Schwab Amex Platinum cards ?
Any idea about the Morgan Stanley one which seems to offer waiving the fee?
You can apply for both the standard platinum and the Schwab platinum- they're treated as different cards.
There's really no reason at all to pay the $695 annual fee beyond the signup year on any platinum card though unless you're in the tiny fraction of people who actually get full value out of all the various credits/perks.
The Morgan Stanley Platinum (again- a DIFFERENT card)- you can earn an "engagement" bonus equal to the annual fee each year if you hold certain amounts of money in MS accounts-- some details here:
Unfortunately the IRS only lets you do 2 credit card payments a year- so I can only do the 2 signup bonuses with this bill, and have to pay the rest via a bank transfer.
I do get to usually knock out one more for state tax bill at least.
There are 3 tax payment processors that take credit cards, each can take 2 payments to the IRS. Doesn't that give you 6 payment opportunities?
273 Comments
Your comment cannot be blank.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
In America having a family is still encouraged. But if you look at the rest of the world less people are getting married or are getting married at a later age. Elon says we need to have more children or else the world economy will start to suffer.
Also usually the "upgrade bonus" offers aren't worth doing at all unless it's on a card you've already had before (since they let you bypass the once per lifetime restrictions)
The entertainment credit, additional Uber credit over Gold as well as additional lounge access over what I already have cover the increased cost of Gold vs. Platinum pretty well. And I'm pretty sure they'll downgrade you if requested when/if the perks aren't worth it anymore.
In America having a family is still encouraged. But if you look at the rest of the world less people are getting married or are getting married at a later age. Elon says we need to have more children or else the world economy will start to suffer.
Generally speaking this isn't a card you keep year over year- you take the bonus and other credits (double dipping most of them) and then move on.
There's rare exceptions (folks who can get near full value from all the credits and/or folks who both fly a LOT and also have a centurion lounge at their home airport) but this won't be most people.
You can do that of course, but you're leaving a lot of money on the table compared to some combo of:
2-3 cards with category bonuses covering most of the your spend
1 card covering non-category spend
Churning new cards for bonuses (which is where the best value is)
So just to give you an idea of the math here, let's compared a 2% cash back card to churning cards over the course of a year.
2.5k/mo is $30,000 in spend.
At 2% cash back you'll net $600 in rewards.
With 30k in spend you could instead do these signup bonuses:
$500 Boa Premium card for 3k spend
$500 for US Bank AR for $4500 spend
$750 Ink Cash for $7500 spend
That's $1750 n cash--- it's potentially several thousand dollars more if used for travel.... and you've only spent through half your 30k spend so far.
You ought be able to pretty easily top 3k straight cash--- or a LOT more potentially used for travel, with 30k in spend doing new signups.
If you're not willing to churn though- at least strongly consider using more than one card.
There's a few routes for this.
If you can get platinum BoA status for example you can get a few cash cards that'll get you 5.25% cash back on gas, online spending, dining, etc- plus one that'll get you 2.625% cash on everything.
If you want travel rewards....well, again signups really are the way to go here- you can rack up north of half a million amex and chase points pretty easily/quickly....something that'll take you a lot of years of "normal" spending..... but otherwise you'll probably want to pick either the chase or amex ecosystem specifically.
This might be based on what airlines you have available to you and who they partner with... Chase points are the more valuable of the two, but might not be for you specifically. Then get the appropriate 3-4 cards in that ecosystem.
For chase for example it's the Freedom Unlimited (or ink unlimited- better signup there), Freedom Flex, Ink Cash, and then a sapphire card (probably CSR, but YMMV)
Typically airline-specific cards aren't great- again beyond signup bonuses- unless you almost exclusively fly a single airline... (in which case even the premium ones CAN be worthwhile if you fly a lot due to lounge access).
Hotel cards CAN be worth it beyond the signup bonus- as they'll often give you free nights worth more than the annual fee, or some hotel status of value... but worth it to keep, not to actually put normal spend on.
You are discussing two entirely different cards, though they're both issued by Amex.
You can get both. And the signup bonus on both.
The fees and benefits of each are also different.
You can get both. And the signup bonus on both.
The fees and benefits of each are also different.
Can we apply for both Amex Platinum and Schwab Amex Platinum cards ?
Any idea about the Morgan Stanley one which seems to offer waiving the fee?
There's rare exceptions (folks who can get near full value from all the credits and/or folks who both fly a LOT and also have a centurion lounge at their home airport) but this won't be most people.
I think the first problem is you sound like you want to only ever use 1 card.
You can do that of course, but you're leaving a lot of money on the table compared to some combo of:
2-3 cards with category bonuses covering most of the your spend
1 card covering non-category spend
Churning new cards for bonuses (which is where the best value is)
I was just recently disappointed when our current 2.5% card benefit went away because that was "good enough" in my opinion. Now I'm looking at cards that offer nil spending rewards, or travel cards that aren't really compatible with my non-travel lifestyle. Not much time to travel while raising kids and building careers. I think I'll hold off on Amex Platinum until closer to retirement. Who knows what the annual fee will be then.
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
Mostly it improves your score.
Because you tend to have so much available credit that your utilization stays very low... likewise utilization on each individual card tends to be low.
And even closed cards stay on your report for years, so as long as you keep whatever your oldest card is alive your avg. age of credit will be fine too.
The only "bad" thing churning can do to your score is on # of hard pulls--- but those are typically VERY tiny hits that go away quickly.
I've churned through dozens of cards in recent years with a score comfortably north of 800
I was just recently disappointed when our current 2.5% card benefit went away because that was "good enough" in my opinion. Now I'm looking at cards that offer nil spending rewards, or travel cards that aren't really compatible with my non-travel lifestyle. Not much time to travel while raising kids and building careers. I think I'll hold off on Amex Platinum until closer to retirement. Who knows what the annual fee will be then.
As to your wife-
You can still get 2.5% cash back- no annual fee- with the Alliant card
https://www.alliantcred
Though the 2.5% caps at 10k spend... if HER spend isn't higher than that (ie YOU do the other 20k a year you mention) this might work for her.
Alternatively, if you can get plat status with BoA (most easily done with 100k in an ML IRA) you can get 2.625% cash back, no annual fee, on the Unlimited Cash Rewards card.
Bonus- if you can ever talk her into holding a 2nd card, you also get 5.25% back on the 3-2-1 Cash Rewards in a category of your choice, PLUS 3.5% back on grocery and warehouse club spend ($2500/quarter cap on that)
Can we apply for both Amex Platinum and Schwab Amex Platinum cards ?
Any idea about the Morgan Stanley one which seems to offer waiving the fee?
There's really no reason at all to pay the $695 annual fee beyond the signup year on any platinum card though unless you're in the tiny fraction of people who actually get full value out of all the various credits/perks.
The Morgan Stanley Platinum (again- a DIFFERENT card)- you can earn an "engagement" bonus equal to the annual fee each year if you hold certain amounts of money in MS accounts-- some details here:
https://frequentmiler.c
Sign up for a Slickdeals account to remove this ad.
I do get to usually knock out one more for state tax bill at least.